Youth Back Pain Attributed To Video Games

Youth Back Pain Attributed To Video Games

August 18, 2007
Owwww!!! My back and/or neck hurts...

Back and neck injuries among teenagers will be the focus of an upcoming conference of the New Zealand Manipulative Physiotherapists Association.  So what's the cause?

Hint: If it wasn’t video games, GamePolitics wouldn’t be reporting on this story. Said NZMPA spokesman Duncan Reid:
This seems on the cards considering the associated health problems of obesity, reduced levels of activity, and the popularity of passive entertainment systems such as PlayStations that encourage further inactivity and prolonged sitting posture in the adolescent age group.

Does that mean Wii gamers who jump and flail about during a rocking round of Wii Tennis are safe from back ailments?

Nope.  According to Reid, kids who do too much activity are equally at risk.

AE:  Yikes.  Damned if you do, damned if you don’t.  Maybe gently leaning side to side on Nintendo’s Balance Board will be safe?

To be fair, games are not being singled out as the sole cause of back pain in children.  Australian physiotherapist Peter O'Sullivan cites “sporting activity” as a contributing factor in addition to the “static postures” common with playing video games.

Via: Stuff.co.nz

-Reporting from San Diego, GP Correspondent Andrew Eisen wrote this story while exhibiting exceptional posture 

Comments

When I had severe back pain as a kid... it was mainly due to the utterly stupid amount of large textbooks we were forced to carry to school and back every single godawful day. Most kids carry their backpacks on one shoulder, rather than two, which really doesn't help.
[...] [Via GamePolitics — Thanks, Justin]  [...]
What about the "prolonged sitting posture" caused by having to be in those uncomfortable desks every day in school?

Anyways, my back pain is from carrying a 40 pound drum on my shoulders for long stretches of time, not sitting on my couch playing Guitar Hero.
So if both overexercise and underexercise lead to problems, what kind of daily regiment do they propose? Do they give ANY recommendations on how much exercise you should go through each day? Or are they just holding the conference to assign blame to as many things as they can?

Then again, this is New Zealand, so I shouldn't honestly be suprised.
Nah, they're just announcing what the rest of the world knows already.

Don't overdo it (you don't start off as pro, you WORK your way up there slowly), and don't sit on your ass ALL day.

As for gaming being a key element in obesity? Hardly, rather it's bad food trends... But no one wants to admit that, do they?


Speaking of which, you KNOW it's bad when the "you are what you eat" reality shows has you watching couples feeding their kids with cola and chips every morning. Worse when you actually know a lot of people who DO that.
Well shoot, THIS explains everything.

And here I thought my back pain was due to spondylolisthesis they found after landing on a tree root from seven feet up.

*Cough* Anyway. Video games are hardly "the cause" of this, bad posture is. If your posture is bad enough, you can ruin your back while reading, watching TV, hell, even doing homework.
Doesn't come as a surprise to me, playing guitar and keyboards can, apparently, accelerate the onset of joint problems in your hands, just as typing, particuarly on an 'old fashioned' style typewriter, and yes, the biggest problem with most computer games are the fact they are sedentary.

It's amazing how many people will complain with zeal if their work set-up doesn't match Health and Safety Laws, and yet will quite happily accept terrible conditions for their own leisure time.
I was born with Spina Bifida Occulta and thus have always had back pain, so don't blame teh evil games.
@ GoodRobotUs

That's because they can't possibly obtain a large settlement if they sue themselves for slacking off in a health-hazardous way. :)
A well balanced exercise program is as important to good health as a well balanced diet.

We also know that "diets" vary in their effects from person to person. What is good for one person may be hazardous to another.

Parents in-the-know do know that the best place to start investigating good health for their kids (as well as themselves) is with their family physician and a good physical exam to set a baseline for present health.

From there, it does tend to be trial and error to determine what is "reasonable" for each individual. Not to mention that change in habits, both nutritional and exercise -wise, are not easy to make. Sometimes, a massive change is needed, but whether that individual's physiology can accept a drastic change all at once may need to be taken into consideration as well. Slow, steady change may also be difficult. Sometimes even patience is stressed.

It always comes down to the complexity of the indivdiual, which many studies outright ignore in favor of sensationalism or shock value.

I treat this sort of thing the same way I do with relationships (family, social, etc):
Don't worry about the rest of Humanity. Worry about what does or does not work for you and your children if you have them. While everyone else is trying everything under the sun simply because the news or a study of the moment says "this works" or "this doesn't", people who are focusing on themselves and their own family are either having better success or quickly narrowing down what is specifically best for them or their family.

Nightwng2000
NW2K Software
Kind of ironic considering many schools are instituting a DDR regimen in their physical education departments... and lets not forget the recent story about Wiis in elderly care homes.
I would imagine that video games would aggravate problems due to bad posture.
Actually, most of the times I've played video games I'm either lying on my stomach or sitting upright and forward. I think this guy has some image in his head of some slovenly overeater leaning back on the couch with his mouth and eyes half-open, having not budged in hours except for his fingers on the controller for the fifth day in a row.

I've been gaming for over 25 years and working in restaurants and bars for the last 15, and my back feels great. I attribute it to regular exercise and a fairly healthy/consistent diet, but what do I know, I'm not a manipulative physiotherapist.
My own experience with back pain has been more generic in regards to size of monitor/TV, size of fonts, size in general requiring me, a legally blind player/computer user, to sit forward. True that in the case of a computer, I can reduce resolution size, but that does present problems with overall image size and therefore makes reading a large area a burden.

But more than anything, it's a case of "gamer's thumb" that I suffer from every once and awhile. More so with the limited controllers (such as the Atari joystick). But newer controllers and more expanded playability reduce that. Still, from time to time, a rather hectic action packed game can lead to a jittery thumb or even a painful hard spot on the thumb that lasts for a few days.

But back pain, while it occurs from time to time, is still rare for me.

Nightwng2000
NW2K Software
I DON'T excersice and i have 0 back pain, (although I do have aches and pains elsewhere).
I think its interesting that kids spend so much more time in static, unmoving, sitting postures in schools than most of them do playing video games. To be fair, I had more back pain in HS/College from sitting in the wooden torture devices loving dubbed "desks" than I ever have from playing video games ...
I actually have a sore neck today from reading last night. Is reading to blame? Can I alert the Reading Consumer Association owned website ReadPolitics about this issue?
@ Serrenity

That is a VERY good point. The chairs at my middle/highschool were made out of this stuff I can only describe as synthetic sheetrock, and hurt like hell to sit on for any length of time (and I actually have some padding, I can't imagine how my twig-like brother dealt with it).
I my experience, I spent more time hunched over in a bad chair at school than I ever did at home. Hopefully though things have improved since then and schools are kitted out with something more suitable.

The news here is old and obvious, but it's very well worth repeating: Hold any position for too long and you'll break. Twist and bend your back for too long and you'll break. Slouch ill-supported for too long and you'll break. Overexert yourself too much and, you guessed it, you'll break. So read that little leaflet that came with your keyboard (you still have it, right?) and remember that your spine is more important, more valuable, and much harder to replace than your GeForce.
Oh of course, its the video games, it couldn't be the six hours at school in classrooms or sitting at home watching television, it has to be the videogames. What a load.
As a gamer from the age of five, I have sat on the floor in absence of chairs, on a very old sofa, and in the chair in which I'm currently typing this. I have sat in or on these things for hours on end, thoroughly unhealthy behaviour. Not ONCE have I been striken with back-pain by any of these. Only my day-long sessions of marathon reading have ever left me with back pain, and that was with far more activity than with gaming.

@Matthew:
The desks at school are stilll as horrible as those you remember. It is nearly impossible to not feel uncomfortable by the end of the day.
well Wii Sports is sporty. but I'm not that hooked on some simple buggy simulation sport software package. I get more neck aches playing the demo games at Wal-mart when looking up at the screen[recommend Target instead].
I recently got a new chair - this helped my posture since the chair is adjustable in addition to having a back and arm support. (The older chair did have a back support, but it was too flexible to be of use.) Almost right away, it feels a bit more comfortable for the back.

For exercise activity, you need at least something that can be done easily and at almost any time. It could be something as simple as "desk exercises", or some program that can be done at a free pace. Currently, I'm aiming for 100 pushups in a row, which I strongly believe removes tensions from my back shoulder muscles. I'm up to 30-35, which is a long way but has made me feel a bit better.
Video games? Really? I could've sworn it had something to do with being forced to carry 4 text books weighing 7-10 pounds each to school every day in Elementary and Middle school. And I mean forced. If you didn't bring it, Detention.
@Matthew

I don't think school have purchased new desks since they opened
Yeah, a a kid i never really had much back pains dispite my use of games.

Its not until i get into highschool and hand to start carring my books that i started to get sore.

I could easily beat someone to death with the brick called the history book. And 90% of the time we never even used the books, we just had to carry them around.

I remember in highschool my backpack became ripped and torn that i litterly used ducktape, staples and what ever else i could muster in school/home to hold it together.

Now that im older and working, i have tons of back pain. and im doing the most exersise i've ever done in my life as well, as well as sitting on my ass all day.
for the record every now and then doctors like to tell everyone about moderation. its not an attack on us its just telling people not too spend too much time on the couch and if you are also just starting to excersize the boston marathon is a no!
It is somewhat comical that the primary issue here is obesity, yet people go after video games instead of junk food. Bizzaro world!?!?
@GamersRyno

Heh, my own school had a novel solution to combat obesity. Remove the soda fountain in the lunchroom. Nevermind the pizza, cheese filled bread sticks, nachos and other stuff, soda was the downfall of the students
@ xzero87

quote
That is a VERY good point. The chairs at my middle/highschool were made out of this stuff I can only describe as synthetic sheetrock, and hurt like hell to sit on for any length of time (and I actually have some padding, I can’t imagine how my twig-like brother dealt with it).
endquote

For us twigs (see the part of my name that says "sticman"?), sitting in those little torture chambers is presumably about as pleasant as the following thought experiment:

Imagine you are lying belly-down. Now somebody puts a small end table made of lead on your butt (thus all of the weight focuses on the points where the legs touch your buttocks). Then, this horrible individual places an anvil on top of the lead end table.

Stay in this position for about 45 minutes to simulate class length, and allow for some fidgeting on your part so that the legs of the table may sufficiently reposition your internals.

Oh, and I almost forgot. Put a wooden plank on your back and have the evil man stand on it for that time span. And imagine you can feel it on your spine. Skinny people have visible spines when we slouch, which you know is happening in a classroom setting.
or tap dance. Yeah, have him tap dance on the plank.
In other news, living is a precursor of death! Honestly, it's getting tiresome to hear that anything you do can be bad for you. Of course it can! That's why moderation is your best friend - even moderation itself.
[...] Stuff.co.nz Via GamePolitics [...]
meh I have always had back postures I need a back brace that helps postures but tis 80$ >
I've had back pains from sitting in school chairs for several hours a day. So...boo chairs! Boo school!
Its the year 2007 and i swear i have had the same desk since 1996 and i have moved from school to school state to state. The school desk top is made of a laminated press board which has been written on and more than likely puked on, the chair is of a plastic which is either slopped down towards the floor causing you to scoote back in every 5 mintues or is cracked and fixed with ducktape.................Got Tape? The supports for the desk are made of a tin type metal which are uneven and look as if rewelded on by some crazy janitor dude over the summer (Actually happens) and still bends out of shape......... But i have seen the light of a new chair. This chair i speak of is only two materials can you guess? METAL AND PLASTIC !!!! SAVE THE PRESS BOARD!!!! The new chairs have no back support but a giant round shaped hole. The desk top it self seems as if for a 6th grader causing me and my fellow class mates to hunch over to write and read.... AND THE WORST OF ALL... they took out the cool book storage thing under the chair which i proudly used as a foot rest :)....


Old Desks http://www.schooloutfitters.com/catalog/product_info/cPath/CAT202_CAT208...
New Desks
http://www.schooloutfitters.com/catalog/product_info/pfam_id/PFAM2708/pr...

Now you tell me which chair i rather have!!!!!!!! Cheap Schools
oh and as i side note if you want to calculate the comfort scale please

7(hours a day) X 5(days a week) x 4(weeks) x 9(Months) - 1.5(Month Vacation Time/time at lunch/walking around) x 10lb back pack (Average student back pack weight)



1220 Hours in a desk
1200lbs total worn by the student a school year
The most common problem for gamers is their poor posture in front of the console. And of course they keep it for hours in a row. It would help to get up often and walk around a bit. Even do some stretching exercises.

There is no doubt that overweight hurts your back. Especially in the long run. Again a regular switch between pfysical activity and video games is recommended.
I’m Not So Sure About This Surgeon

Picking a surgeon you trust your back to can be a traumatic decision. We like to think all doctors are fully qualified and competent in their specialties, but we also all know it’s not true. Your regular doctor will probably be the person who picks the first surgeon you see. But it’s important to know you don’t have to stick with the surgeon your doctor picks if he or she fails to meet your expectations. If you have any doubts at all about your surgeon, then you need to find another one. You have the right to have your medical records transferred so it’s not like you’re starting all over again. You should make sure you ask the surgeon any question on your mind. A lot of people get shy around doctors or just accept everything they say without question. Doctors are human too, don’t forget. You need to feel completely comfortable with the person who will be operating on you.

Post new comment

By posting comments on this Web site you agree to abide by the Comments Policy.
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This image is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions. The letters in the picture are all UPPER-CASE.
Image CAPTCHA
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.

GamePolitics ShoutBox

Posted 09/07/08 at 06:06pm
BlackIce: Ooh, you sound like you have a problem with skimpy clothing!
Posted 09/07/08 at 04:23pm
DarkSaber: Barely
Posted 09/07/08 at 04:21pm
BlackIce: I believe that a Bikini counts as clothing.
Posted 09/07/08 at 03:53pm
Brokenscope: I'll give a you a hint, its not a shotgun, and its not actually palin.
Posted 09/07/08 at 03:52pm
ZippyDSMlee: GRIZZAM PRIME:I know sad eh? but I try anyway :P
Posted 09/07/08 at 03:27pm
Adamas Draconis: admitidly its a photoshop, but the thought....http://punditkitchen.com/2008/09/03/political-pictures-sarah-palin-photoshopped-b.
Posted 09/07/08 at 03:24pm
Adamas Draconis: theres a pic of her in a bikini with a shotgun...horrifying
Posted 09/07/08 at 01:50pm
BlackIce: Sarah Palin does not look nice. She'd look worse with no clothes on.
Posted 09/07/08 at 01:06pm
sortableturnip: McCain is just a man...he even likes MILF boob ;)
Posted 09/07/08 at 08:47am
HarmlessBunny: @DarkSaber: ROFL
Posted 09/07/08 at 08:26am
DarkSaber: http://sameritech.wordpress.com/2008/08/30/mccain-caught-staring-at-sarah-palin%E2%80%99s-boobs/
Posted 09/07/08 at 05:44am
Matthew: Little-known fact: The LHC is designed to reveal the existence of a meal between breakfast and brunch.
Posted 09/07/08 at 01:38am
GRIZZAM PRIME: Zippy: Better jokes I have heard. Worse too...
Posted 09/07/08 at 01:34am
ZippyDSMlee: Shadow Darkman Anti-Thesis of : its humor...everyone was talking about eating "bunches" the cereal..I just could not ignore it. :P
Posted 09/07/08 at 01:20am
Shadow Darkman Anti-Thesis of : Zippy: WTF?
Posted 09/07/08 at 01:12am
ZippyDSMlee: zippy wants to know...why uuu all eating on poor bunchakneejerk ... =0_o=....LOL
Posted 09/06/08 at 11:38pm
Shadow Darkman Anti-Thesis of : The words of SounDemon in the Nuked Cat thread are LEGENDARY Win!
Posted 09/06/08 at 09:04pm
gamepolitics: but I do love me some brunch, too...
Posted 09/06/08 at 09:01pm
gamepolitics: TJLK - brunch is just breakfast dressed for respectability
Posted 09/06/08 at 05:52pm
Freyar: I prefer Mid-night snack.. Because I can eat in the middle of the night without feeling too stupid, or whatever.
Login or register to post shouts