ELSPA Denies 90% DS Piracy Quote

February 1, 2008 -
ELSPA officials have completely disavowed a newspaper report in which the organization's head of IP security is quoted as saying that 90% of American DS owners use a particular copyright circumvention device. gi.biz has ELSPA's denial, quoting an unnamed spokesperson:
[IP security head John Hillier] didn't quote The Sunday Post on any figures whatsoever. ELSPA (which represents U.K. game publishers) would certainly never presume to comment about America or anywhere else outside of the UK.

The quotes from The Sunday Post were ascribed to his name from another article which originates from a website in Singapore. This, it appears, is where The Sunday Post first found out about the supposed R4 situation and for some reason unknown to John have quoted him on what this article said.

As far as Nintendo are concerned, the facts are completely spurious.

Comments

Ashton Said: "The games in Singapore are really, REALLY expensive. Last time I was there it cost $80 for a GBA game. GBA! Tales of Eternia cost $120! Imagine game prices that are half the cost of the system or more, and you’ll see why."

According to my friend, the game market in Malta is very similar. The official reason for the high prices is to make up the money lost through imports and piracy (of course), but I believe the actual reason may be something closer to "monopoly, lols."

sheppy Said: "Nintendo once claimed over $500 million lost due to Gamecube piracy in a single year."

Yeah, I really don't trust those figures. I imagine they are obtained on the false idea that--if piracy wasn't available--everyone would just buy those games they pirated.

Makes more sense now.

- Warren Lewis

Which.. Does actually make sense..

I thought so.

I mean I couldn't understand why the ELSPA being Eourpe based was commenting on us here in the states.

Do they have this supposed web site, or are they to assume that since it's likely not in english, no one would care to check up on it?

The original claim was so ridiculous, I'm actually inclined to believe this denial, despite my initial gut reaction to scoff at such convenient excuses in most circumstances.

That said, I agree with DeusPayne, I'd like to know more about this website. No reason for them not to reveal it.

You'd think after that BS the RIAA pulls, that they'd check their facts so they don't have to start damage control.
IP security people never check facts sadly...

I would love to see the article in question as well.

Dennis, any chance we could get a link? Maybe someone should find it for him.

Glad to see that they are retracting that figure. Makes you wonder if anything else in the original article was false as well.

Wow, Andi thought Faux News was bad,.

Well, i feel better about that now. Glad for that misconception being cleared up so fast.

Well there you have it.

Ah, responsible journalism... where have you gone?

"Do they have this supposed web site, or are they to assume that since it’s likely not in english, no one would care to check up on it?"

Singapore's national language is English, so it'd likely be in English.

RIP Journalistic Integrity. You will be missed.

Alright I think I have found the article:

http://www.straitstimes.com/Free/Story/STIStory_193855.html

In this it quotes New Era Entertainment as stating the 90% rate for Singapore, not the US.

@ DeusPayne

They refuted the claim and it's up to the newspaper to come up with their source for the quote. If it wasn't a direct quote then the source should have been mentioned in the article. "Blah blah was quoted in the Singapore Daily Sling as saying 'I saw monkeys fly right out of his ass! Right out!' Blah blah couldn't be reached for further comment." If they didn't do that then the fault is the newspaper's and the burden of proof is on them, not on the guy who was misquoted.

Good job EZK, now....seems that the Sunday Post has some explaining to do....

Wonder if the author of that article in the Sunday Post has written any books? ;)

SHEESH! The editor should be fired for not checking the source of the "facts"

yeah i think the newspaper needs to be held accountable not the elspa

Why would people want to play ROMs on their DS when they have problems? I'd rather go for the actual games because I know there's nothing wrong with them, except for the occasional glitch.

"In this it quotes New Era Entertainment as stating the 90% rate for Singapore, not the US."

And that sounds pretty accurate, actually :)

@Ken

Unfortunately, even amongst working adults with spare cash here in Singapore, the very idea of paying for original games is shocking.
With the exception of some of my friends, I get shocked silence all round whenever I mention buying some game or other.. =(

@JBourrie

Heh, its not THAT high... Though I guess its not exactly a low figure either... =/

@Ken

There are good reasons to use an R4 even if you're perfectly happy to buy your games. Most of them come back to convenience. They're typically used with a 2 gigabyte microSD card, so you can store everything you need to play all your games, listen to mp3s, browse the net*, or even make VOIP calls (with a homebrew application) on a single "cartridge". You don't have to carry a bunch of extra stuff or swap cartridges every time you want to do something different.

Granted, a lot of people just want to play pirated games with them, but not everyone.

*The Opera browser requires the GBA-type memory expansion cartridge that comes with the official product.

"Why would people want to play ROMs on their DS when they have problems? I’d rather go for the actual games because I know there’s nothing wrong with them, except for the occasional glitch."

The games in Singapore are really, REALLY expensive. Last time I was there it cost $80 for a GBA game. GBA! Tales of Eternia cost $120! Imagine game prices that are half the cost of the system or more, and you'll see why. But it's been five years so I don't know about the game prices there but I imagine it can't be that good anyway.

just me or are the 'mainstream' media outlets not even trying these days? i guess they figure no one is reading/watching them anymore anyway they may as well not bother

"Singapore’s national language is English..."

Huh, learn something new every day.

@Ashton,

Suddenly, I don't feel so bad about Malaysia's lack of original games anymore, because even the originals in Malaysia are cheaper than Singapore's.

I can't even remember if the Sunday Post is a tabloid. Beemoh would know..

Although, I'd guess it is. The Tabloids all seem to have something against the Industry, and to a lesser extent the US Population. Right-Wing bastards..

Sunday Post not known for the accuracy or legitimacy of its stories.

I am sorry unless they can dig up hard evidence otherwise THEY RELEASED THE STATEMENT, because the media mafia is that dumb some of the time.

@ZippyDSMlee

If they said they didn't do it, they didn't do it. The evidence that they did is very dodgy.

On one hand, the evidence they said this is little. On the other hand, Nintendo once claimed over $500 million lost due to Gamecube piracy in a single year.

@Diane

Yeah, most piracy figures are worked on the assumption that company X would be amount Y better off for every pirated game downloaded, which is, of course, complete poppycock.

Still, it won't stop someone in Congress from quoting these kinds of numbers. A Lie can travel half way around the world before the Truth can put on it's shoes... or something similar to that. So industry lobbyinsts will quote the 90% and the MAFIAA will get a little stronger.

Someone's been reading Pratchett ;)
 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
MattsworknameWhining about games not haaving enought females, thats foolish, cause if the games are good, then the lead will be well known as a result.see alex vance, she wasn't even the playable lead, but she's so well known cause half life 2 was such an amazing game06/30/2015 - 9:04pm
MattsworknameOn the subject of gaming. Im of the opinion that, its fine if there are more FEMALE leads, but if the game itself isn't good? then your doing a disservice by having a female lead cause they wont get any recognition or attention.06/30/2015 - 9:01pm
Mattsworknameandrew, im not as hyped, without the origional cast, I feel it just won't have the same impact . I'll still give ti a shot, but my expectations are low for it. Its a shame we lost ramis.06/30/2015 - 8:57pm
PHX Corphttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xIojPUPGhjY IWALVG:GameStop Goes RETRO? Let's Check It Out!06/30/2015 - 8:26pm
Andrew Eisen(Ghostbusters is my favorite movie, if anyone was wondering why I'm so unusually excited for this project.)06/30/2015 - 7:01pm
Andrew EisenI am so completely over-the-moon with excitement for the new Ghostbusters movie! It's going to absolutely destroy me if it sucks. Long wait. Fingers crossed!06/30/2015 - 7:00pm
Goth_SkunkAdditionally, the entry really doesn't have much of a point to it. It's just a long, rambling rant akin to what an angsty high-school student would write on their facebook page.06/30/2015 - 6:51pm
MonteAnd most of those viewpoints just so happen to revolve around women and topics that feminists cover, and not actual gaming journalism.06/30/2015 - 6:51pm
Goth_Skunk@DocMelonhead: First off, thanks for using an archive. Second, I would argue that Miss Alexander doesn't know the right women. Given the members of her echo-chamber, I don't find that surprising in the least.06/30/2015 - 6:50pm
Goth_Skunk@Monte: GamerGate does not focus attention on feminists; it focuses its attention on viewpoints it happens to disagree with. The fact that most of those opinions happen to come from radical feminists is a coincidence.06/30/2015 - 6:31pm
Andrew EisenBut hey, we all make bad videos from time to time. I'm certainly not going to hold that single one against her.06/30/2015 - 6:31pm
Andrew EisenAh, okay. I probably don't read their blogs or follow them on Twitter so I've never heard anything they've had to say. The only thing I know about Sommers is the video we reported on a while back and I certainly wouldn't classify that as scholarly!06/30/2015 - 6:30pm
Goth_SkunkAlso, "junior campus feminist" is a young (late teens to late 20's, hence "junior") college student radical activist (see Emma Sulkowicz as an example). This, as opposed to a more mature, scholarly feminist like Sommers.06/30/2015 - 6:24pm
Andrew EisenNo, because "feminisim" isn't a group. There are feminist groups with leaders though.06/30/2015 - 6:23pm
Goth_SkunkDoes Feminism have a leader?06/30/2015 - 6:19pm
Andrew EisenWell, maybe the SPJ Airplay discussion will be just what everyone needed and we'll all live happily ever after!06/30/2015 - 6:16pm
MonteFrankly, for those in it for jounalism, the best thnig they can do is forget GG and find a new Tag. By using GG theybring with themselves all of the baggage that comes with it, and thus no one listens to them. They voices would go farthar without trolls06/30/2015 - 6:12pm
MonteThing is with internaet movements, their is no leadership or membership which means ANYONE can define it and use it as they please. No one member gets to sayhis version is right and everyone else is wrong because his claim is just as valid as theirs06/30/2015 - 6:10pm
MonteGamergate's menaing varies from person to person. Some pretty much allign it with MRA's. Other's do it because they want to defend developers from feminists who criticize their work. This has nothing to do with journalism but gets the Tag anyway06/30/2015 - 6:08pm
DocMelonheadGoth, Take a look at this: It's old, but got a point form the "Gamers are Over" blogger herself: https://web.archive.org/web/20150530072314/http://boingboing.net/2015/05/29/all-the-women-i-know-in-video.html06/30/2015 - 6:08pm
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician