Video Game Fiction Leads to Censorship Dispute at Art Institute of California

January 8, 2007 -
A censorship debate is churning at San Francisco's Art Institute of California, where a piece of student-penned fiction led to the school administration's confiscation of a small magazine which published the work. As reported by the Los Angeles Times:
(Author Simone) Mitchell's essay, titled "Homicide," centers on three African American males who address each other in vulgar street slang and go on a rape and killing spree. At the story's end, it's revealed that they are characters in a video game played by three white suburban boys.

School officials pulled the magazine, Mute/Off, from distribution within hours of its publication. When Mitchell's teacher, Robert Ovetz (left), protested, he was fired. Ovetz said:
The library was told they couldn't even have a copy for its archives. I was shocked. How could this happen at an art institute?

For his part, Mitchell, who is African-American, explained that he was trying to make a point about racial stereotypes and violence within video games:
There are so many stereotypes in games, of African Americans as thugs, for example. Video gamers are exposed to this kind of violence and offensive language all the time and need to think about what they are doing.

State Senator Leland Yee was quick to support Mitchell and Ovitz. In a press release issued on Friday, Yee said:
I’m dismayed that an institution of higher learning, especially here in San Francisco, would think it is acceptable to exercise prior restraint on a student publication. Equally appalling is that they have fired an instructor who stood up for the students and their free speech rights.

In 2006, Yee sponsored legislation which made California the first state to outlaw censorship of college newspapers, broadcast journalism, and magazines.
Allowing a school administration to censor is contrary to the democratic process and contrary to one of the main goals of higher education, fostering an environment that allows for meaningful discussion.

While Yee's legislation does not cover private schools such as the Art Institute, he vowed to look into the issue further. Yee is best known to gamers as the architect of California's contested video game law. 

Comments

Just because one is against offensive video games does not mean that one is in favor of censoring them; hence, there is no inherent hypocracy here.

@Benjee: Temple is part of the University System of PA.

Huh. I used to go there, actually. I left partially because it was a moneygrubbing corporate entity that handed out cookiecutter diplomas. Or at least that was the vibe. The game design teachers weren't bad. You actually did learn how to model, animate, etc, but they made you take a lot of BS classes too. Cartooning for a game designer? I guess, but at over $363 per credit, it just felt like they were milking me.

They they went all PC about this isnt surprising at all.

Whatever happened to the freedom of the press ?
And how is it that a ART school of all sakes needs to censor ? (And since this a PRIBATE school, they can. If this is however a public school, then it would be even worse)

Sounds like a good story.

...ruined the ended, though, haha.

It being removed is almost as funny (ironic funny) as Fahrenheit 451 being censored.

so a man for video game sensorship is agenst college censorship because he defines it as an art or soemthing? flip-flop?

It is a private institute so it is there right as publishers of the material to be able to censor it if they want - I believe the libary should be allowed to get one of the copies which are currently out in circulation.

I heard something funny about someone wanting to Censor some words in the book Fahrenheit 451...

Legally, freedom of the press only protects from the government. Being a private institution means they can basically do whatever they please.

Personally, the censoring and firing were completed in poor taste.

@Evirustheslaye,
The story is about violence in video games and their use of stereotypes. If anything this lends Lee a hand with using it for his efforts to censor video games. Then you have to ask yourself if Lee even considers games a form of art/speech (I doubt it). If he doesn't then he is not really flip-flopping.

I’m dismayed that an institution of higher learning, especially here in San Francisco, would think it is acceptable to exercise prior restraint on a student publication.

*sigh* So it's ok to exercise prior restraint on video games, but not on student publications?
-- If your wiimote goes snicker-snack, check your wrist-strap...

Leland Yee talks out of both sides of his mouth. Censorship is okay when it comes to video games, but not okay with student publications.

Unfortunately for him, the U.S. Constitution doesn't discriminate...

Actually this just highlights the point about the MAJOR problem video games have is the generation gap. Education and engagement is key to solving this problem.

This just shows what a contradictionary and two-faced asshole Leland Yee is. Free Speech only applies in certain situations (student papers) otherwise the government should play nanny state and censor what's offensive (violent video games). God i hate that guy.

So what happens if a student publication is made in the form of a violent video game? Would Yee be able to (in spin only or otherwise) reconcile his contradictory positions? Or would his brain just shut down as it went into an infinite recursive logical loop?

Just stupid...

GamePolitics.com » Blog Archive » Video Game Fiction Leads to Censorship Dispute at Art Institute of California
One win for censorship, one loss for fiction. One victory for pro video game censoring, but anti lit. censoring politician, a point the ...

That's a clever concept for a story! I wished I had read it, first. It has multiple interpretations as a commentary on racism. It makes you think. Isn't that the goal of art? To evoke a response? Maybe they should re-read their own tenets once in awhile. And for the record, it's a STORY, it's NOT REAL. Though, it happens in real life plenty.

Which of these is not like the others:

1) San Francisco 2) Art Academy 3) Higher Education 4) Censorship

It is a clever concept, and I've kind of seen it before. The most recent Twilight Zone series from I think the mid nineties, had an episode where this woman's family and house kept changing, but she was the only one who noticed, until she became a completely different person herself, and it turned out they were characters in a sims-style game.

To be fair to Senator Yee, - and correct me if I'm wrong - it appears that he believes in censorship for minors, not adults. It's not a position I agree with but I don't consider it hypocritical.

Wish they'd post a copy of the story online . . . I'm wondering why the school decided to pull it in the first place.

But oh well. It's a private institution, so the writer doesn't have a right to publish anything on campus . . . Yee is the only real funny part of this story.

This piece shouldn't have been censored. Regardless of whether it was because it was of the violence, rape or it's game-centric twist, the author has a right to be able to publish what he wishes to express.

Doesn't stop him from being completly uninformed and a puppet of third-rate ventriloquists. Rape in a video game pops it's head up again, and apparently it's something we gamers are exposed to this 'all the time'. This seems to ignore the fact that very few games even include sex in any form (I can only think of Leuisure Suit Larry, Mafia, Farenheit/Indigo Prophecy and GTA:SA off the top of my head, and certainly none of them includes rape), certainly far less than movies at any rate.

And I'm not buying this whole 'racial stereotype' thing, either. In this category we have GTA:SA, 25 to Life, Saints Row and 50 cent. I believe 50 Cent should be excused from racial stereotyping in games, because it's not the game that does so. It's 50 Cents 'franchise', which he also spreads through other media. 25 to Life and Saints Row were a cash-in on the other two games, and GTA:SA is popular, but not a common thread through all games.

Did this guy just read about GTA:SA and assume there were many games like this? That's the only way I can conclude that he he believes that racial stereotyping and rape are common occurances in gaming, when any real gamer would know that the exact opposite is true.

[...] Video Game Fiction Leads to Censorship Dispute at Art Institute of California [GamePolitics] [...]

Actually, Shaded Spriter, court rulings have basically been unanimous that even private institutions can't censor. I was an editor of the student newspaper at Temple University, which operates like a private school, and we always operated with the knowledge nothing we printed could be restricted by the university.

Freedom of speech is freedom of speech, especially under the header of "the press." Even private institutions can't suppress that.

What is really funny about this story is that the school offers a "Game Art and Design" and a "Visual Game Programming" degree.
 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
MaskedPixelanteI like Nintendo as much as the next person, they're pretty much the only company putting out the games I want to play, but that was pretty embarassing to have NNID go down due to overuse.12/25/2014 - 4:35pm
MaskedPixelanteSee? It's NOT a repeat of last year's fiasco.12/25/2014 - 4:22pm
PHX CorpLizard squad is responsible for The XBL/PSN shutdown https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QSpZvsoWvig12/25/2014 - 4:17pm
IanCOh shut up bitching about Nintendo. At least they advised people to downloading updates before the big day. Sony/MS? Not a peep.12/25/2014 - 3:50pm
MaskedPixelanteBoth PSN and Xbox Live are down. Since I'm sure Sony and Microsoft have better online support than Nintendo did last year, this isn't from "everyone logging onto their new devices all at once".12/25/2014 - 3:48pm
prh99John Romero's Christmas present, a custom Icon of Sin sculpture. http://www.pcgamer.com/john-romero-gets-the-icon-of-sin-for-christmas/12/25/2014 - 3:37am
Matthew Wilsonthe interview will be on youtube/xb1/ andriod today.12/24/2014 - 1:05pm
james_fudge1900's?12/24/2014 - 12:56pm
james_fudgeYeah we could go way way back :)12/24/2014 - 12:56pm
E. Zachary KnightCopyright law in general has been broken since at least 1976. Could be even earlier than that.12/24/2014 - 12:24pm
james_fudgeWhat he said :) They want to make it worse than it already is.12/24/2014 - 12:14pm
Papa MidnightDMCA has been broken since 1998. Good luck getitng Congress to do something about it.12/24/2014 - 11:39am
Craig R.At least they owned up to the mistake. But doesn't change the fact that DMCA is thoroughly broken.12/23/2014 - 5:23pm
MaskedPixelanteSpeaking of Dark Souls OMG I'M MAKING ACTUAL PROGRESS WTH IS THIS WHAAAAAAA12/23/2014 - 10:49am
MaskedPixelantehttp://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=144500932&postcount=740 Yup, DSFix was part of an unrelated take down, and is being resolved.12/23/2014 - 8:04am
prh99Of course had they not done such a rush on the port we wouldn't dsfix to make the game not look and play like ass. 720 internal renders aren't so hot scaled to 1080.12/23/2014 - 7:38am
Papa MidnightIt was most likely an automated tool. Happens all the time. Just another case of the broken DMCA Claim and Takedown process that puts the entirety of the burden of proof on the accused instead of the claimant.12/22/2014 - 10:09pm
Conster*applauds IanC*12/22/2014 - 7:37pm
MaskedPixelanteSounds like BN was going after an unrelated mod, and took out DSFix in the process. Probably once a counterclaim goes out, this'll all be sorted out.12/22/2014 - 7:04pm
Matthew Wilsonhttp://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=144440299&postcount=1 wtf is namco thinking.......12/22/2014 - 6:17pm
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician