Lone NY Senator to Vote Against Video Game Law Explains Why to GP Reader

July 31, 2008 -

As GamePolitics reported last month, Sen. Thomas Duane (D) was the lone member of the New York State Senate to vote against a video game bill that was eventually signed into law by Gov. David Paterson. The measure, sponsored by Sen. Andrew Lanza (R) was approved by a 61-1 margin in the New York Senate.

An enterprising GP reader who happens to be a New York resident (and who wishes to remain nameless) wrote to the State Senator regarding his stance on the legislation:

Dear Sen. Duane

 

...I would like to congratulate you on your lone opposition vote on the above referenced bill... As informed citizens are aware, this law addresses none of the issues associated with video games, redundantly mandates provisions that are already in place such as per product industry ratings and console parental controls, establishes yet another toothless advisory committee, and likely constitutes a violation of the First Amendment...
 
I welcome government efforts in the form of education for parents, but do not welcome intrusive government efforts to usurp parents' role as arbiter of their children's exposure to mass media.
 
Sen. Duane's Chief of Staff, Laura Morrison, wrote back:
 
Dear Mr. [GP reader]:

 

...Senator Duane shares many of your concerns about S.6401-A.  He recognizes that there is already an effective, voluntary [ESRB] rating system in place... and that parental controls are available on all current video game consoles.  Parents should determine which games their children have access to and the marketplace should decide which games sell and which do not.  

 

Like you, Senator Duane questions this bill's constitutionality and points to the fact that similar bills have been struck down in other jurisdictions.  He regrets that he was the lone voice in dissent on this matter.

GP: It's great to see gamers involving themselves in the political process and even better to see an elected official who writes back with something more than a form letter.


Comments

Re: Lone NY Senator to Vote Against Video Game Law Explains Why

Personally, I can't blame the GP reader for wishing to remain anonymous. I understand why they would want to. I figure game-bashers like Jack Thompson will start bashing him/her for "allowing makers of violent and/or pornographic material to distribute their products to minors," or some random bullshit like that.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I AM CONDEMNED TO HAUNT THE DREAMS OF JACK THOMPSON UNTIL HIS CRUSADE AGAINST VIDEO GAMES ENDS.



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I AM DOOMED TO HAUNT JACK THOMPSON'S DREAMS UNTIL HIS CRUSADE AGAINST VIDEO GAMES ENDS.

Re: Lone NY Senator to Vote Against Video Game Law Explains Why

I hadn't actually thought of that, but now that you mention it, that's a damn good reason to leave my name out of it.

Re: Lone NY Senator to Vote Against Video Game Law Explains Why

A Democrat NOT voting in favor of government intervention?!Say it ain't so!

Just joking,but this is very weird,nonetheless.

Re: Lone NY Senator to Vote Against Video Game Law Explains Why

Being level headed and logical will probably single-handedly destroy sen duane's political carrier.

Re: Lone NY Senator to Vote Against Video Game Law Explains Why

You say that like it's a BAD thing!

Re: Lone NY Senator to Vote Against Video Game Law Explains Why

Man, he'd get my vote for sure. Kudos to him

Re: Lone NY Senator to Vote Against Video Game Law Explains Why

WOW...

 

...instead of a form letter, he got an informed letter.

Re: Lone NY Senator to Vote Against Video Game Law Explains Why

Man that was bad.

E. Zachary Knight
http://www.editorialgames.com
Oklahoma City Chapter of the ECA
MySpace Page: http://www.myspace.com/okceca
Facebook Page: http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1325674091

Re: Lone NY Senator to Vote Against Video Game Law Explains Why

               the marketplace should decide which games sell and which do not

What kind of crazy talk is that?!!??!

</sarcasm>

 

 

Re: Lone NY Senator to Vote Against Video Game Law Explains Why

More logic in polotics? WTF is this world coming to? :P

Re: Lone NY Senator to Vote Against Video Game Law Explains Why

If that letter was hand written, and he referred to himself throughout as Senator Duane then he deserve to make president.

 

Re: Lone NY Senator to Vote Against Video Game Law Explains Why

"Sen. Duane's Chief of Staff, Laura Morrison, wrote back:"

 

 

Re: Lone NY Senator to Vote Against Video Game Law Explains Why

Must have missed that somehow....

Re: Lone NY Senator to Vote Against Video Game Law Explains Why

I am reminded of an old countpoint for the "Majority wins!" argument back in my college days:

"And who was it that yelled 'Crucify him!' to Pilate?" An angry mob. Majority wins indeed.

Good to see that people like Duane are getting elected. A shame that voices of reason like his are getting muffled out by the clattering of the bandwagon.

 

 

 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Poll

Poll: Is it censorship when a private retailer decides not to sell a particular video game?:

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
Wonderkarpjust be happy and encourage it.05/29/2015 - 7:37am
DocMelonheadSorry about that, but I'm surprise at what IP participate in this discussion.05/29/2015 - 7:25am
E. Zachary KnightIron, I did not Google Search because I figured the ESRB would publish such infor on their site, which is where I looked. http://www.esrb.org/ratings/ratings_process.jsp05/29/2015 - 7:22am
WonderkarpDocMelonHead, don't look a gift horse in the mouth05/29/2015 - 7:21am
E. Zachary KnightDoc, Uncalled for. Please keep things civil.05/29/2015 - 7:21am
MattsworknameThey were discussing the appeals process for Esrb ratings Doc.05/29/2015 - 7:21am
DocMelonheadDid IP post something that isn't related to White Supremecy?05/29/2015 - 7:13am
IronPatriotBut hey, you're welcome.05/29/2015 - 5:23am
Andrew EisenEZK did say he didn't find any info on the appeals process. And if all he did was look at the ratings process part of the ESRB's website, he wouldn't have. That's where I would have looked too. But hey, thanks for being thorough and finding the info.05/29/2015 - 5:01am
Andrew EisenDude, again. I am NOT saying there is no appeals process. THERE OBVIOUSLY IS. All I am saying is that the appeals process is not described in the ratings process part of the ESRB's website.05/29/2015 - 4:59am
IronPatriotI googled appeal esrb.org and it is the first and third hits. Second is esrb talking about appeals for web publishers. Gamefaqs is fourth.05/29/2015 - 4:01am
IronPatriotZachary said he did not find any information about a formal appeals process. I did a simple search and found two places on the esrb site with the info. Just sayin.05/29/2015 - 3:57am
IronPatriotOn Google I get "1 Written Testimony of Patricia E. Vance President ... - ESRB" http://www.esrb.org/about/news/downloads/pvtestimony_6_14_06.pdf05/29/2015 - 3:55am
Andrew EisenNow, that post on GameFAQs was made four years ago. It appears the ESRB has since moved the appeals process stuff behind the publisher login on its website.05/29/2015 - 3:32am
Andrew EisenOh, third link on the Google search. Okay. That leads to a GameFAQs message board which quotes a section of the ESRB website that includes a description of the appeals process. But when you follow the link, that quote doesn't exist.05/29/2015 - 3:30am
Andrew EisenThird link down from what? Look, I'm not arguing the existance of an appeals process. There obviously is one. I was merely noting that it's odd that it isn't described on the website's ratings process section but it is on the mobile site.05/29/2015 - 3:25am
IronPatriotOK, so use the third link down, which describes the appeals process and is not on the mobile site"Publishers also have the ability to appeal an ESRB rating assignment to an Appeals Board, which is made up of publishers, retailers and other professionals."05/29/2015 - 2:47am
Andrew EisenRight, which links to the ESRB's mobile site. On the website (again, unless I'm overlooking it) the appeals process is locked behind the publisher login.05/29/2015 - 2:37am
IronPatriotHuh? Google "appeals esrb". It is the first link. Click it. No login requested.05/29/2015 - 2:31am
Andrew EisenInteresting. It's on the mobile site but unless I'm overlooking it, I don't see it under the Ratings Process on the web site. It is under the publishers section but you can't access it without a login.05/29/2015 - 2:13am
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician