Sunday Editorial Roundup: Op-ed Slams PS3 Buyers For "Burying Head in Electronic Sand"

Sunday Editorial Roundup: Op-ed Slams PS3 Buyers For "Burying Head in Electronic Sand"

November 19, 2006
The author of an op-ed in the Philadelphia Bulletin laments the consumer attention being lavished upon the PS3's debut.

Steve Feldman (left) hosts a local, politically-oriented radio program. He writes:
I'm glad for U.S. retailers that this product is in such great demand that people are waiting days in parking lots to buy one - I believe in and try to support a strong U.S. economy.

But I so much wanted to say (to those waiting on a PS3 line), "Aren't there more important things to think about and amass for beyond a video game?" ...I wasn't sure who to pity more: him or our nation.

Feldman goes on to cite a list of national and international problems: Iraq, Korea, etc.
And all these people care about is acquiring the latest video-game player... rather than deal with the problems I've listed, they'd rather bury their heads in this new electronic sand. The alternate universe of the video games has become reality for far too many.

Now I realize one cannot be immersed in the nation's or the world's problems 24/7/365... We all need some mental down-time. But we cannot be consumed with nonsense all the time. There is truly something wrong when buying a video-game-system is so important to someone. Would people spend two days camped out overnight to get the chance to talk with their senator? 

Comments

Would people spend two days camped out overnight to get the chance to talk with their senator?

Why? Most of them are idiots.
Are beanie babies really an artistic medium, though? Well, in a since it is, but not on the same level. I'd consider waiting in line for days over beanie babies somewhat ridiculous, but I wouldn't say the same about doing the same for a film or for a video game or for a novel. The medium is more complex, and thus has more to offer. But of course, no one person or group should be able to say for everyone which has more to offer and which doesn't, that's just my personal oppinion. So while I may laugh at people waiting in line for beanie babies or tickle me elmos, I'm certainly not going to accuse them of destroying America.
Normally I'd say "screw you" to this guy, but here he's right - these people aren't even lining up to get a really good game. They're just in it for hardware which can't do anything really by itself - getting it early is just good as a status symbol, and they could be doing more productive things with their lives.

That said, it's their lives and their rights - and just as they could be doing more productive things, they could be doing worse (like dumping toxic waste in wetlands, or something).
He seems ingorant to the fact that other world issues are borring to the general popultion and there is no will power to change them.
I understand where he is coming from, but I don't like that sort of attitude, I know campers are a bit extreme, but I think people like this can forget their own passions you could just as easily say 'Why are you spending $500 on a Sat-Nav for your car? You have a map! Would you pay that much to talk to your senator?'. 'Why are you spending $100 on that designer perfume? There are some nice ones for a fraction of the price and you could gave the rest to charity!'. 'Why are you watching that comedy show? You could be watching something about Iraq or Korea!'.
If this guy spends all of his time saving money to give to charity or for doing good, and all his time learning about current affiars with no time left for mere entertainment, I salute him, but I somehow doubt this is the case.
People have their niches and it is a disproportionately small amount who are interested in 'important' things. Films, TV, fashion, cars, photography, football, and video games are big in the minds of many people and people will do funny things for their particular interest that the rest of us would find crazy. To me, Football fans paying £60+ ($100+) for a good seat at a Chelsea match, or going all the way to Eastern Europe to see their team play FC Nobody is crazy, but I'm not going to ask them what they could be doing with their time and money, or what they'd do to speak with their MP. I'll just be happy they get something they enjoy out of the money they earn.
My time, my money, don't try and make an 'approved activites list' for me.
@Chris S.

I don't think he was criticizing people for paying $500 dollars for a PlayStation 3. What he was saying was that waiting in line for 3 straight days in 10 degree weather to buy a video game console is...a little odd.

How many people stand in front to a store for 3 straight days buying a navigation system? Perfume? A movie player? Anything else but a video game console? See what I mean?
@Fandel

Tickle me Elmo
Furby
Cabbage Patch Kids
Beanie Babies
etc.

It's not game consoles, it's the "I've got one and you don't" theme on a want. The Items you mentioned aren't in a huge demand. Get something that has been beyond hyped, throw in a mention that places will only get a handful, and even the stuff you mentioned will have lineups for days just to get one.
@Fandel.
Yeah, like I say, I do understand where he is coming from, but I do see people going to extremes for movies (Star Wars, LOTR), Harry Potter and football tickets (not so much the waiting in line but flying to Switzerland for a day just for Manchester United v Young Boys Bern, though I'm sure I saw big queues in Middlesbrough where I live for a European match).
It is a little crazy to camp out for days, but unless this guy is utterly consumed with 'important things' (and he says he isn't) I don't think he can call it the downfall of the nation. I agree that it's a bit daft, but it's their money and it's not gonna cause armageddon. I mean 'I didn't know who to pity more... him or our nation', come on, 3 days every five years doing sometihng mental?
He does say that he isn't on about important issues all the time, but you'd have a hard time saying that a PS3 camper is consumed with games 'all the time'. It takes a lot to camp out, but when they have got their PS3 safely underneath the TV, they are going to get back to normal life again with their job and friends. To me it sounds like he's making a not unreasonable, but poor assumption about people who camp out for a console.
LordLundar beat me to it. People were -trampled- in mall rushes for Beanie Babies. Back when I was in High School and taking holiday and summer jobs I worked in a seasonal store that sold Beanie Babies along with other assorted worthless junk (black velvet pictures, useless candle holders and picture frames, etc): there were at least three repeat customers who would camp outside the entrance on a weekly basis to look for new Beanie Babies. One was caught on multiple occasions trying to break into the employee/storage area to get at the boxes.

As for his assertion that people who camp out for these consoles don't care about anything else, that's a baseless assumption and should be treated as such. End of story on that point.
He's obviously never talked to anyone that would camp out for things like this. I've never camped myself (I'm far too cynical to go for hype these days), but I've known plenty of people who have (And not just for consoles; concerts and sports seem to be the main draws).

The thing is, these people go for the wait, believe it or not. It's the atmosphere, the excitement, the tension and the camaraderie of waiting with like-minded people that actually makes these sort of things fun for those involved.

The fistfights, muggings and tramplings are a different kettle of fish, however. A side-effect from always being told that if we don't have the latest we're nothing, and has very little (If anything) to do with games.
Problem is, it IS an 'exploit for personal gain' society that is forming, I've seen it in the actions of everyone from Senators, though Right Wing Lawyers and Corporations and down to people mugging other people for their game console. It's no longer about 'What you can do', it's about 'What you can take'.
Well, you've got 2 types camping out: the hardcore gamers who want the latest sand greatest now, and the vultures who see it as a source of income. When people will pay 4x the price of the thing on ebay, it's pretty easy to rationalize sitting outside for one.

A friend of mine from work managed to get his hands of 4 of them just by taking 3 days of vacation, and is expecting to clear $10K. That's a pretty good week for most people. I don't see him as being blind to the world. I see him as exploiting the supply and demand for a big payday.
Someone is oblivious to the fact that most of the campers were ebayers who stood to profit anywhere between $1000-$2000+ for waiting in line. Yeah, that might be it.
Would people spend two days camped out overnight to get the chance to talk with their senator?

Actually yes I would, provided it was some good face on face time not just a couple of questions.

Anyway that's not the point what can average gamers do about north korea or Iraq? Besides protesting, or enlisting nothing. All they can do is wacth events unfold on TV and hope for the best, and since doing that will change nothing they'd rather play video games. Also they realise that if they don't wait in line to grab a PS3 they'll either have to succumb to rediculous ebay prices or wait foir months fro them to hit store shelves again.
This guy does a helluva job making an "ass out of u and me".
@majestic
the problem is there is no way to tally who is and who isn't selling on ebay just by looking at them in line or seeing them buy a ps3, so the media assumes a majority are gamers.
"And all these people care about is acquiring the latest video-game player… rather than deal with the problems I’ve listed, they’d rather bury their heads in this new electronic sand."

Well, let's see how one can deal with each of the things listed...

"We're amidst a major upheaval in the governance of the country;"

Oh noes! Democracy worked and, for the 110th time, there's been some sort of change in our government!

"A sworn-enemy has developed nuclear weapons and has tested the means to attack us with them;"

So the gamers of the world should unite and go beat them into submission with our new PS3s!

"An even-crazier sworn enemy has the rockets to reach the United States and is on the cusp of developing nuclear weapons themselves;"

Which one is this? But in either case, the gamers should use their mad skillz and go into Iran (I'm assuming he's talking about Iran) and go fix the situation. Cuz we're gamers, and since video games are murder simulators, might as well point it in the right direction! WOOO!

"We're mired in a war against terrorists in Iraq and engaged in another front of the same war against like-minded terrorists in Afghanistan;"

See above, except change Iran to Afghanistan and Iraq. YES GAMER GEEKS! GO JOIN THE MILITARY!

"Depending on who you listen to, the economy may be about to plunge off a cliff"

So buying stuff for 500-2000 over the original retail price, you know, capitalism? is -bad- for the economy?


"Porous borders on our north and south are allowing in a stream of illegals which probably includes hardened criminals and perhaps terrorists"

Gamers! Hold hands at the boarders and don't let anyone through!

"Might they possibly ever be as obsessed to find out the true facts about, say, what the war against militant Islam is really all about?"

Who's to say they haven't? (And maybe that's part of why they're "burying their heads in this new electronic sand")
Since when was Bill O'RLY's rants copypasta?
And all people seem to care about is writing flaky little op-ed pieces in newspapers! I mean, come on! There are really important issues going on in the world! Why would you bury yourself in front of a word processor instead of camping outside your Senator's house for two days? Surely, this nonsense will get us nowhere!

...

It's called capitalism, Feldman. Why were people so excited about the PS3? The prospect of making $2,000 profits for essentially standing around in a line for a couple days. That's a lot more than I make in two days. It's not rocket science - it's a correction of the market and people willing to exploit it. Did you miss that part in Economics 101?

As for Senators, no, I would not spend two days camping in front of their house to talk to them. Aside from getting arrested for "stalking" them, if I elect them to represent my views, they should do it. Because if they don't, I'll gladly spend two seconds voting them out of power.

And, to belabor the obvious, I seriously doubt Feldman pitches a tent in front of Rick Santorum's residence every weekend.
""I’m glad for U.S. retailers that this product is in such great demand that people are waiting days in parking lots to buy one - I believe in and try to support a strong U.S. economy.

But I so much wanted to say (to those waiting on a PS3 line), “Aren’t there more important things to think about and amass for beyond a video game?” …I wasn’t sure who to pity more: him or our nation.""

And wheres your rant on people that pay thousands for clothing or people that camp out for a movie...why don't Y O U take your head out of the sand...sure the PS3 launch was a PR nightmare and damaged the industry some but then its there fault for not having popper crowed control setup and I hope some of thos retailers and sony get sue over it that will teach the they cant release such a thing without take procations...

Despite what I just said I agree buyers have their head in the sand but for all the reasons you don't understand.

1.The PS3 is focusing on Media first and games 2nd thus the over the top price tag.

2.its a game machine,not only has it gone over the top but gameplay is not worth that kind of price,the 360 was not either but has matured and at 250 used well worth the price.

3.With sonys attack on importers and tightening of thier "regions" they seem to be more interested in protecting region and movie sales more than anything else.


4.Sonys shear arrogance has pissed me off to many times and releasing this behemoth at THESE prices AND attacking importers..I have had enough of sony I will ignore them until they can show they are doing soemthign worth while in gamingdom,the 360 might be lost but its healing well from its horrid launch,the WII however is not missing a beat with graphics to keep up with current gen and true innovation unlike sonys posh and trendy fou innovation,the WII will lead the way for gaming the next 5 years.
For the people who are in line for the console itself, and not to sell it on ebay, it's not about hiding your head in the electronic sand. Deep down, it's about art and storytelling. It's about loading up a next-generation video game for the first time and engaging a long-forgotten sense of wonder. And I don't think you can completely seperate that from world events. By far the most anticipated launch game for the PS3 is Resistance: Fall of Man. I'd even go as far as to say the people standing in line for a PS3 are essentially standing in line for Resistance: Fall of Man. Judging by its website, the game clearly offers a anti-fascist message, and likely covers other important issues, in addition to its jaw-dropping interactive storytelling. The developers have constructed an entire alternate timeline for WWI and WWII to serve as the setting for an alien invasion. How is that electronic sand?
GP posters; don't defend activity you'd find laughable if it was towards another medium (like beanie babies) just because its over games. not every criticism of the industry/ the consumers is without warrant.
@ Mike Abundo

I wouldn't wait three days in a parking lot to buy a video game system, but I definitely agree with you that most senators are stupid and I wouldn't wait even three minutes to walk with a stupid senator.

I don't give a crap about politics except for when they're attacking video games for being too violent. I hate it when they do that. I totally agree though!! Why walk with a retarded senator who spends most of his time eating crumpets and drinking tea in a fancy ballroom? That's all politicians ever really do is eat doghnuts and drink tea in ballrooms. They don't do anything for the country and most of them can barely walk because they're so obese.

If I had to choose between burying my head in a PS3 or giving a crap about politics, I would choose the PS3 every time. Although I wouldn't make such a big deal about being the first one to buy a video game console, I don't care anything about politics and this guy is saying that politics are more important. Why doesn't he tell the politicians that? They obviously don't know!! If they did, they wouldn't be so retarded.

Politicians are a bunch of idiots in ties and suits with the I. Q. of a dog. Oh, and by that I don't mean to put down dogs. By dog, I mean a really stupid retarded dog. Most dogs are smarter than politicians. It really is a shame because I've been to Washington D. C. and I like the place but the people suck. All they do is mess up the country. I think you're absolutely right politicians aren't worth walking with. If you did walk with one, you'd probably be three times dumber afterward. That's just my opinion.
If all it took to get face-to-face time with my Senator was a two-day wait, I would most certainly be camping out right now. The problem is that there is no way for me to communicate with my Senator. I can write them, but I only get back form letters. I can lobby, but I'm not a known lobbyist, and I won't be let in. The only way I can get face time with prominent federal representatives is to pay thousands of dollars to sit at their table at a fund raising dinner. Even then, I have to compete with the other people at the table who are richer and more important than I am.

Also, I didn't wait for a PS3. Even if I wanted a PS3, it would not have been worth it. I pre-ordered a Wii from the NWS and waited four hours to get it because it took them that long to process the line. Thousands of Wiis and only 6 registers. Seriously.
The reality is that we all should, like Steve Feldman, be worried about the impending Naval assault of Islamic fundamentalists. We need to be working in factories, making anti-Mexican landmines as it's pretty clear dumping hoards of tax money into building the American Great Wall isn't going to stop them. We need to spend more time and money on national defense measures, and end the outdate concept of "liberty" so that we can all be safe in this homeland. If we can't find a working solution, we should be pouring money into whatever our leaders can come up with and not spend it on frivilous things like games, music, or other un-American entertainment.

Post new comment

By posting comments on this Web site you agree to abide by the Comments Policy.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This image is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions. The letters in the picture are all UPPER-CASE.
Image CAPTCHA
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.

GamePolitics ShoutBox

Posted 07/04/08 at 08:47pm
eraserheadthelynch: as much as we hate thompson hes only human and he looked happy accepting tha t award
Posted 07/04/08 at 03:38pm
Shadow Darkman Anti-Thesis of : (I know that was late but better late than never.)
Posted 07/04/08 at 03:38pm
Shadow Darkman Anti-Thesis of : Everyone! Quick! Repent! The Apocalypse approaches! Jack Thompson has been honored for his deeds! *screams and faints*
Posted 07/04/08 at 03:12pm
JustChris: The parade was a false hope for jack...an ego boost is an ego boost.
Posted 07/04/08 at 02:33pm
Silencets: Read the comments in the Editorial...JT himself in all of his asinine glory was there, as well as details on the parade
Posted 07/04/08 at 02:24pm
BlackIce: What?
Posted 07/04/08 at 01:59pm
Silencets: I still can't believe JT was in a parade...
Posted 07/04/08 at 11:01am
BlackIce: Frank, I watch that when contemplating armed robbery.
Posted 07/04/08 at 10:49am
ZippyDSM: Monolith: get a name yet? *yawns* was no on much yestersday.
Posted 07/04/08 at 10:45am
Frank: To prepare myself for the agony of writing a long reply I'm watching that clip from FOX news about the torture game 2.
Posted 07/04/08 at 10:43am
Frank: After reading Jack's reply I think that at some point today I'm gonna have to give him my own reply.
Posted 07/04/08 at 10:42am
eraserheadthelynch: i think noel was on super skunk [cannabis] himself when he made that comment
Posted 07/04/08 at 10:24am
Jack Wessels: Haha, Thompson finally replied to the edatorial. Much lulz.
Posted 07/04/08 at 10:20am
gamepolitics: heh... GP is like a shark. Can never stop.
Posted 07/04/08 at 10:19am
Belgarion89: @GP Dude, they made you work on the 4th? That's harsh!
Posted 07/04/08 at 09:24am
eraserheadthelynch: GOD BLESS AMERICA HAPPY 4TH[even though England is better
Posted 07/04/08 at 07:48am
beemoh: @ConstantNeophyte: Of course! It's not games that turn people into killers, it's kills that turn people into gamers!
Posted 07/04/08 at 05:47am
GRIZZAM PRIME: Happy 4th of July!!!
Posted 07/04/08 at 12:56am
eraserheadthelynch: @ConstantNeophyte i thought it was a parady when i read that wow thats so dumb
Posted 07/04/08 at 12:04am
Frank: I figured out something more "horrible" then the tortue game two. First read about Jack Thompson then watch Fox news.
Login or register to post shouts