Israeli Military Withholds Security Clearance from D&D Gamers

December 6, 2006 -
Could your role-playing habit keep you from getting a government job with a security clearance?

If you live in Israel, it just might.

YNet reports that 18-year-old Israeli Defense Force (IDF) recruits who mention playing Dungeons & Dragons are automatically assigned a low security clearance. The reason? According to the Israeli army:
We have discovered that some of them are simply detached from reality... They're detached from reality and susceptible to influence.

D&D is apparently quite popular in Israel. Fans of the game are said to be aware of the negative stereotype and often attempt to keep their hobby secret.

Gamer shame, anyone?

With military service mandatory in Israel, most teens are recruited when they graduate high school. Matan, a young Israeli soldier, is a fan of "live action role-playing" (LARP) in which fans dress in costume and act out their adventures. He told YNet:
It's not a game of winners and losers, but rather entry into another world with stories and plot changes.

However an IDF official explained the official position:
One of the tests we do, either by asking soldiers directly or through information provided us, is to ask whether they take part in the game. If a soldier answers in the affirmative, he is sent to a professional for an evaluation, usually a psychologist.

These people have a tendency to be influenced by external factors which could cloud their judgment. They may be detached from reality or have a weak personality - elements which lower a person's security clearance, allowing them to serve in the army, but not in sensitive positions.

Another gamer, David, objected to the negative stereotyping:
Many people who play served in the most classified units. They are intelligent and any attempt to label them as 'weird' is incorrect and unfair.

It's unclear whether the IDF policy translates to PC or console RPGs such as World of Warcraft or Everquest II.

GP: This is not a new story. The YNet article cited originally appeared in early 2005. We just came upon it, however, and found it worthy of our readers' consideration.


To think that the Israeli military would buy into the sterotypes and use such blatant discrimination policies is disgusting. You'd think a country in such great need for able-bodied people to serve in the military would have more sense than that.

It seems that Pat Pulling resurrected from the dead...

That seems a bit odd. I havn't played D&D my self, but i would think that playing D&D couldent be that mind warping. Hearing a guy who is a little too into D&D during role call would be wicked funny though.

Guy1: soldier reporting for duity sir!
Guy2: soldier reporting for duity sir!
Guy3: Level 12 palidin reporting for duity sir! ...Whats every one laffing at? I swear on the next roll i'm gona smite you guys.

I agree with Muetank...that would be hilarious.

You know we should just fight our wars with larping. I would join the army in that case.

I'm really not that surprised about this. I had some jewish friends go over their to visit family and on the way back home at the airport the questions where all like this, "Are you Jewish?" followed by "Do you speak hebrew? Why not?" "Come here to live or Visit? Why arn't you living here?" Really had nothing to do with security they just wanted you to feel like a tool for not living there if you where jewish.

I'm sure they'd find similar results for "absent minded" people who don't play D&D if they looked. I know plenty of D&D players (even if i didn't play I got hooked into D&D video games before I learned about the pen and paper version whoops.....) and few if any are really absent minded.

What I do find interesting is that they send them to a psychologist. I wonder if the recruit can refuse to go. Best thing about it though looks like an easy way out of the military in isreal. lol. Run around the base dressed as a wizard playing acting by throwing lightning bolts then refuse to go to a shrink. =P

Sounds like they're afraid of open mindedness.

Think the IDF reads too much Jack Chick? :)

If there is such a large group of D&Ders in Israel, then maybe they should join forces, like us western gamers are?

I've seen this article before.

I thought since then the IDF adopted a "Don't ask, don't tell" policy.

I think this article is pretty outdated. I know of at least one Israelli Soldier with high security clearance that is a gamer.

I heard about this a while back, from a friend. It amazes me that this sort of stuff happens. Really, its just sad. And games like NWN or NWN2 are a lot like D&D probably even moreso than Everquest or WoW, so it makes me wonder if those sort of games are frowned upon.

Really though, these rules are just silly. I'm suprised they haven't started bumping down clearance levels because folks play video games or chat online or something, with that sort of thinking.

Maybe the top brass just watched too much "Monsters & Mazes" one weekend. Oy, what a horrible movie that was.

GM: "You approach the briefing room doors, you can hear the general and the prime minister inside, suddenly a suspicious man dressed in black with throwing knives on his belt and a blowgun in his hand is behind you."

N1/VJa: "Let me in to the briefing room"

Player: "I refuse him"

GM: "You need to roll a nineteen"

Player: (rolls).... @#$%! a six!

GM: "You allow him access into the briefing room, upon entering he blows a dart into the prime ministers neck before slicing the general into quarters with his katana"

Player: "Why did you put a ninja in isreal?..."

GM: "R0fl, stfu noob.. lrn2GM."

Hell give the an analyst position. I mean damn, if you can play old style DnD you can easily deal with the mind numbing boredom on intelligence work.

I'm kidding. Please don't roll a twenty on me.


Then again, I suppose if you're going to be weeding people out of important positions, things like hobbies and not silly measurements like psych-profiles or test scores are the best way to ensure you've got a group of highly trained individuals.

I can just see this in action...

Recruiter: So, what are your hobbies?
Soldier 1: Well, I like to program computers and brush up on physics equations. Oh, and I play the occasional game of D&D.
Recruiter: Alright, we've got an excellent opening in Cannon Fodder division. Enjoy your two week stay!
Soldier 1: Isn't my term supposed to be longer?
Recruiter: Only if you live. Next recruit? Ah yes, and what are YOUR hobbies?
Soldier 2: I pokes the dead bodies with a stick. Sometimes I use rock and chain to beat them.
Recruiter: Excellent! Welcome to the intelligence division!

This is the most absurd thing I've read all day.

Marshie, that is Priceless!

ROFL... I've played my fair share of D&D and this rule is quite ridiculous. I can only think of 1 person that destroys the image of D&D because all he does is work on D&D all day long, and talks about it all day in school. Needless to say this person has failed many highschool courses, and was expelled last year for threatning our principal by saying, "I'm going to blow up this school!"

Thankfully I never played D&D with him and the real people I played with are smart. Just because people play D&D does not mean their stupid, dumb, or slow. This is simply a misunderstanding of the game coming from people who have never played the game. I see a coincedence.
I wish our politics would play video games before they talk about how terrible they are... I bet they would even get addicted to some of the video games.

I'm going to have to agree with some of what matan said and disagree with the rest of it. He's right, LARP isn't a game of winners and losers: it's a game of losers.

"These people have a tendency to be influenced by external factors which could cloud their judgment. They may be detached from reality or have a weak personality "

Odd.... that looks more like a definition of a bigot who blindly follows stereotypes about groups of individuals.

Maybe they should do the smart thing and weed out bigots instead. I know the US military could use that type of rule. Then again, the US military might only be left with a handfull of soldiers to defend the US and no one high up in the ranks.

Of course, it might also leave us without a President too.


NW2K Software

*enemy tosses a grenade*
D&Dsoldier#1:crap gotta roll a saving throw
D&Dsoldier#2:ir cast stoneskin
D&Dsoldier#3:ill back up and get ready to rez you n00bs
*genade explodes*
*soldier 1 saving throw fail*
*soldier 2 casting failure*
D&Dsoldier 1&2:rez plz!
D&Dsoldier 3:cant ir needz limted wish to reassemble mangled body parts el oh el
D&D soldier 1:omgwtf...bbq?
D&D soldier 2:damn n00b priest
D&D soldier 3:screw joo guys imma go solo the lunch instance.

The IDF is silly >.>


Yeah, I was wondering why the Isreali military would be listening to a christian whacko.

Though psyche evaluations for all people entering the military is a good idea. (not that I think they're all crazy, but it's probably better to make sure you aren't giving a gun and combat education to a borderline psychotic)

Man, D&D players are so pathetic. Now AD&D players, that's a different story. ha HA!

Could be worse, atleast no one's trying to recruit D&D players for suicide bombing jobs because of their detached sense of reality. Then I would be mad.

...Strangely enough I remember when this was an issue at my house when I was like 10, because for some reason my parents felt that Emotional Disorder + D&D = School Shooting. Luckily that never happened, because I took up Shadowrun instead. zing!

Thanks, Jes.

On the one hand, I can understand the sort of negative stereotype D&D can carry. I understand that this fine hobby is, at times, misunderstood by certain people even without the misinformation which has been spread by detractors such as Jack Chick or Patricia Pulling.

It's just hard not to mock it when someone with a shelf full of Shadowrun, White Wolf and Rifts (screw you, Registered Trademark symbol, you have no place there!) books could scrape by this test honestly just by answering the question without elaborating with "but I play other games LIKE D&D."

Israeli raid leader: Ok, let's go guys.
Israeli soldier hits hassan nasrallah for 16 damage(glancing)
Hassan nasrallah:Yell: MUAHAHAH! This land is rightfully ours, israeli dogs! Prepare to face allah's wrath!
Israeli soldier #1: Heal plz
israeli soldier #2:Get the rockets, guys!
Hezbollah rocket hits raid group for 234 damage(AOE)
israeli soldier 3#: Omfg, the rockets are too powerful. some1 report this 2 blizz, diz shyt iz buggd
Israeli soldier 4#: Who has Aggro?
Isreali soldier 2#:Lol!
Hassan Nasrallah uses might of the hezbollah (+50 intel)
Israeli raid leader: Someone dispel tht!
Israeli soldier #1:KK
Israeli soldier 1# dispels might of the hezbollah.
Israeli soldier 2: Sweet, he's a 20%
israeli raid leader: Keep it up!
Hassan Nasrallah: ARRGHH! I've had enough with you pigs! ROCKETS, FIREE!!!
Hassan nasrallah berserks
Hezbollah rocket hits for 835(AOE)
Hezbollah Rocket hits for 947(AOE)
Hezbollah rocket hits for 246(AOE)
Israeli soldier #1: WE R GONA WHIPE!
Israeli raid leader casts lay on hands.
Israeli soldier #3 dies
Israeli 3: Shyt i'm ded lol
Hassan nasrallah dies
Israeli raid leader: YES!!!!
39 other israelis:*Various acronyms and exclamations of applauses, /dancing, etc.
Israeli raid leader:looking for group: Has downed HN!!!!!
Syria:looking for group: Ghey
Pakistan:looking for group: Don spamm lfge or i gona report
israelis on lfg: SWWEETT!
Israeli raid leader: Ok, i roll on axe.
israeli soldier #4: phat lewt lol

Being a gamer opens you mind,being open minded dose not make you god war fodder.

10 to 1 I bet they will change thier minds if they need troops.....

People seem to be misunderstanding this. They're quite happy for D&Ders to be grunts. And they're not using it as the sole criterion for rejecting people. They're just using it as an indicator for someone who may have the wrong personality. And there's a certain logic to it. You probbly want people with a very black and white attitude. You don't want someone to thin "Hey! Maybe these bad guys have a point"

But it still stinks of bad over generalising. It's like basing gender on height. You can get pretty good accuracy if you assume that anyone who's over 5'11" is male, but it's not a good way of filtering. It will have a lot of false negatives and false positives. Likewise, only requiring gamers to go for psych profile eliminates the non-gamers who may be detached from reality.


There is no logic to this. There happens to be a few results, but very likely they're no more accurate than snagging random samplings.

Gamers have suffered under a lot of false stereotypes which just don't prove true. Of course there are going to be exceptions, but these are just that: exceptions. Walk into the average RPG-dedicated store and you won't find a bunch of socially-inept people, cowering from the light. You'll find people you'd be hard-pressed to pick out of a crowd.

Sure, there's going to be some cases where the screening proves accurate and a gamer does have issues seperating fantasy from reality... but I'm willing to bet it's any other hobby which even remotely involves the imagination.

Speaking as someone who is both a long time gamer (to include D&D, World of Darkness, Rifts, GURPS, Deadlands, Shadowrun, Call of Cthulhu, Cybergen, CP2020, Blue get the idea) and a combat veteran who held a security clearance, this is rather silly. However, several people have commented that they think this is outdated information. I'm a bit caught up in final preparations, so has anyone been able to run that down?

Okay... this is really starting to become unnecessarily offensive.

To explain my previous comment:

There is a world of difference between laughing at poor decisions made by a small body of ignorant politicos, but many of these comments are crossing the line by making light of the people affected by those politicos, people, in this case, that are fighting a war and dying.


What gaming stores do you shop at, all mine have those socially-inept people cowering from the light (that might be why I shop there, I identify with em).

Because understanding the systems used in D&D requires so much less intelligence than, say, knowing how to play football....

Well, their loss at the end of the day, there's people who strive towards working together as a team, using each others strengths and weaknesses and assessing their resources to apply it towards a given situation. Of course they'll be no use to the army....

I wonder if there is any research that supports this policy. Maybe there is some co-relation between vivid imaginations and suceptibility to influence. Either that or weak minded people tend to get pulled into the game by friends for lack of anything else to do. I played because I liked it, but i've seen plenty of players who got involved just to be a part of something.


Apparently you've never spent any time at /b/ or you would realize our comments are as nice as it gets on the intarwebs.


You're likely correct, but there are still lines of decency that should be considered, no?

These games don't detatch people from reality. Gamers can function as well as anyone else, unless they have a problem somewhere else. I played for a long time and I am very much aware of the world around me.

No so much as detach as get used to it while one can get used to how sad life s one is not going to blow ones brain out from it same can be said with Porn.

What do you bet that one of those 'external factors' which 'cloud their judgement' happens to be 'morality'?

Never a good trait in a bloodthirsty murderer - errr, I mean, soldier.

*sigh* unfortunately, we have no way of knowing how Israelis think living in our comfortable, insulated, and safe nations. They are in a constant siege state, and of course a little paranoia is to be expected. Other reasons for not gaining security clearance in Israel: poor grades, political views, criminal offenses, use of prescribed psychiatric drugs. So pretty much, high level security clearance is only for people who are A) capable and B) extremely dedicated. I, personally, would just play D&D and get a low security job. 3 years of acting as a medic or providing border security sounds a bit more innocent than interogating prisoners and planning military raids. In my opinion.

buy hgh 1000...

buy hgh 1000...
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
MattsworknameWilson: how? Im still waiting for my upgrade notice07/29/2015 - 3:44am
Matthew WilsonI updated to a clean instill of windows 10.07/29/2015 - 2:36am
Mattsworknameargue that it's wrong, but then please admit it's wrong on ALL Fronts07/29/2015 - 2:06am
MattsworknameTechnoGeek: It's actually NOT, but it is a method used all across the specturm. See Rush limbaugh, MSNBC, Shawn hannity, etc etc, how many compagns have been brought up to try and shut them down by going after there advertisers. It's fine if you wanna07/29/2015 - 2:05am
Mattsworknamediscussed, while not what I liked and not the methods I wanted to see used, were , in a sense, the effort of thsoe game consuming masses to hold what they felt was supposed to be there press accountable for what many of them felt was Betrayal07/29/2015 - 2:03am
MattsworknameAs we say, the gamers are dead article set of a firestorm among the game consuming populace, who, ideally, were the intended audiance for sites like Kotaku, Polygon, Et all. As such, the turn about on them and the attacking of them, via the metods07/29/2015 - 2:03am
MattsworknameAndrew: Thats kind fo the issue at hand, Accountable is a matter of context. For a media group, it means accountable to its reader. to a goverment, to it's voters and tax payer, to a company, to it's share holders.07/29/2015 - 2:02am
Andrew EisenAnd again, you keep saying "accountable." What exactly does that mean? How is Gamasutra not accounting for the editorial it published?07/28/2015 - 11:47pm
Andrew EisenMatt - I disagree with your 9:12 and 9:16 comment. There are myriad ways to address content you don't like. And they're far easier to execute in the online space.07/28/2015 - 11:47pm
Andrew EisenMatt - Banning in the legal sense? Not that I'm aware but there have certainly been groups of gamers who have worked towards getting content they don't like removed.07/28/2015 - 11:45pm
DanJAlexander's editorial was and continues to be grossly misrepresented by her opponents. And if you don't like a site, you stop reading it - same as not watching a tv show. They get your first click, but not your second.07/28/2015 - 11:40pm
TechnogeekYes, because actively trying to convince advertisers to influence the editorial content of media is a perfectly acceptable thing to do, especially for a movement that's ostensibly about journalistic ethics.07/28/2015 - 11:02pm
Mattsworknameanother07/28/2015 - 9:16pm
Mattsworknameyou HAVE TO click on it. So they get the click revenue weather you like what it says or not. as such, the targeting of advertisers most likely seemed like a good course of action to those who wanted to hold those media groups accountable for one reason07/28/2015 - 9:16pm
MattsworknameBut, when you look at online media, it's completely different, with far more options, but far few ways to address issues that the consumers may have. In tv, you don't like what they show, you don't watch. But in order to see if you like something online07/28/2015 - 9:12pm
MattsworknameIn tv, and radio, ratings are how it works. your ratings determine how well you do and how much money you an charge.07/28/2015 - 9:02pm
Mattsworknameexpect to do so without someone wanting to hold you to task for it07/28/2015 - 9:00pm
MattsworknameMecha: I don't think anyone was asking for Editoral changes, what they wanted was to show those media groups that if they were gonna bash there own audiance, the audiance was not gonna take it sitting down. you can write what you want, but you can't07/28/2015 - 8:56pm
MattsworknameAndrew, Im asking as a practical question, Have gamers, as a group, ever asked for a game, or other item, to be banned. Im trying to see if theres any cases anyone else remembers cause I cant find or remember any.07/28/2015 - 8:55pm
Andrew EisenAs mentioned, Gamasutra isn't a gaming site, it's a game industry site. I don't feel it's changed its focus at all. Also, I don't get the sense that the majority of the people who took issue with that one opinion piece were regular readers anyway.07/28/2015 - 8:43pm

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician