Sunday Editorial Roundup: Writers Weigh in on "Bully"

Sunday Editorial Roundup: Writers Weigh in on "Bully"

October 22, 2006
In an op-ed for the Provo Daily Herald, Paul McMasters of the First Amendment Center, writes:
"Video games, it appears, are replacing television, which replaced movies, which replaced the penny press, as the "new pornography" threatening the minds and morals of the nation's youth.

"For more than eight decades... experts have produced study after study and political leaders have conducted hearing after hearing, all in an effort to prove -- by repetition if not by hard evidence -- that media violence harms young people, even adults... Despite those efforts, drawing a straight line from violence in the media to violence in reality remains difficult if not impossible."

Meanwhile, in the Springfield News-Leader, columnist Michael Brothers (seen at left) weighs in:
In an effort to save young people from themselves, the powers that be at every level of American life are shooting legislative arrows at low-hanging fruit — usually the fruit of pop culture — all the while talking about giving parents 'tools' to protect their kids..."

"Attitudes (and ignorance) toward games is perhaps the worst. Nowhere in American culture is the rift between generations X and Y and older people so apparent. A new game out this week called "Bully" has generated a storm of backlash from the out-of-touch crowd. One anti-game zealot called the game a "Columbine simulator" based solely on the title..."

"When are we going to give young people an ounce of credit — around here and in this country? Why do we mistrust them to make good choices?"

Comments

Guys - this is Michael Brothers, one of the writers highlighted on this thread. Just wanted to say thanks for the positive feedback.

On a related note about profits and scare mongering... While I do think sometimes the misrepresentation of games is about scaremongering (most prominently among broadcast outlets), I really believe that it ultimately comes down to a lack of familiarity and context. (I could write a book on that one.) None of these activists or journalists play games, and it shows. From my perspective as a journalist, it's pure ignorance, not a play for profits.
Give both these folks cookies. The media needs more smart people rather than sensationalists.
Wow. Nice to see the flip side of the coin on occasions. Shame these well thought out reasonings don't sell newspapers to the masses of ignorants who demands sensationalism which the media is only too happy to deliver.
So what do you think we'll blame for corrupting america's youth?
Give these two prizes. They get it.
Nice to find two journalists who know what's what and see through all this. I especially agree with Brothers; we should give kids more credit for their intelligence. Having been around kids, I know this all too well. Ask my 2-year-old niece, who's mentally going on five. It's incredible, not to mention a little scary in a Village of the Damned kind of way. ;) At this rate, she'll be thinking like a 20-year-old by the time she's 15.
So what do you think we’ll blame for corrupting america’s youth?

Hopefully, Holodecks and virtual vision stuff.
Once a child gets the fact that the stuff on TV isn't real, he is mature enough to play most videogames, with the exception of some of the gorefest games.

That age is young for some. older for others.

My parents never gave me enough credit till I started fixing their computers and building the house network.
"Why don't we trust...."

Why, because the Boomer/Hippie mantra "Don't Trust Anyone Over 30" was neatly flipped to "UNDER 30" as soon as they all hit that magical number. Thankfully it's not universal. I know plenty of people in their fifties and sixties who are rational and reasonable about video games and media content in general: they may deplore the content, but they don't take it as a sign of the fall of the Republic.
"So what do you think we’ll blame for corrupting america’s youth?"

I saw in one article Henry Jenkins was talking about how people who grew up playing video games are coming into power slowly and that this hubub over games will die down. However, he said the new thing the older generation would not understand and lash out against could be something like the new social networking sites. I immediately thought "Crap like MySpace is for losers and sissies..." after reading it before being hit by the irony of it. Apparently I'm already old.
If I was in the same city as whoever made that article, I would make him/her a pastrami sammich, on the house.

I'm glad we got people like those two. Makes me feel more wam and squishy on the inside.
/concurs with above post.
I was warm and squishy before reading this but now I'm fresh from the oven warm, and 30% squishier.

It's nice to hear articles that talk about the issue and not try to make it this over sensationalized story based on pure opinion
Hey, I forget who the jackass is who runs this website, but can you do me a favor? Bully gives you the chance to make out with boys as well as girls. Sounds pretty gay to me, and there's nothing scarier in America than the gays. Can you contact some of the stupid American press and bring this to their attention? That'd be just fab.

Thanks, you cunt.
I immediately thought “Crap like MySpace is for losers and sissies…” after reading it before being hit by the irony of it. Apparently I’m already old.


Maybe... although MySpace and social networking sites are attacked from a different angle.

In the case of games, they are being bashed by people who have no understanding about how stuff works (a.k.a. Thompsonisms). Myspace and blog systems can be bashed by people who feel that they create people who have no understanding about how stuff works (a.k.a. AOL Syndrome).

While there is still opposition to the new media, it is based around a different concept. One is lack of education, the other is the lack of providing education. The relationship is only with the result - the rational is slightly different.
I believe that this is just a fear of technology. every time a new technology rolls around it is feared and casted out as devils work or youth corupting. As if adults are not just as corruptable. even moveable print had its issues in the beginging. Oh no an easy to read mass produced learning device stop it at any chance. In the case of videogames and any other type of digital media this is true as well. there was a student that was caught with porn on his psp and a huge backlash went out. had of it been a dirty magazine they would have just said boys will be boys type of thing and it would have moved on. but since it was on the mysteriouse electronic device. a ghost was let out. Just because its on an electronic device does not mean its evil. I know many people will respond with anger or even mild disregard but its true.
High-Five to the journalists. I dunno about rewards, but they've got the right idea.
Unfortunately, the pro-gaming view just isn't profitable at the moment. You can make money associating yourself with what the press and ignorant populace considers evil. I'm sure that at one point, we'll find something new and shiny to rant about (i.e PS3 prices o.O), but until then, lets just give these guys a spotlight :D
You can't compare the myspace bashing to the video game bashing groups it's not the same.

As pointed out prior a lot of the video game bashers do so because they don't understand the technology or the product. A lot of the myspace bashers do understand.

There are plenty of "acceptable" social sites/forums that don't cater to the bottom of the gene pool and create an environment which embraces stupidity. Selectively bashing myspace is like bashing that old custers last stand atari game. Simply for being the most glaring example of when something goes horribly wrong.
McMaster' column was printed in the Thibodaux Daily Comet Wednesday and in the Houma Courier today.
Furnace Filters...

...

Post new comment

By posting comments on this Web site you agree to abide by the Comments Policy.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This image is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions. The letters in the picture are all UPPER-CASE.
Image CAPTCHA
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.

GamePolitics ShoutBox

Posted 09/05/08 at 11:33am
Shadow Darkman Anti-Thesis of : @Zippy: *Facepalm*
Posted 09/05/08 at 10:35am
ZippyDSMlee: SticKboy:yay! *pounce cuddles luff luff* :P
Posted 09/05/08 at 10:34am
Zevorick: @Flamespeak What about Claire Redfield from Resident Evil? She's certainly not the typical "Weak woman character"
Posted 09/05/08 at 10:04am
Shadow Darkman Anti-Thesis of : Oh and Chrono Trigger FTW
Posted 09/05/08 at 10:03am
Shadow Darkman Anti-Thesis of : Wow. Someone pulled a New Anon in the 11-year-old GTA thing.
Posted 09/05/08 at 09:20am
Tarosan: That is just stupid... 'Paper Tiger' I mean really, he's begging to be arrested and criminally charged with contempt
Posted 09/05/08 at 09:16am
Tarosan: Oh god not again what is he doing now?
Posted 09/05/08 at 08:50am
sortableturnip: JT press release *snicker* http://jaablog.jaablaw.com/2008/09/03/the-new-face-of-the-broward-judiciary.aspx#comment-1340589
Posted 09/05/08 at 08:49am
Austin_Lewis: @Harmless Bunny: Ayla from Chrono Trigger
Posted 09/05/08 at 08:43am
HarmlessBunny: @ Flamespeak: How about April Ryan from the Longest Journey?
Posted 09/05/08 at 08:29am
BlackIce: @AL, KoF, GrPr: Paradise City. Full Volume.
Posted 09/05/08 at 08:28am
SticKboy: ATTN Zippy: Dude, check out the last comment in the latest BBFC vs PEGI news story; we finally agree on something!
Posted 09/05/08 at 08:20am
gamepolitics: I have only been able to play my Spore offline... also, I'm underwhelmed so far
Posted 09/05/08 at 08:11am
NovaBlack: so once again, pirates.. playing early and no hassle (DRM cracked so no benefit from it) and legit consumers hassled
Posted 09/05/08 at 08:10am
NovaBlack: @GP check out the spore furums. LOTS of ppl complaining cant activate game with Ea servers. Game was cracked Before release!!!
Posted 09/05/08 at 07:42am
Cheater87: Dead Space banned in 3 countries. http://www.destructoid.com/dead-space-release-date-pushed-up-again-outright-banned-in-three-co
Posted 09/05/08 at 06:56am
beemoh: EA 'free petrol' stunt causes controversy: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/london/7599639.stm
Posted 09/05/08 at 06:11am
Flamespeak: Jade from Beyond Good and Evil is a good one. Too bad it didn't sell too good. Here's to the sequel.
Posted 09/05/08 at 06:10am
Flamespeak: Lara Croft = Sex object, Fat Princess = making fun of overweight women, Cooking Mama = women belong in kitchen.
Posted 09/05/08 at 06:09am
Flamespeak: You can't please feminists with any representation of women in video games, it seems.
Login or register to post shouts