The Only Other Game to Receive an Adults Only Rating for Violence

June 22, 2007 -
In the wake of this week's Manhunt 2 news, Duke Ferris at Game Revolution pens a feature on what he says is the only other game to receive an Adults Only rating from the ESRB strictly for violence.

That game, Ferris writes, is Thrill Kill: 
In a sad sign for Manhunt 2, Thrill Kill was never released. Virgin Interactive was going to publish it for the Playstation, but then they got bought by EA just a few weeks before the game's launch. EA, however, immediately pulled the plug and said they'd never publish such a violent game.



The game's Wikipedia entry, however, makes no mention of an AO rating:
The ESRB's complaints had Paradox change some of the game's content. For example: "The Imp" character name was supposedly changed from "Senator Lieberman" (a direct spoof of the US senator of the same name). Characters wore briefs instead of g-strings. Belladonna's suggestive wail at the start of a match was toned down...

Comments

Re: The Only Other Game to Receive an Adults Only Rating for

 

I still have a ps1 and a unrated thrill kill game from overseas along with about 300 other ps1 titles and still plug it up for some old school gaming the game is repative if its one player but 3-4 players its a blast if you want to play the games like the maker made them MOD and order from overseas

I'm sorry but how is this any worse than MK or any of the other ultra-violent fighters that have been released over time? MK4 was released at around the same time as this and it had far more violent content than anything in that video.

Game obviously marketed toward horror genre fans and fans of death metal groups such as Cannibal Corpse, Six Feet Under ect. Ahh, oh well they usually get the short end of the stick as many states prohibit entertainment they enjoy.

Obviously these politicians won't let us get what we want. They are the ones who are cruel and sadistic like you implied and much compared to Hitler.

I just want to release a statement that I, too, will be banning Manhunt 2.

Bandwagon jumping is fun.

The funny thing is that this once AO bound game looks pretty damn tame in comparison to some of the games currently on the market with M ratings.

@Rob

Of course ratings drift and increased graphical quality.

We may as well be banning R rated horror movies...

does this mean if they forced a hip hop storyline and rappers into manhunt 2 it would get past the ersb? i always wondered about thrill kill, but i did pick up the game that used the same engine, wu-tang:shaolin style. which contained a lot of the same moves and kills. i think some of wu-tangs finishers were worse. i have to wonder how much more sexually suggestive thrill kill was. if you've ever seen the documentary on the MPAA called 'this film has not yet been rated' you notice that the MPAA has larger issues with sexuality (when their not protecting the interests of major studios) then they do with violence. it leads me to believe that the reason rockstar clinched the AO was from scenes that had to deal with nudity and sex then with prolonged torture. apparently, knocking someone's head off like it was a golf ball while you stand on their back and screaming fore is okay, but a woman with a sexually suggestive scream is a no go.

Decent graphics for a PS1 era game, although the hit detection looks pretty bad. The moving camera is also very distracting.

Looks like a pretty generic Mortal Kombat klone.

Yeah, I played it more than 5 years ago-it's very, very sadistic (the bathroom arena was just downright disturbing) and morbid, but the game production quality was decent. A friend of mine who works for www.viz.com, used to do video game reviews, and so they would get a lot of promotional betas (like Tobal #2), since this game never went gold.

Beladonna, the nurse, had a taunt, that was a brief attempt at masturbation (it was very brief). Another character, had the ability to use his own arm as a weapon (reminded me of Time Killers). I remember playing one arena that had toilets or a toilet in the center, and you could do some kind of fatality with it. So this game pushed the envelope like nothing I have ever seen before, and since.

He's right. I covered that story 10 years ago for C/Net GamerCenter - I think. I was working for way too many sites and mags then. But as I recall, it was canceled because it was going to get the AO and therefore never went officially "gold."

The Punisher was rated AO, before they toned down some of the torture scenes for the consoles. The PC version was released uncensored, with an M rating I believe.

random j03 Says:
June 22nd, 2007 at 8:48 am
" knocking someone’s head off like it was a golf ball while you stand on their back and screaming fore is okay.."

Lol wtf?!

And exactly HOW is Thrill Kill more violent than any of the Mortal Kombat games?

Looks kinda... repetitive.

This game was actually really fun. The most innovative thing about it was the "violence meter" instead of a health bar (not sure if you noticed in the video). Your "score" would be based on how much violence you dished out, instead of how much damage you took.

It was a really fun game, especially when you got four people going.

It's sad when we let people who have no interest whatsoever in our past time dictate what we can or cannot do with it.

@Coldsnap :

I may be wrong (obviously) but I think the hoopla had to do with not only the excessive and prolonged violence but the excessive hints at acts of sexuality. Based on my memories of the storm then, people's reviews above of its game play and so forth. There is a hypocritical and normally self-serving moral line. Developers of games are punished for crossing this line while movies, television, print and the Net get away with it hand over fist. Sometimes they get away with it because they haggle with rating boards or use lobby groups. Sometimes they merely coast on the first amendment rights they routinely go to court over protecting. Mortal Kombat and Eternal Champions both had some gruesome scenes in them but yet both found homes on the Genesis, the former finding homes on a lot more systems since it sold well. Plenty of games deserved the same spotlight but never got it.

Instead MK sold well, it got in the public eye and kids were found around it, flocking like drugged geese. Their parents slacked on their responsibilities, some store chains and arcade owners flagrantly watched as kids racked up their sales, and Joe Politician found a topic that he could milk for years to make it look like he was doing something society really needed. Above better education. Above poverty in America. Above the quality of health care and a cache of other more viable issues.

Everyone involved has dropped a tiny snowball, and now it's growing more huge every couple of weeks and politicians and others exacerbate the industry's woes. The industry's organizations CAN do more, in educating the public of the technology's worth and by enforcing a consistent system by which software is rated. Bob Shopkeeper CAN surely do more about kids buying games meant for adults and educating parents. I've seen it work and parents still reject the data as sound advise. But instead we allow laws to be make the world a "better place" where instead of free choice you have game ghettos within stores, higher prices, more hostile vibes, and a very nasty picture of the world of the future to look forward to.

BTW, how edited is the ISO I've seen around for play? I never really wanted to play it so didn't take the effort to grab it.

thrill kill had its moments of sexuality like "the moan" and g-strings and i think those two reasons coupled with the uber-violence at the time was what did it in. so to say the rating or pulling of the game was solely based on violence may be a touch of wishful thinking. remember kids violence > sex.

pssh, that is obviously an M rated game.

@ Brokenscope

Well, even back then, when I had some interest in the game I thought it still looked a little tame. I really don't think there was anything in there worthy of an AO rating, even back then. There was still more blood and gore in the Mortal Kombat games.

It looks like it's just a powerstone rip off, with the violence of Mortal Kombat, and an awful soundtrack.

Oh and what's up with the highlander powerup at the end there?!?

Ironic... I've played Thrill Kill quite a bit actually, one of my old roommates had a release candidate copy for Playstation. I've certainly played games that are MUCH more violent since (G.U.N. specifically comes to mind). If Thrill Kill was rated AO for violence only then the board rating it as such clearly has not played it very long. One of the charicaters is a Dwarf with several "fetish" costumes to select from, f'rinstance.
Personally I don't understand why a game being rated AO is such a "mark of death" in the market. As someone who regularly purchases various forms of electronic media it has always been the level of production quality that makes or breaks my purchasing decisions, not ratings or "extreme content." It seems transparent to me that making political noise AT ALL regarding video games is a cheap political manouver to generate votes, no different from candidates using attack language or pretending to be religous.

Don't forget the Eternal Champion games, especially the Sega CD version. Those were explicitly gory, they blow Mortal Kombat away. Even today it could still be considered extremely gory.

That game looks awful. I thought the characters were killer mannequins or something.

Eternal Champions wasn't so bad overall. I have played quite a few fighters worse than it was but never had the Sega CD version just normal Genesis. I wanted it to be able to attack the chihuahua with a rooster. I think everyone agrees with me that chihuahuas are evil.

i would still buy an AO title. im actually very interested in buying manhunt 2 because the first was entertaining and the second is now infamous. i think they should release two versions of the game like they do with "unrated" dvd versions of movies and see which one sells.

I say save the game by editing it down to a Mature (M) rating and take the approach that South Park did with the whole Mohammad controversy. They could edit the most violent and pr0nographic parts and replace it with some super rude cartoon mockery of the British Board of Film Classification (BBFC), Sony, Nintendo, the ESRB, Jack Thompson, Sam Walton, Jesus, and George Bush by having them all poop on each other. That would make a point, and they can't censor that. Well, at least the USA can't censor that. Those Europeans will probably still not allow it...

@ Grimm22

Thrill Kill was in the making long before Power Stone was. In fact, Trill Kill was to be the first four player fighting game before it got canceled. Eventually the engine was use to create that Wu-Tang Shaolin Style fighting game, which came out some months after Power Stone.

@ DragonBomber

Then you haven't experiences the true brutality of Eternal Champions if you haven't experienced it for the Sega CD. Look on YouTube for the fatality/overkills/etc. videos on there and see for yourself. A lot of them can be considering extremely graphic by todays standards, even if it was a sprite based game.

Andre
the reason why AO is the kiss of death is because the industry itself hates it from the retailers that refuse to touch it and the consoles makers that have said they would not approve it on their system(Sony/NIN).

Frankly MS should jump on this and show adult class games have a place, and a home on the 360 :X

Speaking of moaning and touching anyone remember the females in quake 2?

[...] [Via Game Politics] [...]

Meh, ThrillKill looks M to me.

"The PC version was released uncensored, with an M rating I believe."

It had an M rating, but the the deaths from the "interrogation" scenes were done in black and white (originally they were in color), and the camera often panned away from the more brutal ones.

I just need to ask, but AO is 18+, and because of this, Nintendo, Sony and loads of stores won't stock or supply AO titles. However, we have the 18 rating in the UK which is basically the same restrictions as AO in regards to who can purchase said item.

So my query is how can companies like Sony and Nintendo (and Microsoft if I'm not mistaken) say they don't support AO titles, when in affect they do over here in the UK - the rating is the same.

According to Patricia Vancne, lots of games have gotten AO for violence. Most are just edited to be Ms before release and the public is none the wiser unless told by the developer as with Manhunt 2 or Punisher.

This was a good game. I remember playing the uncensored version quite a bit with a crowd of people. The camera worked better then it should have, and there was no one character that you can really cheat with. Well, maybe Oddball...

Hi,



I am Harsh Dayal Sharma from Atechnocrat Solution (SEO based web designing firm India). I would like to offer you SEO content writing service for Link Popularity from all over the world. We are able to deliver quality incoming links from PR based sites. In essence, we provide Article writing and content development services that make everyone to feel good web presence and possess result oriented page ranking.



The result is a unified strategy that is both efficient and cost-effective. We do business for your business growth.



Let me know if you have any question.



I look forward to hearing from you.



Regards,

Harsh Dayal Sharma

(Sales Engineer)

Atechnocrat Solution

Phone. 91-11-65043753

Mob. 91-9873107450

e-mail: harsh@atechnocrat.com

URL: www.atechnocrat.com

If you want to discuss, please add me on MSN Messenger

MSN ID: atechnocrat@hotmail.com

Yahoo : sumit_mee@yahoo.com

Skype : atechnocrat









Website design | SEO | E-Commerce | Multimedia | Software development
 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
Andrew EisenThat's enough, folks.02/03/2015 - 2:11am
MechaCrashYou know what else is uncalled for? Your whiny tone policing.02/03/2015 - 1:54am
Sora-Chan@MechCrash my complaint is more direct at how you reacted. When someone is leaving you do not run up behind them and kick them in the ass out the door. Hense, what you said, was uncalled for. It doesn't matter who it is.02/03/2015 - 1:40am
Andrew EisenPlus (and I know you didn't say otherwise, I just feel it's important to point out) there's nothing wrong with discussing the elements of games that you take issue with or find problematic.02/03/2015 - 1:34am
Andrew EisenMatthew - That's one way to handle it but you'd potentially be missing out on a ton of great games. After all, just because a game has elements that may rub some the wrong way doesn't mean they aren't worth playing.02/03/2015 - 1:33am
MechaCrashSave your crocodile tears. I'm glad to be rid of the people who complain when games get treated as a form which can have messages and meanings and demand they be relegated to simplistic toys, to be played with and discarded.02/03/2015 - 1:12am
Sora-Chan@MechCrash Simpley put: Uncalled for.02/03/2015 - 1:03am
MechaCrashThank you for confirming you want games to remain the playthings of children and not art of any kind, Wonderkarp, and good riddance.02/03/2015 - 12:23am
Goth_SkunkThe tropes that bother me the most don't appear in video games: Dumb/Jerk Jock trope, Narcissitic Psycopath (when male), and Dad Is A Homophobe But Unaware Child is Homosexual.02/02/2015 - 10:22pm
prh99They can make zombie games all they want, I just wish they mix it up a bit. My use vampires etc or some Lovecraftian horrors.02/02/2015 - 10:09pm
Matthew WilsonI tend to be on the side of free markets. if you do not like a trope, do not buy a game that uses that trope.02/02/2015 - 9:59pm
prh99MechaTama: Yeah, the zombie apocalypse stuff is just getting old, and infestation scenarios aren't much better.02/02/2015 - 9:57pm
MechaTama31I just catch a whiff of zombie and my eyes just sort of glaze over and my attention drifts elsewhere.02/02/2015 - 9:52pm
WonderkarpI'm going to live it like 1995 before I logged on, only with magazine subscriptions and newsletters telling me whats being made and whats coming out. rest can suck it. peace out.02/02/2015 - 9:52pm
MechaTama31prh: seriously. I think that's why I hadn't heard of this game.02/02/2015 - 9:52pm
Andrew EisenKarp - Best to you.02/02/2015 - 9:49pm
prh99I can think of another trope that is over used, zombies02/02/2015 - 9:49pm
WonderkarpGP. its been a fun ride. but I'm out. I'm done with all of this. the fighting, hell even the news. Its made me a very unhappy person. all of it. Andrew, its been real.02/02/2015 - 9:46pm
Andrew Eisenprh99 - As the overarching narrative of the game? Sure but then again, no one said it was. Plus, I don't think the guy you're going after is in distress. I think you're going in to stop him. Could be wrong though. Haven't played it.02/02/2015 - 9:44pm
Andrew EisenGoth - Ah, you caught me before the edit! Not just my opinion (and also not the sole reason) but if you don't have a problem with the trope and you don't think it's overused, that's fine! You're not a bad person!02/02/2015 - 9:42pm
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician