GameDaily: "Gamers Are Getting Screwed" by New Console Launch Bundles

GameDaily: "Gamers Are Getting Screwed" by New Console Launch Bundles

November 11, 2006
Tough talk from GameDaily editor James Brightman yesterday.

Here at GamePolitics we like tough talk, especially when it's on the money. Even more so when it's about the money.

Brightman looks at GameStop/EB's online bundle pricing for the Wii, and finds that it registers high on the gouge-o-meter: a $249 console plus $450 of bundled games and accessories adding up to $699, nearly triple the price of the Wii itself.

This is nothing new, of course. We complained about the same predatory retail practices during the Xbox 360 launch last year. Can this be legal? Apparently so. GDB spoke with Bob Freitas, an attorney who specializes in tech and anti-trust issues. Freitas said:
The most common way that something like this would be looked at would be a problem with so called tying arrangements, where someone will condition the purchase of one product on the purchase of another...

But, there have been a lot of changes in the law.. that have resulted in the anti-trust law prohibitions against tying arrangements just not being as strong as they used to be...

It's pretty tough to mount an anti-trust based attack on most forms of product bundling.

Entertainment Consumer Association (ECA) president Hal Halpin, who knows a thing or two about retailing based on his former career as head of a game retailers trade association, explained how can consumers fight back:
What our (ECA) members and what consumers should do, in my opinion, is vote with their wallets... they should go to retailers and support the retailers that don't (bundle).

From the ECA's perspective, this is actually the first time that it was raised as a potentially questionable legal matter... It's certainly worthwhile looking at because if it's of concern to our members it's of concern to us. And oftentimes it just plain out sucks...

The industry's inevitable move to digital distribution may change or even eliminate the bundling equation by the time we reach the next round of consoles.

Full disclosure dept: The ECA recently acquired GamePolitics.
Posted in

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
and thus I'm waiting until they come out with the edition that has 2 controllers :D
In all honesty I kind of like the bundles. It's the only alternative since the manufacturor's moved away from selling the console with 2 controllers and a game. Now all you can get is the console 1 controller and a demo disk. Remember the old days the NES came with 2 controllers and Mario, Sega came with Sonic and 2 controllers.

Granted forcing you to buy a bundle in an online preorder is BS it is an appealing alternative when you figure the average parent buying it as a x-mas present will probably opt for the bundle since the base system comes with nothing. The bundle makes it easier on the average ignorant consumer.

Until Sony Nintendo and Microsoft start putting out their own "bundle" this is going to remain a popular alternative.
@DHK: but isn't the point to get rid of bundles? If the stores see that bundles won't sell they they won't bother with them, or at least not force it on everyone. Sure they could just wait for sales to pick up after the bundle dissolves, but if non-bundles sell better then why wait?

Though I agree, it matter less and less as the system grows older. Then again, another thing is that as the system grows older the bundles are much more reasonable: they're no longer trying to force $300-$400 worth of merchandise on you, which is probably the main problem here. This 'deal' forces people to buy more then they might want, and in the worce cases give you no control over what games or other items you get. You could be stuck with $100+ of games and accessories you didn't want, and you have to take that or you get nothing so you're SOL either way.
Some places are making you buy things other than games, CompUSA only allows pre-orders for a PS3 if you buy a 40" HDTV from them, it's not as bad as forced bundles, but a lot of desperate people who can't wait in line will probably turn to it.

It's unfair because the system isn't a necessity so they can make you buy whatever they see fit, rather than what you actually want, if you don't like it they'll send you somewhere else.
What are some places that don't give people a choice between bundles and the individual system?
That won't really work- fighting with your wallets, that is. It's like gas- it could be five dollars a gallon and people would pay. If the bundle doesn't sell, eventually they'll just take the games out and sell the systems and games seperately and those will. These bundles will only be an issue early on when demand is high and if they sell due to that demand, hooray for the companies and if they don't, well they'll still sell the system- it'll just be after they dissolve the bundle.
By that same token, though, how is reselling or scalping the console on eBay any different? Economically, we clearly have a case where demand is far out pacing supply. Sony could have charged $1,000 a pop for the PS3 and it still would have sold out just as quickly. The eBay practices are a reactionary practice of the market to balance supply and demand. In that same vein, so too are the bundles.

Yes, both practices kind of suck on the receiving end, but we wouldn't have this problem if enough consoles existed. I guess I find solace in the fact that the first run consoles always have deplorable quality, so I can laugh at the clowns who spend $2,000 on a PS3 that breaks in two months. XD

That said, there is an eeriness to how powerful GameStop and EBGames have become. Both are very questionable companies in their own right and I don't like how the industry as a whole continues to give them exclusivity deals or doesn't crack down on their bilking of customers.
@Kyouryuu

No console maker would ever do that unfortunately. What, is someone not going to buy games for their new console? They're counting on those guaranteed game purchases with a system to start feeding back into selling the systems at a loss.

I don't think bundling is a "problem" either. If someone wants something that badly that soon, they'll pay, end of story. I still don't get why people are paying so much for PS3's on ebay or waiting in line for days. All that time and money for Resistence or NBA '07? WTF?
It was a few weeks ago when GP got pwned by ECA. search for ECA and you'll see the story. Unfortunately I couldn't find the original story about the ECA getting created, which is where I predicted the ESA would turn against the consumers and ECA would have to defend us from their MPAA/RIAA inspired ebil.

Anyways, comsumers should get a choice.
Dachande
its not happened yet,think of GP and the ECA as fair whether friends ..
--------------------
Bundles are a bad idea unless they are priced correctly after the system has been out 2 or 3 years.......................
When did GP get acquired by the ECA? Did I miss a whole week's worth of news somewhere?
"Until Sony Nintendo and Microsoft start putting out their own “bundle” this is going to remain a popular alternative."

To me, the best thing they could do is offer a coupon with every system for one free game of your choice from their library. That way, everyone goes home happy.
Where I work we do up in store bundles. A couple of games, A few recommended accessories, and the service plan. Sort of an in store "starter kit" if you will.

There is never a requirement to these though. If a person wants just the unit, they can have it. Companies that force the bundles are a joke though.
Hal's basically got it. If it's a rip-off...don't...buy...it...end of story. I strongly doubt you don't have some other game system to play while waiting to find a non-bundled version ;)
"No console maker would ever do that unfortunately. What, is someone not going to buy games for their new console? They’re counting on those guaranteed game purchases with a system to start feeding back into selling the systems at a loss."

It's very true for those companies that have an economic excuse.

Nintendo, on the other hand...

ECA IconA PUBLICATION OF THE ECA RSS IconSUBSCRIBE User LoginLOGIN / REGISTER

Crispy Gamer




       

GamePolitics ShoutBox

Posted 03/22/10 at 09:58am
ZippyDSMlee: Vlag:I mostly read on a collage level so meh.
Posted 03/22/10 at 09:50am
Valdearg: @DS: Lol, I see we were thinking the same thing in the Stabbing article..
Posted 03/22/10 at 09:45am
Valdearg: Forgive me, Zip, for saying this, but I highly doubt your ability to read and comprehend the legalese they use in the HCR bill. The meaning and effect of the various sections is hard to understand for college educated Americans, let alone anyone else.
Posted 03/22/10 at 09:39am
ZippyDSMlee: Vlag:I been reading it on and off..its a half assed feel good bill....they may be able to fix it in time but good lord its a mess but I guess thats reflected in the government itself....
Posted 03/22/10 at 09:18am
DarkSaber: So your whole objection is based around "I don't want my free handouts to be affected"
Posted 03/22/10 at 09:18am
Valdearg: @Zip: I think you probably should understand what's in the bill before you pass judgement on it..
Posted 03/22/10 at 07:37am
ZippyDSMlee: ds:ha! BY THE TIME THEY GET THIER BENFITS i WONT HAVE ANY LEFT!! :p
Posted 03/22/10 at 07:02am
DarkSaber: for it to cost YOU personally zippy, you'd have to actually be paying taxes instead of sponging benefits.
Posted 03/22/10 at 02:42am
ZippyDSMlee: Like most train wrecks it wont help people much and cost us more in the end than what we would benefit from it.....
Posted 03/22/10 at 02:37am
TBoneTony: Great to see MA go to the back bench in SA, hope that new AG is more ballanced
Posted 03/22/10 at 02:36am
TBoneTony: Oh there it is
Posted 03/22/10 at 02:36am
TBoneTony: Shout is not working for me at the moment
Posted 03/22/10 at 02:34am
SimonBob: (Would you like to rent our Green party? We're not doing anything with it.)
Posted 03/22/10 at 02:31am
SimonBob: hey america: I was watching CNN earlier, and I was thinking, you guys could use a third party.
Posted 03/21/10 at 10:12pm
Valdearg: They beat the parliamentary trick. The senate bill is officially law, pending the President's signature. Now they vote on the fixes to that bill, in the next 15 minutes or so.
Posted 03/21/10 at 10:04pm
gellymatos: Vald: No worries. I do it all the time. Trying to break the habit.
Posted 03/21/10 at 10:01pm
Valdearg: @Gelly: Sorry for jumping to conclusions, LOL.. I guess I read your text in a depressed voice in my head. :D
Posted 03/21/10 at 10:00pm
Valdearg: I'm staying up late, watching CSPAN and MSNBC, and cheering each and every democrat victory.
Posted 03/21/10 at 10:00pm
Valdearg: Yes indeedy. Even Abortion rights got gutted. Obama's going to pass an EO ensuring no federal funds are used for abortions.
Posted 03/21/10 at 09:59pm
gellymatos: Vald: Who said I didn't like it? I'd get a drink out if there wasn't anything where I am at.
Login or register to post shouts