July 20, 2007 -
2K Sports, owned by Take Two Interactive, has just shipped All-Pro Football 2K8, and already there's a controversy.The Street.com reports that the game, which lacks an NFL license but makes up for it by using the likenesses of retired pro players, also features O.J. Simpson, who many believe committed the grisly slashing murder of his wife and a man named Ronald Goldman in 1994.
The Street.com's Priya Ganapati, who has covered Take Two frequently, writes:
A game trailer on the Game Trailers Web site shows Simpson game highlights as his team, "The Assassins," moves down the field. Toward the end of the clip, Simpson scores a touchdown, prompting a large hooded mascot (above) above the scoreboard to make stabbing motions with a large knife...
2K Sports' decision clearly reflects a lack of sensitivity and leaves the company open to accusations of bad taste, but, at its worst, it suggests an attempt to deliberately offend and use Simpson's past to profit and promote a video game that many parents would likely buy as a normal sports-game purchase.
Ganapti writes that a Take Two spokesman forwared a statement saying the mascot's stabbing motion is "not specifically associated with O.J. Simpson, and the game does not promote any such connection.
GP: Although we hadn't taken notice of O.J.'s inclusion on the roster, at least one website did, about 10 weeks back. PastaPadre now seems prescient:
OJ Simpson being in APF 2K8 is unlikely to keep anyone from specifically purchasing it... I would not be surprised however if the topic is brought up sometime heading up to release. The question is whether 2K is actually seeking out the negative press this could present as a way to get the game some attention.
PP also seems to want to blame GameTrailers for a Michael Vick-like APF2K8 trailer.



Comments
Or the Barbarians...BARBARIC!
I have little doubt he'll be pulled. If I'm wrong I'll eat crow, but the WWE severed ties so quickly with the Benoit issue and discontinued all merchandise relating to him in a matter of a couple days. Maybe there'll be a hot coffee version of Benoit hidden somewhere in the coding at best, but I don't see it possible that he'll be a playable character, considering WWE's addressing of the matter.
To be honest, most game trailers are taken from a huge collection of catured video footage, and are chosen for how 'effective' they look, not how 'accurately' they define the gameplay, there's every possiblity that the video was put together by someone who had no idea who was who on the pitch, but just used the scenes that made the game look interesting and fun.
Though I do take issue with Simpson appearing in the game at all.
Screw that; this is awesome; I'm gonna be the assassins and hire every football star ever accused of a crime!
Why take issue with that? He played NFL football, and was pretty popular; therefore including him in a game using the likenesses of other retired NFL players makes perfect sense. What he did or did not do after that has nothing to do with this game.
The only thing at all offensive I see about this is that some idiot purposefully showed O. J. on this particular team, with that particular mascot, for the sole purpose of causing a stir. That is what riles me, not the fact that he's in the game.
Well whatever, didn't Jeffery Archer write (in what i call High detail) all the murders his inmates committed in his books? Why wasn't that critisised?
A similar controversy would be "I made a Jack Thompson wrestler in a Create-A-Wrestler design". It's not really Jack Thompson. It's throwing together pieces and saying "Hey! That LOOKS LIKE Jack Thompson!", as opposed to having a ready made character named Jack Thompson.
Nightwng2000
NW2K Software
Simpson was a great football player, but I personally feel his legal troubles trump his on-field legacy. I'm morally uncomfortable with the idea of glorifying that kind of personality. I don't expect Chris Benoit to be a playable legend in any upcoming WWE games for the same reason.
You (and already others) have stated that these two issues should be seperated. That's fine, and I respect the opinion. I'm just not personally comfortable with it. ...But not to the point that I would protest or boycott the game. I don't think we should erase our history, but omitting him from the game wouldn't have been that big of a deal in my opinion.
Since the game is not yet released, this was not generated by some random mischievous player.
And I watched the trailer, I would say it was not in poor taste. Not any more poor taste than a comedian profiting from an OJ joke, or a Michael Jackson molestation joke, or a Vick dog fighting joke. Video games are under way too much scrutiny lately. Back off people.
The game has been released and has been available for a few days now. Not saying the trailer isn't 2K's, just clarifying.
GET THAT THING ROLLING
Speaking of terrorizing, they need to be detained.
This one by Priya Ganapati is a prime example.
That woman had no idea what she was talking about. And besides, why the hell should ANYONE take offense to that other then the FAMILIES of the victims? Who the hell do people think they are saying "Oh, its has OJ in it and he MIGHT have killed people that I have never met in my life, nor do I think about in my daily routines. I'm never haunted by the situation like the people who know the victims. But I'm offended by it anyways".
Grow up people.
And thats besides the point that O.J. isn't even assigned to that team! You can make your OWN teams! Hell, thats what I'm going to do...I'm going to make the Sin-cinati Serial Killers. It will have O.J. and create-a-player Dahmer, Gacey, Ramierez, Speck, Josef Mengele, and whomever else I can think of.
Why, may I ask, are you offended by it? Did you know the victims? If not, then why do you care if an EXCUSED killer who was found NOT GUILTY appears in a video game? Especially since he was a great football player and deserves to be in this game?
If you want to take offense, great, good for you, have your opinion. But I personally think its stupid. Unless you knew the families or the victims that were effected by that tragic event, then you should have no say on the situation. Because honestly, how the hell can you be offended by this?
Or were the victims of this crime on your mind before this was released? Or is it only now, after watching this video, do you have a problem with it? If its the latter, then yes, my point stands. Its stupid and you should grow up. Because the only reason WHY your offended by is, is because you CAN be offended by it.
And bringing crap like this up only brings back the haunting memories of those times back to the family members, the TRUE people who would/could be offended.
Now, 13 years later, some guy puts up a video of a video game with O.J. on it and people bring it to the lime light. Why? I have no clue...because they can. Or because they have found a way to profit off of it (like thestreet.com). Other then that, bringing this up does NOTHING but cause people to be "offended" when they REALLY aren't offended. And causes further pain to the families.
THAT is why I think its stupid and people should Grow up. If that makes me Jack Thompson, fine, so be it. But I stick by my words.
I don't take personal offense to this. If you read anything that I typed I consider it a minor deal. You're calling people names for having a different opinion than you. Very mature.
This is an issue because O.J. Simpson is getting publicity and likely money off of this project when he doesn't deserve to be in the spotlight anymore. Sure, he's a brutal killer who has attempted to capitalize off his own infamy, but he was a good football player! That's what matters! Seems a little backwards...
I try to show respect for people I disagree with because this is a simple moral issue and there is ultimately no point in arguing, but you are not a respectable person if you are going to try and dictate how others should think with childish name calling.
And the whole thing with the assassin thing is kinda funny. Sure its coincidental, but given the fact that EA has the rights over the NFL, 2k had to find another way to get football teams out there and mascots to support, right?
That was what.... almost a decade ago and no one cared
Don't Care
Even if he didn't kill those people, that is still in bad taste. That would be like... Alfred Packer writing a book called "So what if I ate them?" Instead he chose to live out his undeserved freedom as a rancher in obscurity, until the FDA almost named a restaurant after him, unaware of his cannibalistic past. I'm pretty sure I just lost my point somewhere in the mazed corridors of that paragraph, so I'll just drop it and go to sleep.
"I don’t expect Chris Benoit to be a playable legend in any upcoming WWE games for the same reason."
Makes you wonder if THQ has enough time to pull Benoit out of Smackdown vs. Raw 2008.