Italian Official Says He Will Seek Manhunt 2 Ban

June 22, 2007
Manhunt 2, banned in Britain and Ireland, AO-rated in North America, and likely to be banned in Australia, now faces political opposition in Italy.

The Age reports on remarks made by Italian Communications Minister Paolo Gentiloni (left) who said yesterday that he will move to ban the game in his country. Gentiloni characterized Manhunt 2 as:
Cruel and sadistic, with a squalid environment and a continuous, insistent encouragement to violence and murder.

Comments

"Cruel and sadistic"? As opposed to how many horror movies? They are not exactly marketing this for 7-year olds you... clueless person. x(

Manhunt 2 as "Cruel and sadistic?" I don't believe you, sorry. Manhunt 2 is a horror game so hey, you should know that horror films and games have scarier themes.

I think many politicians are cruel and sadistic.

I am an italian living in Ireland and working in the gaming industry and I am absolutely stunned at the lack of competence of the italian Communications Minister.

He clearly didn't even check the game, or any of the online available clips about it. The words he used to justify his decision are basically a copy and paste of the BBFC board words.

As a Minister, you are supposed to KNOW and get PERSONALLY involved with any matter you intend to issue a decision for. In addition, a ban is just a shortcut and not the most responsible choice. That would be EDUCATING consumers so that no parent buys a 18+ rated game for their kids.

But shortcuts are easy, why go for the responsible route and respect freedom of choice?

Ban censorship.

Man, the ban-Manhunt bandwagon is rolling around at terrible speeds. Anyone want to make a bet on how ling til' it reaches Germany?

With right wingers (incopetent as well) ruling in Poland, I'm sure that Poland will be next after Germany.

Anyway, I knew it (especially after the Rule of Rose) that these macaronians would join the ban-frenzy.

Europe sucks. End of story.

This debacle shold be called something. "Hot Coffee" has got a nice ring to it, so a similar name for this "Manhunt" debacle.

Hmmm.

"Manhunt-hunt" ?

How do you say 'bandwagon' in Italian?

If he is going to ban Manhunt 2 he might as well ban all of Lucio Fulci's films as well as all those Italian Cannibal films like Cannibal Holocaust as i assure you they are gorier and nastier and more brutal then anything in Manhunt 2.

Isn't it utterly redundant for these countries to ban the game, since a) neither Nintendo or Sony will allow the game to be released on their machines, and b) T2 have said they're putting it on hold?

To BmK,

"Italian Cannibal films like Cannibal Holocaust as i assure you they are gorier and nastier and more brutal then anything in Manhunt 2."

Not too mention also Italian Zombie films like Zombie Flesh Eaters (Zombi 2 or simply Zombie) and Hell Lake.

I mean why can't these politicians just give it a rest and let us decide what we want? These control freaks like this shouldn't exist in our planet.

I'm just curious. In italy are death metal groups such as Cannibal Corpse, Gwar and Six Feet Under allowed to sell their albums or perform live there? I mean certainly their music is 10times more graphic than Manhunt 2.

Example: Cannibal Corpse - Rancid Amputation

Torsos hang from their own intestines
Raped of all bodily extentions, stumps wreathing in a sludge
Like infection
Suffering through a Rancid amputation
A pulsating artery accomanied by some veins, slit with no restraint
Sacs of pus develop
My muscles tighten as I feel the rush
I look at your body starting gush

I slice through the limb,
a human dissection portions of half-eaten flesh in my mouth
starting to chew your now bleeding stump

I will swallow your pus your own rectal slime
I'll force you to drink
Vessels explode as needles injected
Uncontrollable
My brain tormented
Slit from head to toe, die through the torture
Disease engulfs you
Internal rot
Fresh cut wounds, beginning to clot
Ripping through flesh is what I do best
Tear off an arm
Amputated neck
Eyes removed, cranium smashed
Decomposing remains, severed in half
Dying slowly never to rest, nerves are quivering as I trip
Removal of life on the blade of my knife
Inserted in your spine, smashing through bone
Feel my hell, I feed on fright
Rape the limbless cadaver

In the image above, thats how large he wants his penis to be after using his male enlargement supplement.

HIEL!

as long as it comes out in at least one euro country (or PAL country), i think us euro's will be able to import it.

i don't know what the NTSCers are going to do... its unlikely to come out in japan, and the other NTSC countries have the ESRB AO rating problem.

but is this not an issue for the ECA? what are they doing about this?

I hope a finished version of the game gets leaked before they go back and tone everything down. Either that or release a unrated PC version via download.

Cannibal Holocaust was banned in Italy and Europe and still is to this day. Well the uncut version at least. They released a censored version that got an 18 and up rating but its illegal to own the uncut version.

@Terrible Tom

look up Italian horror movie directors and the movies they have put out. you'll probably come up with a pretty gory list.

Well with all this I'm pretty sure Rockstar will just tone down the violence so it can get M and no longer and be banned, oh well.

Just for your information, the Communications Minister is the same guy who proposed that the italian government should monitor the Internet and ban all the websites that are considered inappropriate for the population.

Now I don't even want to discuss about how absurd and simply impossible is to "monitor the Internet" (the sentence itself is basically as meaningless as "monitor the universe"), what is clear is that this person is a dinosaur that doesn't even have a slightest idea of what the Internet is, what freedom of choice is, and how to approach technologies that are more recent than a crystal set.

'Nuff said, we italians can only hope that this guy gets sent as fast as possible where he belongs to: the dinosaur museum.

P.S. "Bandwagon" in italian is "Diligenza" and, yes, heavy metal bands normally perform around italy and nobody ever raised an eyebrow. :)

I wonder if these people have even played the game.

I didn't see any reference to Mr. Genitalia in the article...

...but it was right on the money as far as the overall effect on Take2. Consumer demand will go up in response to all the hubbub, and the people who want it WILL find a way to get it. GTA IV is still the company's blue chip player, and sales from that will obviously dwarf whatever losses they sustain from Manhunt 2's limited distribution.
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
Uncharted NESUltra-Orthodox Jews Rally For a More Kosher Internet- http://slashdot.org/palm/30/12/05/21/1217218_1.shtml05/21/2012 - 10:44am
Lisa PhamEvaluation report for Diablo 3 is now up if you're interested... http://www.reclaimyourgame.com/content.php/132-Diablo-305/21/2012 - 8:53am
ZippyDSMleeLOL05/20/2012 - 9:18pm
ZippyDSMleehttp://www.afterdawn.com/news/article.cfm/2012/05/21/gta_iv_r2-d2_attacks_liberty_city05/20/2012 - 9:18pm
ZippyDSMleeThe eff should sue >>05/20/2012 - 3:10am
Lisa PhamD3's online EULA states an offline mode in Section 11... http://sea.blizzard.com/en-sg/company/legal/d3_eula.html05/20/2012 - 12:28am
Andrew EisenFor those of you following the 38 Studios news, a trailer for its in-development Project Copernicus is over at IGN. http://www.ign.com/articles/2012/05/18/project-copernicus-revealed05/18/2012 - 7:33pm
Andrew EisenUncharted - Already covered on GP earlier today.05/18/2012 - 7:25pm
Uncharted NESEA To Provide Free Distribution To Kickstarter Games- http://slashdot.org/palm/10/12/05/18/2058200_1.shtml05/18/2012 - 6:38pm
TechnogeekComcast suspends enforcement of bandwidth cap pending raise to 300GB/month, plans further increases for high-speed tiers: http://goo.gl/b89xma05/18/2012 - 1:31am
Uncharted NESUnofficial Skyrim App Gets Legal Note From Bethesda Lawyers- http://m.kotaku.com/5911035/unofficial-skyrim-app-gets-legal-note-from-bethesda-lawyers05/17/2012 - 2:55pm
Uncharted NESWhen Games Allow Mods, Beautiful Things Can Happen- http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120516/09044318944/when-games-allow-mods-beautiful-things-can-happen.shtml05/16/2012 - 7:46pm
ZippyDSMleeand its working now after a reboot ><05/16/2012 - 7:30pm
ZippyDSMleeI have been haveing trouble with it, its an odd win7 bug, with no firewall installed it works fine with one installed it works for a bit then dose not want to work 0-o05/16/2012 - 5:56pm
james_fudgenot today05/16/2012 - 5:12pm
ZippyDSMleeANyone have ofdd steam issues of it not connecting?05/16/2012 - 4:39pm
james_fudgeDo Monks have more fun than Witch Doctors? Film at 11.05/16/2012 - 3:03pm
Uncharted NESLionhead Possibly Making a Hybrid MMO/Offline Game for the Next Xbox- http://m.kotaku.com/5910791/speculation-lionhead-possibly-making-a-hybrid-mmooffline-game-for-the-next-xbox05/16/2012 - 12:15pm
Uncharted NESMax Payne 2 Firing Blanks on Xbox Live- http://m.kotaku.com/5910736/max-payne-2-firing-blanks-on-xbox-live05/16/2012 - 12:14pm
ddrfr33kThe Ocean Marketing saga continues... http://kotaku.com/5910586/ocean-marketings-christoforo-says-former-client-asked-him-to-continue-working-for-them-under-fake-name05/15/2012 - 9:01pm

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician