GamePolitics has learned that controversial Miami attorney Jack Thompson faces a disciplinary hearing before a referee appointed by the Florida Supreme Court.
The pending judicial review follows a recent recommendation by the Florida Bar that five counts of professional misconduct against Thompson should proceed to the state's high court for action. If the charges are eventually upheld, Thompson could face disciplinary action up to and including disbarment.
Among the counts of misconduct facing Thompson, three are directly related to the activist attorney's ongoing campaign against video game violence. Those counts involve Thompson's participation as plaintiff's attorney in
Strickland vs. Sony, a high-profile lawsuit he brought against several video game industry defendants in Alabama in February, 2005.
In the suit, Thompson represented the families of two Fayette, Alabama police officers and a police dispatcher murdered by an 18-year-old
Grand Theft Auto player in 2003. At the time of his arrest for the killings, Devin Moore reportedly said, "Life is like a video game. You have to die sometime." Moore, subsequently convicted of the murders, now sits on Alabama's Death Row. Thompson was not involved in the criminal case against Moore.
As reported by
GamePolitics in November of 2005,
Alabama Circuit Court Judge James Moore (no relation to Devin), presiding over Thompson's lawsuit against Sony, Rockstar, Take Two, GameStop and Wal-Mart,
revoked Thompson's
Pro Hac Vice (visiting) license to practice law in Alabama, essentially throwing Thompson off the
Strickland case.
In upholding a pair of complaints against Thompson by Judge Moore, the Florida Bar alleges that the outspoken attorney violated numerous professional standards both before and after his
Pro Hac Vice status was revoked in Alabama. Among the misconduct alleged by the Bar is Thompson's assertion that a local Alabama attorney claimed he could fix cases before Judge Moore. Among other documents, the Bar's complaint points to a November 28, 2005 motion filed by Thompson with Judge Moore which says:
It is clear that (Judge Moore), whether the 'fixer' is the reason or whether the 'fixer' has combined with other improper influences to jettison justice in this case, must no longer preside over this case
Also cited is a July, 2006 e-mail allegedly sent by Thompson to Judge Moore, the state Bars of Alabama and Florida as well as an attorney with law firm Blank Rome, which represents the video game industry defendants in the
Strickland case. That e-mail reads:
You're the guy who wants to give (Grand Theft Auto publisher) Take-Two my scalp. You chose to believe people that you knew were thieves and liars, and now you are their useful SLAPP Bar complainant... These are your corporate criminal buddies, Judge Moore. These are the folks with whom you made your bed, the folks whom your good friend said he could fix the case.
A third count to be considered by the Supreme Court involves a complaint made by Blank Rome, Thompson's opposing counsel in the
Strickland case. Among its numerous allegations is a charge that Thompson directly contacted Take Two CEO Paul Eibeler. Included in this count is a December, 2005 message, allegedly sent from Thompson to Eibeler which reads:
Maybe the absolutely dumbest you did was hire Philadelphia's Blank Rome as your law firm of choice to represent you in courtrooms... Blank Rome, also very importantly, managed to lose all motions to dismiss our wrongful death suit in Alabama... We expect to try this case in 2006. We expect to take at that trial every single penny Take-Two currently has.
The two remaining counts alleged by the Florida Bar relate to Thompson's professional conduct in relation to his ongoing battle against the airing of shock radio in South Florida.
Asked to comment by
GamePolitics, Thompson said:
A referee is appointed and we have a trial. The Supreme Court reviews it later. The trial isn't going to happen, however. I have sued The Bar in Circuit Court. It's in far more trouble than I am.
Thompson declined GP's request to share a copy of the current lawsuit against the Florida Bar. However, an earlier federal suit filed by Thompson against the Bar in October of 2006 was dismissed by U.S. District Court Judge Paul Huck in late December. In ruling against Thompson's suit versus the Bar, Judge Huck wrote:
Thompson submits nothing beyond wild accusations of a vast conspiracy against him that the Bar is unfairly proceeding against him.
It is unclear at this point when a hearing on the Bar's allegations may take place.
Comments
Now, to those of you stating that jack will find away out of this, I doubt it.
Do not forget, this is not some circuit court, this is the Supreme, and not even jack can bully them without bringing the force of the entire legal system against him. You don't screw with the Supreme court.
Secondly, Disbarrment is not only likely, it might be the only punishment that fits the crime so to speak, at this point, he's proven that censure, warning, and other less severe forms of punishment mean nothing to him. So, at this point, the Supreme court might have no choice but to put and end to his career once and for all.
Ahh, finally, after years of advocating it, ti's finally happening, jack thompsons being dished out the same legal attacks he loved to dish out.
How's it feel Jack? Hows all that crow taste? Bitter aint it?
In what world could you have ever BEATEN us?
The Florida Supreme court is having a disciplinary hearing on Jack Thompson following a recommendation by the the Florida Bar which could lead to him loosing his license to practice law. Could this be the beginning of the end for Jack Thompson?...
It's good to remember things like these, because it builds a stronger character case against him. As much as JT has a habit of making grandly offensive proclamations about his critics - which I can say this since it's an undisputed fact, as his constant insults are childish and beneath his station - this is the proper way to deal with his self-marketing campaign. You have to paint a clear picture of who he is and how he treats people who prior to listening to him have been unprovoked.
:p
But it would be worth it.
Methinks its time to start a new Deadpool on Thompson's career - I had run one on my old blog (OLD blog), but I might just be time to start up a new one. I'll see what I can do to find a good method so I don't have to manually write up each entry.
Oh please somebody say he has tape recorded conversations where he discusses all the people who are conspiring against him in a Nixon-esque way! I would buy that before "In harm's way II: even harmer".
Let me dig up that letter real quick.
What gets me is the last line though. "Thompson submits nothing beyond wild accusations of a vast conspiracy against him that the Bar is unfairly proceeding against him."
To my knowledge, Jack's been making wild accusations of vast conspiracies for a while again a lot of folks, not just the Bar. Lets see, there's the ESRB, that Utah A.G., Tycho and Gabe, Scott from VG Cats, normal video game fans, and a lot of other folks. So... hey, this is nothing new. Haha. I hope this means we're seeing Disbarment proceedings now.
Jack Thompson is always right.
Jack Thompson is fighting evil corporations.
Therefore
Anyone who disagrees with Jack Thompson has been corrupted by the evil corporations.
What more proof do you need?
As for JT getting disbarred, I don't think it'll happen. The universe has a notorious track record for being unfair.
Still I doubt this'll be pleasant for him. I don't think courts particularly like lawyers who accuse judges of being for sale just because the judge came down against them about something.
"I’m not confident that he will be disbarred."
Nor am I. It should be a sure thing, given Thompson's often inappropriate, unprofessional, and even unethical conduct, but I'll wait to see how this plays out before getting too excited. He seems to have a knack for weaseling his way out of responsibility. Maybe this time he'll actually be held accountable.
@Brokenscope
Planning a trip to the courtroom? ;)
Bring a video camera. For, you know... posterity.
On the other hand, racking up this many complaints in what? About 2 years? Even if he's spared disbarment, this is likely going to hurt.
Ironically, I expect that if he doesn't get barred what they do to him in staid will anger him to the point that his attacks become even wilder, thus making him more likely to be disbarred in the future.
-Auto
Although, when everything crashes and breaks, we should respect him as our years-long rival, even if he fails to do so.
In the recent case of John Bruce trying to prevent Bully from being distributed, didn't the judge, at the time, state he was filing a complaint with the Florida Bar? Are those complaints to be handled seperately or will they also be handled by this "referee".
And, frankly, it seems rather appropriate for a "referee" to handle this part. Makes it truly sound like... well, a game. Though I suspect John Bruce is thinking that irony sucks right about now. :)
nightwng2000
NW2K Software
nightwng2000
NW2K Software
I knew that eventually he'd getenough complaints against him that sooner or later the Flordia Bar would be forced to deal with him. I'm surprised it took them this long.
I have to agree with Brainswarm, though. Even if he's disbarred, he won't go away completely. I can see him becoming some sort of traveling minister or something, speaking at various churches and continuing to rail against games ow whatever else in pop cutlure he deems "evil."
At least the good news would be that stripped of his license, he could no longer abuse his profession and flaunt his authority to bring forth frivolous lawsuits and otherwise use the law like a blunt instrument.
"Thompson submits nothing beyond wild accusations of a vast conspiracy against him that the Bar is unfairly proceeding against him."
I don't know where Jack gets all these crazy ideas. It has never occurred to him that his Florida Bar problems are due to his conduct. He's convinced they're just "out to get him". And Blank Rome is out to get him. And Take Two. Is he going to get disbarred? Maybe he'll get let off easy this time, but if he doesn't change his ways (and he won't) I know something will happen to him.
OWNED!
Thompson's world is about to crumble. Not sure how much of it will fall, but its very dependent on the fiasco we see here. Thompson is using his power like a child now. He is in way over his head. This entire time we've heard of him, he fits the same symptoms of a senile man. I'm no doctor, but I'm sure of it.
The media feeds him way too much. He's the hungry hungry hippo of the media.
*Chomp*
http://www.hahasong.ytmnd.com/
Let us not forget the 50's were when people let idiots like Joe McCarthy and J. Edgar Hoover run wild.
If Jack truly were trying to bring 'family values' back to America, he would start complaining about something other than Rockstar and Howard Stern. Almost every game he ever complains about is made by Rockstar. Only exceptions I can think of are Halo, Doom, and Killer7.
Maybe Jack needs to have a chat with Brent Bozell? I'm sure he'd love to censor.
But i just do not go and watch it. And i don't belittle the people who do enjoy it.
Explain to us how 'violent' video games are murder simulators. Please provide detailed examples on how it is done.
I'd also like to know what are these 'Family Values' you speak of. please provide a detailed explanation
Thank you.
If we don't need this "crap" in our countries, then we don't need violent films, or music, or literature as well, oy. I, as well as many/all of these commentators on this blog are what foolish, ignorant, money-grubbing greed hog conservatives (a.k.a. facists, Nazis and Right-Wingers) play violent video games oy. I beg to differ oy.Out of all the millions of people in America who play Doom, GTA, or Counter Strike, how many do you think went on to go killing people, huh? In fact, in 2005, a police report states that violent crimes among youths have in fact declined quite a bit. Compare that to the '50s when there were "family values", oy. I bet "family values" also means to you there would have been no civil rights movement, oy. You know what, go read the graphic novel V for Vendetta, or its movie counterpart, as well as South Park: Bigger, Longer, and Uncut and you might just learn something, oy.
Violence didn’t start with Pac Man.
"""""
Yup. If videogames affected children, our generation would all be listening to bleepy electronic music whilst eating strange 'power pills'
oh wai......
Anyways, how soon should this Supreme Court case take place anyways? I'd like to sit and wait for the demise of his crusade.
Jack made his bed, now he has to get disbarred.
IIRC, possible other punishments for Jack out of this are nothing (if he gets off), censure (a formal reprimand), or a fine.
Possibly a limited suspension, but short of permanent disbarment might be a possibility as well.
http://gamepolitics.com/comments-policy/
(I haven't been able to visit this site within the past few months, took quite some time to catch up on previous articles).
In short, Jack's verbal diarrhea comes back on him yet again. No help for you, Jack. Not yours.
Sure, the guys a jerk and a pain in the neck, but I really wouldn't want anything like that to happen to him. I suspect the Florida Bar association would see things the same way. They have a range of measures at their disposal.
failed bills and trying to get them passed into law.
As I'm sure politicians will see the disbarrment,
even if they don't see the trail of failure and bitter
resentment in Jack's wake.
But still, it wont stop him from speaking out. In fact
it may increase it, due to him having less to lose.
The worst case is that jack will still preach his anti-gamer
propaganda, but the law writing will be left to the less
inept lawyers.
I hope he doesn't get disbarred, I prefer to have an enemy
who has done nothing but hand out victories. I mean look at
all this legal precedent we have thanks to Jack. How many states
have a bitter taste in thier mouths and their wallets when they
tried video game laws? Once bitten, twice shy.
-Twixn-
Ha, "poor" Thompson, TAKE THAT!
It's good that in the end Thompson is being brought to justice. And he's brought to justice by his own group, the Florida Bar. How ironic can you get it. Let's hope, for once and for all, Thompson learns a big lesson from this whole case. You can't hide, nor run for as it is, the things you do, you take responsibility for them yourself, the consequences are up to you entirely. Feel the power of common sense and ehtics. But most of all, feel the power of Justice.
So all thats really left is the trash he spouts constantly which really has no impact at all. I mean hell if ya'll are gamers I'm sure you have come across people just as bad in gaming forums...the ragers and so on....Thats all Jack is. He tries to drive his "enemies" into a rage and then sits back and laughs. That is what he is trying to do with the Florida bar right now and that is what he was doing in that letter quoted above.
Fred Phelps was once a lawyer, and he got disbarred by his state (Kansas I believe)... but could still practice law until he was later disbarred federally.
Is this the case for Thompson as well (given that he does seem to be active in multiple states), or does disbarment mean he's done as a lawyer?
And his last case against the Bar, rejected as "wild accusations of a conspiracy theory", was filed only about 3 months ago and he's filing another one?
http://kotaku.com/gaming/harassment/the-definition-of-harassment-234268....
Close. It's 'vae victus.' For anyone that doesn't know, it means "woe to the conquered."
Jack knows he's done bad now. Nothing could be further from the truth...But, maybe if we pitched in our own experiences with this tyrant...(If you had any, that is,) that would've put him in a tad more trouble, but, who keepin count?
Jack could be Disbarred, but, if he does stay in, he won't be too active for long...They'll probably keep him on a watch list for awhile, just to make sure he doesn't split and go crusading again...For all our sakes, lets just hope he gets booted out of the BAR.
When he's disbarred, I can see him screaming in the courtroom over and over, "Forgive them for they know not what they do".
Repensum est Canicula, pure genius. Belongs along side vie victus (spelling?) from the first legacy of Kain game.
http://www.jack.thompson.justgotowned.com/
Disbar him already!
Is that the sound of Crybaby Jack's time as lawyer running out?
I hope so. I've been waiting for this...
JT had BETTER be disbarred. After taking into account his acts of immature, irresponsible behavior, I'd be vastly shocked if he still has a job after this. Good luck surviving the Florida Supreme Court, Thompson.
@RabidCheeseMonkey...
Wouldn't "Hit the Road, Jack" be a much more appropriate song? We are talking about a man named Jack, after all.
If they are smart, and jack is disbarred, then the moment the media starts quoting him as an expert, the industry will own there asses. A disbarred and disgraced attorney being refered to as an expert attacking the industry falls well within ther relm of slander/defamtion.
I think that the best thing to come out of this is that jack will have to back off to avoid disbarment. If he doesn't, it could end his career permantly ,cause the moment he's disbarred, every single case he's involved in crumbles with it. Think about it, the primary fiqure behind a legal case suddenly losing his license, it's legal death infront of a judge.
I still think he's toast, and that his license will be sent through the paper shreeder, but we'll see.
I also think disbarrment is likely because for the first time there's actually a pretty strong case against him. The main reason why he got away with it in the past was because most of the time it was an isolated incident here and there. Now we have a clear pattern of professional misconduct. Also, it's gotten to the point that there's been so many complaints against him and he's become so high-profile of late (due in part to his own machinations) that he's pretty much made an...er..."public nuiscance" of himself that can no longer be ignored. It's like I figured; given enough time and complaints, sooner or later the bar would have been forced to take major action. Now we're finally seeing it. The karmic chickens are coming home to roost.
And like others have said this will be a serious blow to his credibility (not that the Bully case already helped in a big way to that as well). In closing, "Repensum est Canicula." (Payback is a bitch)
Hmm. There seems to be an interesting split between those who think he won't be disbarred and those who think he will. I'm all for starting a pool! Who wants in?
Just wanted to do a quick post on this. According to Game Politics everyone’s favorite Florida ambulance chaser, Jack Thompson, is facing a disciplinary hearing before the Florida Supreme Court. As usual Thompson is completely delusional…
A...
NAH NAH NAH NAH
NAH NAH NAH NAH
HEY HEY HEY
GOOD BYE!!!!
It is kind of funny that he thinks that people are out to get him. Reason being - Everybody is!
____
"If at first you don't suceed, kick it and get out the instruction manual"
It would rather nice to read the word "Former attorney" when news media and such refer to Jack. Not to mention being disbarred would put some kink in Jack's credibility. I mean, most poeple get reconized as "experts" who also professionals in a certain Field, whether it be an attorney, a professor, a psycologist or what-not... That professionalism in a certain field is what gives those experts their credibility, especially in the eyes of the ignorant (politicans) who know nothing about the experts or the issues they speak of. Disbarment and not being able to call himself an attorney would greatly tarnish his credibility....
Unfortunatly, i have doubts that he will be disbarred since Jack has been able to avoid it for a rather long time, and will probably somehow slip out of this one... And Unfortunatly, Ignorant Politicians and news media don't do much background checking on their "experts" and will probably overlook the fact that he's come so damn close to being disbarred, and thus will give him the same level of credibility that they have always given to him.
Regardless, it seems Jack is having a "Backdraft" moment... "You see that flash of light in the corner of your eye? That's your career dissipation light. It just went into high gear."
"you have no chance to survive, make your time"
I love his quote about how the Florida Bar is in more trouble than he is. Because you know, when Jack Thompson sues somebody, they're going down for SURE, right? Loser.
Always thought that was funny. Considering that Penny Arcade isn't located within Seattle Jurisdiction.
thanks
JT has ruined this issue for all sides involved, and a lot of people are sick of him turning it into a circus.