New E3 Format Leaves Some GameCo's Cold

New E3 Format Leaves Some GameCo's Cold

July 7, 2007
E3 will certainly be different this year. But will it be better?

GameSpot has interviews with a number of companies who aren't attending for a variety of reasons.

Most notably, Tecmo boss John Inada was highly critical of the new E3:
New show management didn't seem to know what they were doing. I don't have money to waste on an experimental project. Previously, we were not treated very nicely by the old E3 management, so we didn't feel obligated to cooperate this year. I also heard that a lot of the [retail] buyers weren't coming.

A unnamed source described as close to a large, non-attending publisher also cited concerns over flagging retailer participation:
GameStop's not really going to be there, Best Buy's not going to be there. Why should we bother dealing with the ESA's confusion when we can meet with our retail partners separately and then stage our own gamers' day event later on in the year where we set the rules? It just doesn't make any sense.

Comments

IO never understood why theyd hold it in an inherantly expensive loactaion, its like holding the 2012 olympics in london not Birmingham ie insane.
[...] Release date: TBA | Platforms: PC | Official Site Link: E3 Expo Official Site Link: New E3 Format Leaves Some GameCo’s Cold @ GamePolitics.com Link: Countdown to E3 @ GamesIndustry.biz Link: E3 2007 @ GameSpot Link: IGN.com E3 Central    By Tiago Sá at July 9th, 2007       [...]
Verbinator
at the same time alot of devs can not show their games there,this is the other side of the coin compared to the old E3,hows the electronic trade show is it any better than E3? or is that what E3 was.....

sorry I lost my train of thought LOL
I'm looking forward to hearing how this E3 goes ... and I'm glad that the cut back scale means I don't have to go this year. My product team is presenting a game this year and it will be the first time that anyone has seen actual game content for it.

I'm glad that I don't have to stand on my feet in in front of of a video monitor and demo the same 5 minutes of game play over and over and over.

I'm happy not to be shoving my way through crowds of people who have no business being at the show other than to say they've been, many who consider their blogsites and fanboy web pages to be actual contributions to game critique and journalism (present site excepted).

I'm glad I don't have to try and sell a product to people who can't understand me or even hear me when I speak ... and when they ask questions, I can neither understand their take on English nor even hear them over the din of some meaningless (but allegedly hip) noise blasting out of an adjacent booth.

I'm glad my employer isn't blowing millions of dollars on media and messages that have no real effect, other than line the pockets of hotels and restaurants in Los Angeles. That same money can now be used to buy real advertising, real exposure, real promotions targeted on the people who will put the product in their stores and the people who will eventually buy and enjoy the game I'm creating.

E3 is still an important show, but it takes its place as one of several now, not the ultimate or end all. My project team put in no less effort for this than if the show was like the E3 of old. What's truly different is that the guys showing the game have only one mission at E3 ... show our game ... not see the show, or get drunk after hours and show up late for demo sessions, or get their picture taken with out of work C and D list actresses or actors trying to get some nostalgia tour work going, or to get invites to the Sony or Microsoft parties. They are on mission to show and sell our game.

Hopefully, the the people seeing our game demonstrated in our showroom will be for similar reasons. Hopefully they'll be there because they care enough about seeing it to schedule time for it. They'll get the full message we want them to get about our game, not a few minutes caught in passing, distracted by hip hop dancers, flying skateboards, or goofy web media "reporters" telling stories about their adventures as they navigate E3.

That's my rant. This format works for the Toy industry. Let's let it work for the digital game industry too.
Yea I'll admit that I'm not incredibly into MMOs but I'd like to know about game audio and game writing. Those are two things I think that interest me a lot.
@Terrible Tom

Austin GDC is great. I went last year but am not sure if I will make it this year. But if you have no interest in the makings of MMOs, game audio or game writing, then it is not the place for you. I went for the writing parts and loved every minute. We even got to see a sneak peak at Mass Effect.
I never really cared about E3. I'd never pay to go to E3 so this really doesn't bum me out too much. I will admit that it sucks for everyone that did want to go and cannot. But really it reminded me more of a media whore circus.

I am going to invest in GDC, I'll be attending my first GDC in Feb. I'm really excited about it. I'll probably hit up Austin GDC as well.
I think the old E3s problem was that rules were not really followed and you had so many pubs/devs tryign to out do each other,E3 only needed stricter rules and more fines,its large and mess but unlike car shows they only have the top X amount of makers to show their stale old cars,gaming had a huge amount of makers pubs and others,the new E3 is pointless as a high end only event they should merge it with pax (the E3 "staff" helps pax with the large corporations and stuff with them).

Pax runs the event and the E3 staff can be cut down to simple middle man work.
E3 is dead man let it die....or bring it back as the nerd fest it was.
this E3 might teach the industry a lesson to learn if they still care.
screw E3, I was finally qualified to go from work and this happens. So all the little GS and Walmart kids got to go, and someone who worked their life to get into the whole field never will.

Bah GDC is more fun anyways
at least .hack Redemption is going to be at the show... Gamespot and IGN said so, so I have no reason to doubt them.
Well, I read this and the Gamespot article linked to, and I must say that this does not bode well for the future of E3.

Key retailers aren't bothering to put in more than a token appearance at best, and small developers and publishers are being shut out even if they express interest. Even a few big developers and publishers are essentially going "We aren't showing up. What would be the point in doing so?"

Unless this year turns out significantly better than expected, or they dramatically shift things around again next year, things are going to fall apart in short order. If no one but the biggest show up, in short order it won't be worth their while to show up either.
They'll either bring the old E3 back or we're moving it to PAX. I prefer the old E3 only because it always sounded like a madhouse of awesome.
Just wait for the E For All show October 18th - 21st...
Ha.

That's all there is to it, HA.
Surprise, surprise. E3 turns from an all-inclusive show to a "Highlight reel" of only the biggest and wealthiest companies, leaving the rest of the development community in the cold, and RSVP's are lower than expected? Who would have guessed?

I hope at some point we get our old E3 back- this catering to the upper crust of the industry flies against everything E3 was about.
It figures I'm finally on the west coast and am able to go to an E3 and they stop doing the big flashy awesome one. And I'm not even in high enough on the corporate ladder for them to justify sending me.

oh well, Good luck GP running all over Santa Monica.

GamePolitics ShoutBox

Posted 12/01/08 at 02:50pm
Zevorick: Does it honestly surprise you pin? It's not like SecuRom has EVER stopped Piracy before. It just makes it slightly inconvenient
Posted 12/01/08 at 02:47pm
JDKJ: SeanB: There's been plenty new content and off-topic shouts. Ain't nobody ever get called out before for doing it. Relax.
Posted 12/01/08 at 02:47pm
nelttab: @JDJK aye, i could see that... and you know what... im glad i found this site a coupla months ago
Posted 12/01/08 at 02:45pm
E. Zachary Knight: EMA is getting in on the anti-piracy racket: http://www.gamasutra.com/php-bin/news_index.php?story=21306
Posted 12/01/08 at 02:40pm
JDKJ: @nelttab: My interpretation was "Do what you want on the outside, just don't bring it back to my doorstep."
Posted 12/01/08 at 02:40pm
DeepThorn: The ESA is onto you Pin, shhh
Posted 12/01/08 at 02:23pm
Pinworm: Just informing you guys that GTA4 PC has been released on Scene Torrent sites. Thank god for SECUROM!
Posted 12/01/08 at 01:51pm
GamesLaw: Heart @ DesertBus. I donated $50 bucks and they gave a shout out to gameslaw.net which was cool..
Posted 12/01/08 at 01:38pm
DeepThorn: MC where?
Posted 12/01/08 at 01:32pm
NovaBlack: http://uk.tv.yahoo.com/01122008/19/barrowman-sorry-show-exposure.html
Posted 12/01/08 at 01:32pm
NovaBlack: lol random uk story. An actor forced to apologise after flashing. on RADIO and a LISTENER got offended
Posted 12/01/08 at 01:24pm
NovaBlack: /salute Penny Arcade /agreed!!
Posted 12/01/08 at 01:23pm
Michael Chandra: @Tyler: Oh, so THAT's why Jerry was calling! I can't understand what they say on the live cam, so didn't know what was going on.
Posted 12/01/08 at 01:22pm
Michael Chandra: DT, SB, the explanation at the forum explains in more detail as to the why.
Posted 12/01/08 at 01:21pm
nelttab: /salute Penny Arcade
Posted 12/01/08 at 01:20pm
Flamespeak: The guys from Penny Arcade sure do have some big ol' hearts.
Posted 12/01/08 at 01:19pm
Tyler Baumbarger: Tycho from Penny Arcade just called Loading Ready Run to offer matching up to 10,000 from now on for the Desert Bus and posted the info on Penny Arcade.
Posted 12/01/08 at 01:18pm
Flamespeak: If you guys wanna cyber-trail JT, fine. Leave us alone to discuss games and politics, yo.
Posted 12/01/08 at 01:18pm
nelttab: i think he is mainly just saying "Enough with JT" (from my interpritation)
Posted 12/01/08 at 01:12pm
SeanB: i have to agree. If the shoutbox cant introduce new content, and cant be off topic, we may as well post in comments.
Login or register to post shouts