2006 Annual Video Game Report Card - The Grades

November 29, 2006
2006:

Parental Involvement: INCOMPLETE
Ratings Education: B
Retailers' Policies: B
Retailers' Enforcement:
   Big Box stores: A
   Game Specialty Stores: F 
Ratings Accuracy: (not mentioned)
Arcade Survey: (not mentioned)
Industry's cumulative grade: (not mentioned)

2005:

Ratings Education: C+
Retailers' Policies: B
Retailers' Enforcement: D-
Ratings Accuracy: F
Arcade Survey: B-
Industry's 10-year cumulative grade: D+

Comments

Pretty half-assed report card if there is no interpretation as why each grade was chosen, what the criteria was, etc. The report card is not comparable to previous year's either - show some consistancy with the grades that you make up NIMF.

The scores for "Retailers' Enforcement" are pretty ass-backwards, in my experience. I kinda look like I could be 16 or 17 (but am actually 19), and I can waltz into Best Buy or CompUSA and buy any game I want without the clerks even making eye contact with me, because they'd be holding up the line. On the other hand, if I go to EBGames or Funcoland, I get asked for ID whenever I buy an M game.

Also, I find it rather humorous that "Parental Involvement" has no score yet.. judging by the amount of legislation our elected officials think games need, I'd expect a D or F.

Are we going to get to see the rest of the grades at some point??? I'm most interested to see the accuracy rating.

Whoops, should have checked the next story first! Sorry GP!

These games are appropriate for all ages and must not be given ratings like there's something wrong with underage people playing them. I played all kinds of ultra-violent games when I was underage and there was nothing wrong with that. People need to stop listening to anti-game activist turds.

Oh brother. You can tell this is a cheap ass attempt by the NIMF to save their credibilty they threw away with the clear anti-game bias in their last report card. Why do you think the category "Ratings Accuracy" isn't mentioned? Most likely it's for two PR reasons:
1: The whole "Hot Coffee" outcry has pretty much come to a complete end, so they won't look as credible using it as an example as they did last year.
2: So that parents groups like the PTA-which slammed them on the last report card-may consider taking them seriously by not doing what they have clearly been doing for a long time: Slamming game ratings for not following their arbitary moral standards and because of their blatant double-standard concerning violence and sex in games.

Another possibility is that they truly have realized that a huge segment of the U.S. population (at least 60 million, I believe?) plays games. This may have convinced them that if they want recognition in the mainstream, they need to attract support-or at least tolerance-from many gamers. As such, they may be trying the stop throwning out misinformation about games and the people who play them. If you piss of such a large percentage of the public, your credibilty tends to suffer.

Admittingly, a lot of what I said is speculation. Still, I wouldn't accept them with open arms just because they SAY they have reevaluated their position on games. What we should do is pay attention to what they say and do in the future.

Did anyone else notice on how they graded big box stores like Best Buy and places Gamestop down? Who thinks that NIMF just said that because Walmart and Best Buy are their sponsers. Not to agree with He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named, but that's a bit unfair. I've found that enforcement of the ESRB has been equal at both places.

Honestly, who didn't see this coming?

he grade for Movies and DVDs
Parental Involvement: (not mentioned)
Ratings Education: C+
Retailers’ Policies: C+
Retailers’ Enforcement:
Big Box stores:C-
Theaters : C
Ratings Accuracy: D++
Unrated DVD Survey: (not mentioned)
MPAA's cumulative grade: (not mentioned)

Halo 3 rox my sox!!1!

This website merely summarises the salient areas brought up by the report card. You ought to view the complete report card before you spew ignorant statements.

