Tivo Alert: Court TV Looks at Video Game Legislation

August 23, 2007
Fire up the Tivo!

Court TV's Star Jones will examine video game violence and video game legislation at 3:00 P.M. Eastern Time today.

UPDATE: GP has learned that California State Senator Leland Yee will be on the program. Yee, of course, was the architect of his state's 2005 video game law which was recently declared unconstitutional by a federal court judge.

We understand that Katherine Fallow, an attorney who has helped defend the video game industry against legislation, will be on as well.

Not appearing: Jack Thompson, who writes in a comment to this GP article:
I was scheduled last night and this morning to be on this Starr Jones segment. I am now not going to be on. Want to know why?  ...the video game industry people are afraid to go on the air with me.

ECA president Hal Halpin told GamePolitics he would have been pleased to provide counterpoint to Thompson's view, but is flying to PAX this weekend.

Thompson, coincidentally, nixed an opportunity to debate Hal at PAX...

Comments

Star Jones has a job?

She knows law? 0-o

Sorry.. I can't think of anything witty to add, after Zigs and Zippy.

Could there be anyone more unqualified to do this?

I don't know what to say. Are we supposed to be honored to have this topic on a show featuring a failed singer/actress?

Is that how things work these days. You no longer want to work in entertainment so you move to law and politics?

Is it on CNN Newsroom?

@Zachary

She was a lawyer who became a legal analyst who was then hired for the View who then became a "celebrity train wreck" who then became a legal analyst again.

@ GamerDad

Ah. I get it now.

So where does she go after that? Prostitution?

ALA TechSource, in collaboration with the Association of College & Research Libraries (ACRL), held the first annual Gaming, Learning, and Libraries Symposium, July 22-24, 2007, in Chicago. Top gamers, librarians, and others discussed how gaming impacts our nation’s libraries.

Participating in the symposium were Judith Krug, Office for Intellectual Freedom Director, and Katherine Fallow, a partner in Jenner & Block. The presentation, What IF: Gaming, Intellectual Freedom and the Law is available as an MP3 audio file.


http://blogs.ala.org/oif.php?title=what_if_gaming_intellectual_freedom_a...

Sorry misread it as CNN. I have my DVR set to record it since I"ll be at work. Have something to look forward to when I get home tonight. ^_^

She's creepy X.x

Hopefully she'll have some intelligent input on the subject. I fear she may flock with other limelight-loving, ambulence chasing, clueless "legal experts" we all know and loathe.

At this rate she is well on her way to being the next Nancy Grace. All she has to do is get a boyfriend/husband murdered and whore it up for the camera. Oh, and berate her guests into suicide. Well on her way none the less.

"GP has learned that California State Senator Leland Yee will be on the program."

I predict Yee's comments will be something along the lines of "I'm disappointed that the court didn't side with me, hopefully the Supreme Court will agree to overlook the unconstitutionality of my bill. It's for the children afterall."
-- If your wiimote goes snicker-snack, check your wrist-strap...

@ Zigs

I have very little respect for Senator Yee and his stubbourn refusal to accept that his way is not the best to ensure kids do not have access to inappropriate media, but I have even less respect for someone who would use a racist remark like that.

I can agree with people who would berate him for his policies, his actions and his statements in the past, but to insult him because of his ethnicity? If I were moderating this site I would ban you. In making a comment like that, you conform exactly to the stereotype that the anti-gaming brigade has created, an aggressive, hateful, immature person.

Oh, lighten up.

why do we always get these Tivo Alerts the morning of the show? By then we are all at work and can't fire up jack squat, much less the tivo.

I was scheduled last night and this morning to be on this Starr Jones segment. I am now not going to be on. Want to know why? Dennis, you can call me, and I will play the producer's voice mail for you. Better yet, call Beth at 212-973-xxxx, and she will tell you that the video game industry people are afraid to go on the air with me.

So, the great, self-righteous defenders of freedom of expression, of the marketplace of ideas, and who also say that I am a joke and having nothing to say are such sissy cowards that they won't go on a cable news program because they are frightened out of their sorry wits that they can't stand up to the facts of this issue.

If I were the "retard" that they say I am, they would die to be on the air with me to make a monkey of me.

I've been on the Today show eight times and 60 Minutes twice for a reason. I know what I'm talking about, and the industry is scared to death of me. They should be. Hooah!

@Shoehorn O'Plenty

How exactly is calling Leland Yee's mother a whore and father JT racist? Offensive, and this is definitely isn't the place for such insults, but I wouldn't call it racist.

@Shoehorn O'Plenty
I don't think it's that racist, I'm sure many other sites of mainly other ethnicites have made crack-comments like that for white people (or Americans). Plus, it's not like Zigs meant it..

o, and what Gray17 said

This should provide a few worthwhile quotations, i think.

"she will tell you that the video game industry people are afraid to go on the air with me."

Star Jones and Leland Yee sure are industry people all right.

Great way to stop kids from playing games. Make them in china and put tons of lead paint on them. Recall them the next week.

I understand that there will also be an attorney who has represented the game industry against game legislation, so that may be what he is referring to

@ Jack Thompson

I think the reason people from the game industry don't want to be on the show with you is the fact that if you were, they would never get a chance to speak. You would interupt them after the second word and go off on a ten minute speal of your "credentials" and you 60 Minutes interview.

They would rather be on the show with someone who will let them voice their side of the issue.

The problem I had with the statement is that he was using the same tactics as Jack Thompson, attack the person, not their message, opinion or deeds.

Remember when Thompson described Rockstar employees as "Scottish sociopaths"? What does their being scottish have to do with their work? I have said in the past that he is stupid for believing that video games make people into killers, and that he is ignorant for refusing to accept other's point of view. What if I said he was stupid and ignorant because he was an American? Or becuase he was white?

I probably am overreacting a little, but I still think it's idiotic to bring a person's ethnicity into a debate regarding a television appearance they will make and their previous actions against video games. It adds nothing to it.

@ Jack Thompson:

"So, the great, self-righteous defenders of freedom of expression, of the marketplace of ideas, and who also say that I am a joke and having nothing to say are such sissy cowards that they won’t go on a cable news program because they are frightened out of their sorry wits that they can’t stand up to the facts of this issue."

So when your psychologist said "He said that he realizes that he may have offended some with his ad hominem writings, and he will be more moderate in his writing style in the future.", this is the result? Seems like you kept quiet long enough for them to perceive you as reasonable, then when you had your positive report you went straight back to being the rude, deluded person we are so familiar with.

I got a real good feeling that the thing they "fear" with putting JT on the air is getting shitty ratings for the show.

And JT, even Fred Phelps and Michael Crook have been on major shows like that. Who are they? Look them up...see where you rank.

@ Jack Thompson

I agree with Zachary here.

You see Jack, the reason why most people don't like you, is not because of your views...its because your an asshole. You supply some decent facts from time to time, but they are instantly forgotten because soon after you post them, you fling an insult.

Why on earth would the industry want to go on t.v. with someone like that? Its like debating with a child. Because once the debate gets good, you start pitching hissy fits and calling people names.

You just have a real unorthodox way of portraying your views.

I mean Janet Reno? Wtf? Or Penny-Arcade? Gabe and Tycho owned your ass with that check they wrote...and you know it. And you only have yourself to blame for that one.

Its pretty hard to debate with someone who has a history of lying and "stretching" the truth, but can speak with such conviction that people take what you are saying at face value. I'll give Jack credit in that he can be a very charismatic individual and be respectable when he wants to be. Its probably the only thing that has saved his career.

@Zigs... your comments are over the top, today, my friend. See our comments policy.

I would prefer not to wield the ban stick, so please adjust accordingly.

Sen. Yee, by the way, is an American citizen - and I don't believe that I can ever recall any cooperation between Yee and Jack Thompson.

-GP

jt

seriously its COURT tv that means they want REAL lawyers (the hosts aside)

[...] Tivo Alert: Court TV Looks at Video Game Legislation [...]

Spoke to Hal Halpin about this. He said he would have been glad to appear against Jack on Court TV but is flying to PAX this afternoon.

He also reminds me that Jack was offered a chance to debate Hal at PAX this weekend but declined...

Hmmmm watch this or food network?????

meh what the hell i'll check it out

for the record my early post was a jab at nancy grace not star jones (in all fairness i plan to wait till i see the debate to say anything about her work )

just felt the need to clarify

@ Cullarn

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

If I were the “retard” that they say I am, they would die to be on the air with me to make a monkey of me.

I’ve been on the Today show eight times and 60 Minutes twice


man it doesn get any better than this, certainly says alot bout these shows

It's obvious than any show willing to have a clown like Thompson in it is not interested in any real debate and is not worth anyone's time. People who actually get things done have better things to do than getting out of their way to debate a retard. Of course I wouldn't expect someone who sees a massacre as just another opportunity to get his face on TV to be able to even comprehend something like that.

You know what thompson? I call bullshit on your supposed "reason". My 2 year old nephew can blow holes through your supposed truths and theories. If anyone is afraid, especially since there will be someone who has helped defend the game industry against these tax wastes will be on the show, it is you, sera.

"I was scheduled last night and this morning to be on this Starr Jones segment. I am now not going to be on. Want to know why? …the video game industry people are afraid to go on the air with me."

OMFG! Court TV has surfed the internets!

I don't doubt that Game industry people refuse to share air time with Thompson. Buzz Aldrin won't share air time with people like Bart Sibrel but that doesn't make Buzz afraid, just smart. There isn't a shortage of people making the claim but there is a limited number of people who the claim can be made against.

"I am now not going to be on. Want to know why? …the video game industry people are afraid to go on the air with me."

It doesn't bother you that CourtTV cares more about the VG industry than about your presence during the show? No ranting about a conspiracy to keep you silent?

I'm disappointed.
-- If your wiimote goes snicker-snack, check your wrist-strap...

I wonder if Jack's mad that Yee gets to debate the VG industry, but he doesn't? Or does he feel that Yee is incapable of bringing up the appropriate "mental masturbation" quotes at just the right time during the debate?
-- If your wiimote goes snicker-snack, check your wrist-strap...

jt was scheduled until they had the interns hit westlaw and researched his cases then they dropped him like a biohazard container

Dennis, as much as I dont want to put you through the trauma, it would be good if you rang jack and got that voicemail so we could get a transcript.

Who cares? This will be another pointless debate where nothing gets solved.

I second chris' request. I'm also curious to know the real, un-spinned reason why Thompson is not appearing.

Jack is just like Free Waterfall Jr. on the Futurama episode "The Problem With Popplers": always muttering 'Shut up' or, in Jack's case, 'Uh' when other people are speaking.

Did GP redact that phone number?

 GP: yes, I don't want phone numbers for 3rd parties posted here...
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
IanCLisa - what do companies have to do to get a good rating from that site?05/21/2012 - 12:54pm
Andrew EisenI see no logic pills. Thinking the problem is the specific language the MPAA is using to refer to what it's fighting against is what has it on the wrong track.05/21/2012 - 12:47pm
james_fudgehe must have the flu05/21/2012 - 12:16pm
RedMageOkay, who's been putting logic pills in Dodd's coffee?05/21/2012 - 11:54am
RedMageChris Dodd describes MPAA on the 'wrong track', says it isn't right to call infringement theft. http://bit.ly/KeJjJF05/21/2012 - 11:54am
Uncharted NESAlso, the New York Times- http://mobile.nytimes.com/2012/05/21/nyregion/ultra-orthodox-jews-hold-rally-on-internet-at-citi-field.xml05/21/2012 - 11:45am
Uncharted NESAlso, Kotaku's article- http://m.kotaku.com/5911877/40000-orthodox-jews-fill-new-york-stadium-for-internet-rally/gallery/05/21/2012 - 11:37am
Uncharted NESUltra-Orthodox Jews Rally For a More Kosher Internet- http://slashdot.org/palm/30/12/05/21/1217218_1.shtml05/21/2012 - 10:44am
Lisa PhamEvaluation report for Diablo 3 is now up if you're interested... http://www.reclaimyourgame.com/content.php/132-Diablo-305/21/2012 - 8:53am
ZippyDSMleeLOL05/20/2012 - 9:18pm
ZippyDSMleehttp://www.afterdawn.com/news/article.cfm/2012/05/21/gta_iv_r2-d2_attacks_liberty_city05/20/2012 - 9:18pm
ZippyDSMleeThe eff should sue >>05/20/2012 - 3:10am
Lisa PhamD3's online EULA states an offline mode in Section 11... http://sea.blizzard.com/en-sg/company/legal/d3_eula.html05/20/2012 - 12:28am
Andrew EisenFor those of you following the 38 Studios news, a trailer for its in-development Project Copernicus is over at IGN. http://www.ign.com/articles/2012/05/18/project-copernicus-revealed05/18/2012 - 7:33pm
Andrew EisenUncharted - Already covered on GP earlier today.05/18/2012 - 7:25pm
Uncharted NESEA To Provide Free Distribution To Kickstarter Games- http://slashdot.org/palm/10/12/05/18/2058200_1.shtml05/18/2012 - 6:38pm
TechnogeekComcast suspends enforcement of bandwidth cap pending raise to 300GB/month, plans further increases for high-speed tiers: http://goo.gl/b89xma05/18/2012 - 1:31am
Uncharted NESUnofficial Skyrim App Gets Legal Note From Bethesda Lawyers- http://m.kotaku.com/5911035/unofficial-skyrim-app-gets-legal-note-from-bethesda-lawyers05/17/2012 - 2:55pm
Uncharted NESWhen Games Allow Mods, Beautiful Things Can Happen- http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120516/09044318944/when-games-allow-mods-beautiful-things-can-happen.shtml05/16/2012 - 7:46pm
ZippyDSMleeand its working now after a reboot ><05/16/2012 - 7:30pm

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician