Blogger Sees Racism in Grand Theft Auto Series

March 7, 2008
A unnamed blogger who teaches in a Brooklyn public high school sees racial bias in the ultra-popular Grand Theft Auto series - even though he claims to be a fan.

Big Smoke Street Corner touches on the writer's view of racial stereotyping in GTA as part of a larger discussion on race, language and perceptions:
[GTA's] main audience is clearly suburban white males... [the various GTA games] are praying [sic] on the idea of crime-ridden ultra-violent cesspools run mainly by thoroughly corrupt ethnic minorities...

Having played pretty much the entire series (being, sadly, the resolute gamer I am)... I can not remember a single positive image for Blacks, Mexicans, Cubans, Jamaicans, Colombians, Haitians, Italians, Puerto Ricans, Chinese, Japanese, one Jewish lawyer (!) and soon in the upcoming game, Russians and Serbians; not to mention the constant lampooning of liberals and homosexuals. Mind you, of course, there are never any white gangs...

Rockstar Games...  most common excuse for this insipid behavior is that, because their constant use of stereotypes is so widespread, they cannot be faulted as being racist at any one ethnicity. It’s an equal-opportunity putdown for all!

Comments

Hell they're making of fun of my people in GTA IV, you don't hear me bitching about it. (Irish FTW)

The Wannabes(?) in Vice City, the gang the guy who steals from Diaz runs and gets arrested usually around the mall.

What do I win? Cake?

There are no positive images of anyone in GTA games. The inhabitants of the GTA world are pretty much wihtout exception detestable cretins, and are almost all over the top caricatures of everyone and everything.

As far as lampooning liberals go; How can you look at Ammunation (there are other jokes, but this is the first one that comes to mind) as anything other than lampooning conservatives? Wasn't there an Ammunation commercial in Vice City that referred to the movie "Red Dawn" as a documentary?

I myself am a white, overweight, progressive geek of russian descent. I have played every GTA save for VCS, and I have never felt offended by any of the stereotypes that cover me in these games. They are jokes, and they are fairly spread out over everyone.

If you truly find this stuff offensive, then don't play it. Rockstar is not going to come to your house, type you up, and make you play the game at gunpoint. There are plenty of things in entertainment that I do find offensive, so as a general rule I do not expose myself to them... except for American Idol, but my wife makes me watch that.

@Andy_UK

CJ actually bothered me at first. When I first started playing SA it seemed like CJ was more interested in getting his gang back together than finding out who murdered his mom. He's not any more detestable than his predecessors, but given the setup to the story, it really seemed like his priorities were screwed up.

Erm... I hate not having an edit button. I meant the Aryan Brotherhood, not Aryan Nations. Both are white nationalist groups in any case.

Hehe I can't help but be reminded of a python sketch

Good evening and welcome to another edition of 'Prejudice' - the show that gives you a chance to have a go at Wops, Krauts, Nigs, Eyeties, Gippos, Bubbles, Froggies, Chinks, Yidds, Jocks, Polacks, Paddies and Dagoes.

Racism is all stupid immature shit anyway, people are people, they're ALL fuckwits. The double standards shit me the most, why can a black guy use the word nigger but not me? Attempting to censor my vocabulary is nothing short of criminal! Besides if I were to call a black guy a nigger, he can call me a slaver and we're even. Insult about a horrible moment in history for an insult about a horrible moment in history, sounds fair to me.

James Lowe
They also have a quirky sense of humor so it could be a jab on many levels all in fun, thats a trubble with PC nazis everything is serious business and personal to the point of a grudge beyond the grave.

Nah the movie that really sucked was that tomb raider thing, that sucked more balls than 50 porn stars.

Err and its somehow the fault of racism in GTA3

The lampoon right-wingers pretty often too (does no one pay attention to the talk shows on the car radios but me?)

Maybe if they threw in the cousin-marrying Republican preppies from Bully everyone would be happy.

Controversy over a GTA game? I am shocked!

In other words, like South Park. EVERYONE gets it.

Technically, so do the white males in the GTA series, since THEY'RE the ones they're playing as, and they ARE commiting crimes in the game.

At least, he played the games. Good point.

And Sonny is....?

And the folks on the talk radio are... liberals? I would have taken them for Conservatives.

Nightwng2000
NW2K Software
Nightwng2000 NW2K Software http://www.facebook.com/nightwing2000 Nightwng2000 is now admin to the group "Parents For Education, Not Legislation" on MySpace as http://groups.myspace.com/pfenl

Pfft, my family is origanlly from the Volga German (being the Volga River in Russia.) And you don't here me bitching hell, my step brother full blood russian and the fact the main character is Slavic is why he's getting the game.

Oh, and what races were the two cops who framed CJ?

Nightwng2000
NW2K Software
Nightwng2000 NW2K Software http://www.facebook.com/nightwing2000 Nightwng2000 is now admin to the group "Parents For Education, Not Legislation" on MySpace as http://groups.myspace.com/pfenl

I'll buy it. But it's not nearly as racist as it's copycat, Saints Row. I'm a huge fan of both, but I can't deny that there is some racism in the games. But there is a point there too, they are equal oppertunity offenders.

Personally I though FF12 was the most racist game I've ever played. The only black character in actually has bunny ears and lives in the jungle. That was kind of a WTF? moment. In that game, they literally made the black race jungle bunnies.

No white gangs eh? I guess the Mafia doesn't qualify as a gang. Who knew?

@Mikeu

Never played GTA 3?

*rabble-rabble*

There are plenty of white criminals in the GTA series. What about the Italian mob faction in GTA 3? Donald Love and the Property Tycoon in Vice City? The protagonists in GTA 3 and Vice City? The corrupt cops alongside Tenpenny in San Andreas?

Just as there are bad guys in the games who are of different ethnicities, so too are there ambulance drivers, police officers, soldiers, etc.

There is a certain amount of lampooning of homosexuals as he mentioned, but nothing outright offensive, unless you are an incredibly sensitive soul. Most are silly double entendres or bad puns.

"It’s an equal-opportunity putdown for all!"
A lot of stereotypes do get portrayed, but they are portrayed as such. Rockstar is not saying "This is what the world is like, black people and other ethnic groups are criminals, etc." They take a basic premise (80's Miami, 90's Los Angeles) create a city and populate it with over the top caricatures.

"Mind you, of course, there are never any white gangs…"

What do you think the mafia is?

As for positive black roles, um, hello, Carl Johnson, an african american guy in San Andreas goes to break up a drug ring and deal with corruption in the police force.

And as to my point above, in both GTA3 and Vice city you played as a white guy working for a white guy gang most of the time.

Also, from his article:

"I can not remember a single positive image for Blacks, Mexicans, Cubans, Jamaicans, Colombians, Haitians, Italians, Puerto Ricans, Chinese, Japanese, one Jewish lawyer (!) and soon in the upcoming game, Russians and Serbians"

Funny, I can't remember a single positive image for white people either. Carl Johnson in San Andreas does save a woman from a burning building, which might be the only altruistic event in the whole series. What good deeds have any of the white protagonists accomplished?

White men have a gang in GTA. They're called "The Man". Almost all the cops, judges, politicians, military, spooks, etc. are white men, and they all belong to the same gang. You'll notice that in GTA, The Man is not depicted any better than any other gang. That's racial stereotyping, certainly, but I'm not convinced it reflects racism, since *everyone* is bad in GTA. The charge that he can't think of positive ethnic images in GRAND THEFT AUTO is toothless to the point of ridicule. There are NO positive images in GTA.

GTA is a very cartoony universe. They've been moving towards realism, but it's still very obviously a sarcastic pastiche of reality drawn with intentionally broad strokes. It's also required by sane game design that it be immediately obvious by their appearance to what faction any actor belongs. So, if you have an ethnic group of people who all look alike (I'm sorry, but you do. You know which ethnic group I mean.) you can't let them belong to different factions.

Mikeu, get with the program. Italians? White? You're not thinking like a RACIST!

But isn't CJ's struggle trying to help out and break out a positive image???

trying to put the wrong things right????

As the background for San Andreas is somewhat similar to boyz in the hood, and Cuba Gooding JR's character tries to break out too, I see it as positive image.

I know tha really doesn't focus on the race element but it shows a more positive side.

Maybe?

Either way you are all gona buy it!!!

Funny how theese voices are silent when you mention that there are white bad guys and that you play a black guy in San Andreas.
There really not agaisnt races, everyone knows what they say is meant to be treated as ironic for god sake!

Ummm... Aren't Italians, Jews, Russians and Serbians white anymore? Did I miss something?

GTA 3, The Mafia, GTA SA, They are the ones screwing with the casino that you have to take care of. ALL WHITE

Not to mention the cavalcade of idiotic white characters giving you missions throughout all three games.

Corrupt policemen (white in GTAIII, White and Black in GTA SA)
Corrupt politicians (White in GTA VC,
Corrupt inbred white people (Farmers in SA)
Corrupt white religious people (Radio in VC)

There are plenty of corrupt evil white people in the game. The problem of "no white game" stems from the fact that you are playing the white gang.

GTA is a parody. Get over it.

And the guys you played is in III and Vice City are considered "positive" perceptions of white people?

@ Steve

And you thought they were hot didn't you? :P

@Nightwng2000
that would be hispanic caucasian and african american.

Other caucasian gangs in GTA series:

Russian Mafia
Appearances: GTA:SA

Trailer Park Mafia
Appearances: GTA:VCS

Liberty City Biker Gang
Appearances: GTA:LCS

Biker Gang
Appearances: GTA:VC, GTA:VCS


and if i rememerber right these two were also

Streetwannabes/Sharks
Appearances: GTA:VC, GTA:VCS

Avenging Angels
Appearances: GTA:LCS

They're looking for postive images in GTA.

Positive images.

In GTA.

Lets move on.

Positive stereotypes in GTA? Are there ANY? At all?
But my Irish/Welsh heritage doesn't count for anything anymore. Go figure. I'm just white.

"It’s an equal-opportunity putdown for all!"

I love that part.

This isn't news... every GTA player over the past 5 years has noticed this.

You can find racism anywhere, as long as your looking for it.

The person who invented paper is racist because paper is white and not black!!!

But I got a question, does GTA portray gangs as they would be in reality?

In other words, are minorities more likely to be in gangs.

If so, then GTA did nothing racist, they just portrayed the way these races portray themselves.

If not, then that point it mute.

He forgot to mention that most of the white people in the games whom you get jobs from are sleazy businessmen. but i guess that would disprove his point because we all know you can't be racist against white people. YAY DOUBLE STANDARDS!

aren't we all just people any ways? when i run down someone in the car i don't select by race....i choose by the best target. whatever color in the game they all squish the same. LOLZ

Doesnt corrupt police qualify as being pretty bad?

@Kuros

Guilty as charged.

@ Stranger Danger

Actually it is legal to be racist against White people. White men at least. It is called "Equal Oppurtunity". That law bsically tells the employer if a white guy and a black guy apply for the same position you have to hire the black guy regardless of creditials.

Of course it is more complicated than that, but that is the jist of it.

lets lay off this guy, he's fufilling a need: God knows theres not enough essasys in the world written by frustrated academics.


most people just don't get that grand theft auto is satire.... and satire isn't made to make people look good.

Someone needs to inform this guy that there's a difference between race and ethnicity.

@ Steve:

"Personally I though FF12 was the most racist game I’ve ever played. The only black character in actually has bunny ears and lives in the jungle. That was kind of a WTF? moment. In that game, they literally made the black race jungle bunnies."

I never thought of it that way at all, but regardless, I could listen to Fran read from a phonebook for 30 hours and call it a phenomenal gaming experience. Whoever they got to be her voice actor should have my babies...

What a voice!

I seem to remember a couple of White Blokes break into Niko's flat and hold a shotgun to him. In the trailer at least.

Yes GTA can have positive signs.

Its kinda a story!!!

Maybe I look into it too much!!!

What this person seems to believe is that it is intentional. Rather it's a portrayal of characters and ABSOLUTELY NOTHING MORE. For example, it would seem odd for an all white gang to wear brightly coloured floral shirts, straw fedoras, say "mang", and introduce home invaders to diminutive friends. But apparently if you all thought about Cubans in Miami just then you're racist...so shame on you...you racist person you...and it's of course ludicrous to expect that accurate population distributions should be reflected anyways...I suppose he was expecting SA to say on the boxart "There are no gangs consisting of minorities in California whatsoever. Nope none - these are all just really really really tan anglo saxons - some of them might speak Spanish but they certainly didn't learn that here."

It's not intentionally "insipid" or even remotely malicious. And it's not apart of some conspiracy either. It's a game telling a story - I'm willing to bet theres going to be tonnes of white antagonists in this game because, surprise surprise, how many visually ethnic minorities do you see coming from Russia? I'm from there (originally) and at last check we weren't exactly filled to the brim with multi-coloured citizens.

Some people just look to be offended and will seek out such things quite actively. We can't let games fall victim to the same politically correct slippery slope that plagues so many other aspects of society.


Clever

@Steve

The Viera are the only black characters in FFXII? Is Reddas not black?

Given that the Viera are all female and prance around the jungle in pointy heels and almost no armor... Their role as "jungle bunnies" never crossed my mind.

@PHOENIXZERO

I know man but sadly some people out there just don't get it, there is no such thing as different races for humans, other than the Human Race (everyone). you go back far enough and everyone was one color.

YAY EYES OF NYE! everything I learned I learned from Bill Nye, The Science Guy.

I thought Niko in GTA IV was Eastern-European, not Russian. Is he Serbian? I would of pegged him for being Ukranian, since he sounds a heck of a lot like the Ukranian prof I used to have.
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
Michael ChandraThink so yes, since the judge didn't allow them to add ips at will. :P05/23/2012 - 6:23am
ConsterTPB works fine for me (didn't work the day of the verdict). Apparently they switched IP addresses, meaning Brein has to re-sue to have that added to the block-this list?05/22/2012 - 8:16pm
ZippyDSMleesigh...was playing anice game of empire at war and then boom crash...hope new oparts come soon ><05/22/2012 - 1:17pm
Andrew EisenI still say the particular word or phrase the MPAA uses to describe what it's fighting against is the least of its problems.05/22/2012 - 1:12pm
ZippyDSMleeMPAA finally admits piracy is not the same as stealing, kinda http://tinyurl.com/chtcf8p05/22/2012 - 11:55am
ddrfr33k@EZK Bwahahaha! @Michael: Yeah, several news sources have said that google DNS can bypass the TPB roadblocks.05/22/2012 - 11:38am
Michael ChandraWeird, I can still visit piratebay. Wonder if Google DNS is related to that, or I simply have an exotic ISP?05/22/2012 - 9:03am
Lisa PhamNo harm done, E. Zachary Knight. :)05/22/2012 - 4:50am
Uncharted NESBSA Claims Half of PC Users Are Pirates- http://slashdot.org/palm/17/12/05/22/0051216_1.shtml05/21/2012 - 11:18pm
E. Zachary KnightAh. Missed that. My mind just connected DDR3 with ddrfr33k and ran with it. Oh well.05/21/2012 - 10:12pm
Lisa PhamHe also mentioned the game "Shadows of the damned" which is on PS305/21/2012 - 8:08pm
E. Zachary Knightddrf33k, I think Zip is referring to computer hardware.05/21/2012 - 7:33pm
ddrfr33k@Zip: Excellent game. It's a trip.05/21/2012 - 7:09pm
Lisa PhamIanC - if you read/looked at the report (PDF and written) then you'd see where they failed and why. Some games have come close to passing and some have passed. The list of games evaluated. http://www.reclaimyourgame.com/content.php/18-RYG-Evaluations05/21/2012 - 5:49pm
Andrew EisenMaybe I'll luck out and the Wii version won't have this retail exclusive DLC nonsense.05/21/2012 - 5:12pm
ZippyDSMleeBought new guitar...trying to find a nice DDR3/mobo combo under 200$ sicne I need new ram thats 100$....fun times..... picked up shadows of the damned tho!!05/21/2012 - 4:56pm
E. Zachary KnightYeah, that's how I feel about retail exclusive DLC too. ;)05/21/2012 - 3:37pm
RedMageThat's what I started to figure too. They seem to have trouble coming up with an effective scare tactic. At one point they referred to it as "online looting" which just sounds stupid.05/21/2012 - 3:34pm
E. Zachary KnightOf all the sucky suckiness that ever sucked. Lego Batman 2 will suffer from sucky retailer exclusive DLC. Suck! http://tinyurl.com/ckq67vg05/21/2012 - 3:30pm
E. Zachary KnightAs for Dodd, I think it is mostly that he realizes that calling copyright infringement "theft" is bad for PR and that they need to change tactics. Just like how they went from using "piracy" to using "theft."05/21/2012 - 1:48pm

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician