Massachusetts Video Game Legislation Resembles Failed Bills From Utah, Louisiana

Massachusetts Video Game Legislation Resembles Failed Bills From Utah, Louisiana

April 11, 2007
In January, GamePolitics broke the news that the Massachusetts legislature would consider a video game violence bill in 2007.

GP also reported that the Massachusetts bill would be based on anti-game attorney Jack Thompson's unsuccessful strategy that seeks to define violent games as "harmful to minors" in the same manner as pornography.

Lynne Lyman, a spokesperson for Boston Mayor Thomas Menino (left), told GP that the Massachusetts legislation was patterned after a video game bill then under consideration in Utah. Massachusetts officials, at that time at least, felt the Utah measure had the best chance to succeed.

As events would later prove, the Utah bill failed when the legislature concluded it was not likely to withstand legal challenge. Thompson's Louisiana video game law had already beed ruled unconstitutional by a federal judge in November, 2006. 

Despite the setbacks experienced by similar measures, the Massachusetts bill, HB 1423, has now been placed before the State House. No less than 21 individuals are listed as sponsors, including Boston Mayor Thomas Menino, whose office initiated the push for the legislation. Menino was also a key figure in last year's move to ban ads for M-rated games on public transit in Massachusetts.

Comments

This guy is like Jack Thompson's Robin.

I mean reading what someone else posted how he wanted to ban something to protect the "innocent". I also think it is funny to see how they are willing to waste tax payers money by trying to push this through... I mean if the people of Boston were more informed of how this bill was declared unconstitutional in other states and is going to take their money... I am sure this guy and others would loss some votes.
he looks like a large mouth bass
Poli goats...gotta love them they eat everything in sight and when they cant eat it they blame the worlds ills on it and try to ban it to get more votes so they can eat more things..... so they can ban more things.
Sorry to double post, but for the people who wanted to see what i was talking about above, here is a link.

http://www1.whdh.com/news/articles/movies/BO48755/
[...] Massachusetts’ legislators have been offered up HB 1423, a game bill which seeks to “restrict the sale of video games wih [sic] violent content to minors.” “Harmful to minors” is defined as content describing or representing nudity, sexual conduct or sexual excitement, “so as to appeal predominantly to the prurient interest of minors.” Section four of the bill is where the civil rights lawyers are going to have a field day. It states a game is harmful to minors if it “lacks serious literary, artistic, political or scientific value for minors.” That’s about as broad as making brush strokes with Mr. Fantastic’s super powers. [...]
Living near Boston, i just saw a news report that he wants to boycott the ATHF movie. I saw it on the channel 7 news at 6. Just thought I'd put this out there. Apparently trying to sue the company that made the movie wasn't enough, now he wants to stop the movie period. Go figure.
He looks like he ate a whole sega CD console before that picture >.>
In that picture, he reminds me of some crazy old man yelling at kids to get off his lawn. Seems appropriate, actually.
Isn't this the same city that thinks electronic advertisements for a show on Cartoon Network are the same thing as terrorist bombs?

Go figure...
I still think it's kind of sad when Utah of all places remains the voice of reason when it comes to this.
Yup, it's the "Banned in Boston" days all over again. Whoppee.
We get checks from the government, and we spend it on beer! Mexican beer!
Mooninites.
On a slightly related note, I am boycotting the city of Boston and am refusing to visit there on account of him. My girlfriend wants to visit her ancestral home of Hingham, Mass, which is just outside Boston. She has no family there or anything BTW. She just wants to visit. Beyond that, there's no real reason for me to go with her. My family is telling me, "Why not? Boston's nice! It has all this history!" blah-blah-blah. I tell them, "Do you know anything about its mayor and what he's doing? (citing this story and the guerlla ads among others) As long as that jerkwad's in office, I will NEVER visit there!"
Leave it to Tom "Mumbles" Menino... I'm surprised the guy has been in office as long as he has...
Sorry to double post, but I just read the bill. It's not just similar, it seems like a stright-up copy-paste effort. They even use the Miller Test, just like all the other bills that have been shot down.

@Greg

"You don’t like Menino? Tell the people of Boston to stop voting for him. I wish you more luck than I’ve had with it."

If they won't listen to a fellow citizen of Boston, why would they listen to us? What did they tell you when you urged them to stop voting for him anyway?
*fingers* I hope Menino can see this, I'm doing it as hard as I can.
Considering that Menino's administration is afraid of Lite Brites, I wouldn't exactly take his sponsorship too seriously. The man is a Luddite.
*yawn*

I dont think the morons will ever give up after all it is for "the children"

Lets just watch and see this bill go down in flames
@aniki21

Utah managed to take note that similar stuff had failed and consequently let their bill die in committee, but that's pretty much it for legislative figures paying attention to the writing on the wall.
I don't see why this is a surprise. Menino's response to everything is a ban on something. Just google Menino Ban and see what you get.

Criminals are getting illegal guns, so Menino wants to ban the sale of legal guns to non-criminals.

People are getting fat, so Menino wants to ban the sale of trans-fats. (His main objection was how to enforce it)

People are giving themselves lung cancer, so Menino bans smoking in Boston workplaces.

College kids are getting drunk and stupid, so Menino considered a ban on late-night parties (as if anything's open late at night in Boston)

A bunch of drunken idiots rioted after the Red Sox finally won a game, so Menino tried to ban alcohol sales during the world series.

Another bunch of idiots put little electronic boxes in structurally sensitive places, so Menino wants a ban on Guerilla marketing.

Now he wants to ban video games because he thinks kids are becoming violent idiots. It's just how he does things. It allows him to look like he's doing something without actually having any responsibility for actually doing anything.


You don't like Menino? Tell the people of Boston to stop voting for him. I wish you more luck than I've had with it.
I wish politicians would follow the news. They could have known that the LA bill failed and the UT bill was pulled. If their bill is based on those, Why bother?
@e.zachary knight

teh children.
BREAKING NEWS: Politicians Beat Dead Horse in Effort to get Cheap Votes, Watchdog Groups Celebrate Attack on First Amendment.
Don't be so mean. They are trying to protect my fragile mind from the ravages of violent video games. I need the government to step in and take conrol of my life. I want government to tell me what I can and can't see. I want the government to create morals for me to follow. Why would I want to think for myself? Yep, this noble bill in a god sent miracle.

*sigh* sarcasm is so hard to pull off on the interweb...
Hearing the same story over and over again is getting annoying. Next you're going to say that JT has done something offensive to someone or is supporting a new anti-game law.
I will relish seeing this punk's bill destroyed.
*sigh*

Is this cycle ever going to stop? [i]Surely[/i] someone, at some point, is going to keep an eye on the success or failure of the other legislation that their own bill is based on?
I thought that it was Utah that figured out they had no chance of winning, and pulled it themselves. We should protest this bill... SOMEONE, GET THE LITE BRITES!
The pic is funny. He looks like "We'll get you yet gamers!"
Hey check it out! Now Masachusettes is eager to donate money to the video game industry!
Remember, these are the same guys who think Lite-Brites are dangerous to public safety.
He looks like one of those old spitting-image puppets.

"close your mouth! Think of the children!"
alright first things first as a 17 year old i occasionaly play games on my ps2, psp, and sometimes on a xbox 360 when i'm at my friends house. Some of the reasons that i'm not in trouble with my school or the law is because i play games to relieve stress. There are games that releive stress such a sudoku or crosswords in the local newspaper. Yes games are expensive for the new systems such as the playstion 3 but these games are fun and sometimes get kids involved with sports such as skateboarding, football, basketabll, soccer, and golf. SO if you plan to ban gaming forever than that is pretty much the dumbest thing that you could think of to ban
That's a Surprise!!!
Why is it when somebody commits murder or a violent crime, they blame it on video games. Video Games are virtual reality, you won't see a italian plumber running around consuming mushrooms and jumping on turtles in real life would you, NO, so why would someone believe that a game is real. Damn they even blamed Columbine on a video game. Politicians suck and they believe that video games are causing kids to become violent. Actually, it is other kids that make kids violent, by bullying them, and driving them to cause violence.Violent video games don't cause violent kids, they have free will, everyone does, at least I hope everyone does. What these politicians are doing is trying to ban our freedoms as humans. So as for tuna face up there, who wants to be re-elected, he can just talk all he wants and stop telling parents what to do with there kids.
F***ING POLITICIANS, I'M A MINOR!!!

F***ING POLITICIANS DAMN THEM!!! As a minor I feel... insulted, degrated, and disrespected!!! Banning violent videogames is one of the stupidest things that anyone could do!!! Videogames are one of the fastest growing industries in the U.S.A. and stopping the sell of violent videogames would cause an economic recession, not a big one but even a small recession right now would be a very bad thing... i.e. the war and the gas prices have already caused a 30 year low in the American economy!!!

Shard is right

Video Games are a staple of our economy, and banning violent video games would just be the tip of the iceberg, next they would ban movies with violence, then violent music, the politicians are trying to take away our rights as americans by taking away our free will and by doing that they are causing people of other nationalities to call americans in general dumbasses because our politicians don't want violence or sex in games, movies, or music. Whatever happened to the rating system that video games have. Parents should know that their six year old doesn't need to be playing Grand Theft Auto or God of War because those games are rated M for MATURE!!! When I have kids I will tell them you can't play that game because it is too mature for them, and not be a dumbass and listen to my kid say it is a good game when I already know the ratings system, I like the video game rating system it works its just the parents who don't pay attention to the ratings system, that cause most of the problems. Stores need to ask for I.D. when someone wants to buy a M rated game. Some games are rated AO because they are too violent or have too much sexual content for kids, or minors who are not mature enough, to even think about playing them. Parents need to pay attention to what their kids are doing, because the politicians believe that the games are to blame, but it is the parents themselves who are to blame for kids becoming violent, well maybe if the kids respected their elders, they wouldn't be little assholes and try to kill things!!!!

Thank You!!

Thank you for listening to my raving about the stupid shit that politicians try to feed parents who need to show some backbone to their kids instead of giving them time out. If I disrespected my parents they slap the shit out of me for disrespecting them, time out for them meant taking a break from showing authority.

Thank You again.

Hello again

OK so these politicians believe that video games cause violence in kids, but what about the families that can't afford to have video games because they want to buy food. Tell me that video games caused the poor kid who never played a video game in his life to kill his best friend.

GamePolitics ShoutBox

Posted 10/07/08 at 01:32pm
DarkSaber: lol, guess it was a matter of time! They even madea Doom one! But you can't beat a game of FRAG!
Posted 10/07/08 at 01:30pm
gamepolitics: Halo board game showed up here today? Didn't even know there was one.
Posted 10/07/08 at 01:30pm
gamepolitics: u mean the ones in the countdown thread? they are verbatim...
Posted 10/07/08 at 12:12pm
sortableturnip: GP, can you post JT's emails into the JT thread over at the eca forums...I love a good laugh :D
Posted 10/07/08 at 11:31am
E. Zachary Knight: No, the link is the same
Posted 10/07/08 at 11:18am
gamepolitics: should the link be changed in the article, EZK?
Posted 10/07/08 at 07:56am
E. Zachary Knight: http://www.ezknight.net/jtdisbar_ext.php
Posted 10/07/08 at 07:56am
E. Zachary Knight: The JT Disbar add-on has been updated to version 0.7.5
Posted 10/07/08 at 07:33am
ZippyDSMlee: Dark Sovereign: the proper reply would be So you want a quick dry rub with cloths on? ba dum dum bish!
Posted 10/07/08 at 04:58am
gamepolitics: GP is on Twitter. Follow gamepolitics for Twitter updates.
Posted 10/06/08 at 07:06pm
Shadow Darkman Anti-Thesis of: @Dark Sovereign: Read "Countdown to JT's Disbarment"
Posted 10/06/08 at 07:00pm
Dark Sovereign: @Shadow: Say what now?
Posted 10/06/08 at 06:37pm
Shadow Darkman Anti-Thesis of: Hey, EZK! I saw what you did there! Great job!
Posted 10/06/08 at 06:28pm
Dark Sovereign: Just noticed: Nikko asks Michelle to go for "hot coffee". Michelle says people get hurt and end up in court.
Posted 10/06/08 at 05:22pm
gamepolitics: If you registered but did not get ur validation email, contact me: dennisATgamepolitics.com I can fix that
Posted 10/06/08 at 04:04pm
Austin_Lewis: well, what with the article about the protests recently, I think its interesting they're opening a large 'center' in a mall.
Posted 10/06/08 at 12:52pm
BlackIce: @Austin Lewis: Any specific parts?
Posted 10/06/08 at 12:41pm
Austin_Lewis: OI, GAMEPOLITICS! Just got this emailed to me, thought you'd like to hop in on it: http://www.thearmyexperience.com
Posted 10/06/08 at 12:21pm
NovaBlack: oops i meant 'unbanned' in uk
Posted 10/06/08 at 12:21pm
NovaBlack: BBFC lose the appeal to.. revoke ..original ..appeal. manhunt 2 bannd in uk. what a buunch of timewasters.
Login or register to post shouts