[...] Every year the National Institute of Media and Family (NIMF) produces the “Annual Video Game Report Card”. This report is often cited each year by political candidates in the issue of violence in video games and how we are protecting our children. The 27-page document was released today at an event attended by Senators Joseph Lieberman and Amy Klobuchar. To cut to the chase, the overall rating given was a “C”. It seems odd that they would get a “C”, given that last year’s report seemed to be pretty positive (though no overall grade was given last year). Granted, this has been a year of controversy. Whereas last year’s ESRB swift reaction to the Hot Cofee mod in GTA was applauded by the industry, the Manhunt 2 controversy clearly set a different tone for this year’s reaction. David Walsh, who penned the report, firmly states …While the Entertainment Software Rating Board (ESRB) has continued to educate the public about its video game rating system, several shocking incidents have inadvertently revealed dangerous loopholes in the ratings process. Simply put, some of the hard-won progress seen in previous years has been lost, and now, too many children are spending too much time playing inappropriate video games that can harm their health and development. [...]
 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Poll

Are you excited for the Xbox One?:

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
james_fudgeapparently gamers are all 14 - 21 years-olds living in basements according to her way of thinking...05/24/2013 - 11:11am
ZippyDSMleeEZK: 0_o thier video card chipset is at the very least 3 versions behind the top PC video card.......05/24/2013 - 7:38am
MechaTama31"You just wouldn't understand how my parenting preferences are more important than everybody else's freedoms."05/24/2013 - 7:37am
DorthLousI love how she plays the "I'm a parent, you're a gamer, you couldn't understand" card... I'm a parent and I find her position despicable...05/23/2013 - 4:16pm
E. Zachary KnightShe didn't address your questions because she doesn't have any answers.05/23/2013 - 3:38pm
Andrew EisenI replied to her comment. Maybe in a few weeks I'll get a reply.05/23/2013 - 3:24pm
Thomas Riordan@Andrew Eisen To what bowling alley does she go that puts sexual images in the faces of 6 year olds?05/23/2013 - 3:17pm
Andrew EisenWell, it took a month but Linda Stender finally replied to me... and didn't address a single one of my questions. http://aswlindastender.com/2013/04/23/follow-up-video-games-and-their-effect-on-children/05/23/2013 - 3:13pm
ImautobotAlso, from a tech perspective the PS4 is apparently already winning. http://bgr.com/2013/05/22/xbox-one-vs-playstation-4-specs/05/23/2013 - 3:12pm
ImautobotSony's PS4 motto should be "We play games." Microsoft's should be "We play games, when we're not rewinding your tapes."05/23/2013 - 3:11pm
Andrew EisenOh look, Dying Light was just announced For Everything But Wii U. That's 73.05/23/2013 - 2:06pm
james_fudgeZippy: they said the same thing about Cell. How did that turn out.05/23/2013 - 1:28pm
Andrew EisenNeed for Speed Rivals is coming out For Everything But Wii U - PS3, 360, PC, PS4 and Xbox One. That brings the grand total up to 72.05/23/2013 - 12:55pm
PHX Corphttp://wiiudaily.com/2013/05/microsoft-is-selling-the-wii-u-better-than-nintendo/ Wii U daily Opinion: Microsoft is selling the Wii U better than Nintendo05/23/2013 - 12:23pm
E. Zachary KnightZippy, they very well may be. But that will only last until they are released. At that time, they will be two generations behind.05/23/2013 - 11:14am
ZippyDSMleefor a good luagh, http://www.escapistmagazine.com/news/view/124288-EA-Exec-Xbox-One-and-PS4-Are-A-Generation-Ahead-Of-PC05/23/2013 - 10:55am
james_fudgeIt's about time! I need W805/23/2013 - 10:49am
MaskedPixelanteLooks like Gamepot is more willing to play ball than Square Enix. Wizardry 6+7 and 8 are available on GOG.05/23/2013 - 10:36am
DorthLousAnybody tried Hiversaire? Thoughts?05/22/2013 - 5:48pm
E. Zachary KnightNew Humble Bundle Weekly Sale. Alan Wake: https://www.humblebundle.com/weekly No Linux or Mac support. :(05/22/2013 - 1:46pm
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician