U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark Knight

August 5, 2008 -

Labour MP Keith Vaz, long a critic of violent video games, has taken umbrage to the BBFC's rating of new Batman flick The Dark Knight.

As reported by The Register, Vaz and Conservative MP Iain Duncan Smith object to the film's 12A rating, which means that under 12s can see The Dark Knight if accompanied by their parents:

...Vaz said: "The BBFC should realise there are scenes of gratuitous violence in The Dark Knight to which I would certainly not take my 11-year-old daughter. It should be a 15 classification."

 

Vaz, who has previously railed against video game violence, wants to get the BBFC before his committee's hearings on knife crime later in the year. Presumably its representatives will be required to explain what they think they're doing fostering violent knifey rages in children...

 

The BBFC has defended its rating, admitting that while it was a "borderline" decision, the violence is in over-the-top comic-book fashion and does adhere to the guidelines for a 12A certificate. With a 15 certificate, said spokeswoman Sue Clark, "Younger teenagers would not have been able to see it, and they are the very people who are going to love it. We would have ended up with far more complaints from people who wanted to see the film and couldn't."

 In light of Vaz'z criticism, it's interesting to note that the BBFC will soon take over video game rating chores if the British government has its way.

 


Comments

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

How about a magic trick?

I'm going to make this pencil disappear...


TA-DAA!!  It's gone!

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

A perfect candidate for the new Academy Award I will invent: Scene Most Likely To Ruin Your Shit.

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

Then maybe The Sith Lords should have been given an R rating also, seeing what happened to Anakin at the end.

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

"The BBFC should realise there are scenes of gratuitous violence in The Dark Knight to which I would certainly not take my 11-year-old daughter"

Protip: DON'T FUCKING TAKE HER TO SEE THE MOVIE IF YOU DON'T LIKE IT!!!!!!

 

COmmon sense, so rare it's a super power

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

Protip? I'd say that's a tip even AMATEURS should be aware of.

COmmon sense, so rare it's a super power

I await the next superhero movie: The Logical Knight

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

Anyway, Vaz's daughter is 11, so she wouldn't be allowed entry in the first place. Moreover, the 'A' stands for "Advisory" so it's precisely this kind of rating that empowers parents by leaving the ultimate decision up to them.

-- teh moominz --

-- teh moominz --

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

"Moreover, the 'A' stands for 'Advisory'"

In the context of the rating 12A?  No, no it doesn't.  It means Adult supervision.  A 12 rating means any 12 year old can walk in and see the film on their own.  12A means that they need an adult with them to be able to see it.

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

The UKs 12 is like the US's PG 13 I see now problem with it getting a 12 rating.

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

Honestly, I think this movie could be a reason that maybe the MPAA should make a new rating, in between PG13 and R. I'd honestly have given this movie a 15, because it was pretty dark and gruesome, but not gory. Definatly not R, but stronger than PG13. Basically, not for those under 13, but shouldn't be rated R

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

You see? This is why we like the BBFC!

Also, there's no way the BBFC will kowtow to as inconsequential an MP as Keith Vaz. He really is a laughing stock, almost as maligned as Julian Brazier. If the BBFC were to be forced to acquiece to his demands (a tricky legal conundrum as it is), there would be a public outrcry not last seen since the BBC was almost shackled by the Hutton Report.

-- teh moominz --

-- teh moominz --

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

"We would have ended up with far more complaints from people who wanted to see the film and couldn't."

So classification is attribbuted based on how many people will complain about it...

You see? This is why I hate the BBFC!

They always come up with stupid reasons to justify their decisions. It's like the Manhunt 2 / Eastern Promises cases: For Manhunt 2 it was distasteful and risky so it had to be banned. For Eastern Promises it was artistic expression and people know it's just a movie.

I wish the games industry would refuse to launch games in the UK and Australia for a few months to see how that would work out.

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

No - classification is partly based upon who the intended audience is supposed to be. Also, this is a rezaction to a complaint, so bringing uip counter-complaints is entirely within context.

So you dislike the BBFC for protecting the interests of people who want to go and watch the movie? WTF are you on?

Manhunt 2 is a) an isolated incident and b) ultimately to do with the murder of Stefan Pakeerah, neither of which have any bearing on this. I think you're just hating on them 'cos they don't neatly fit into your preconceived world view.

-- teh moominz --

-- teh moominz --

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

You pretty much validate my whole comment even though you clearly did not understand it.

"this is a rezaction to a complaint, so bringing uip counter-complaints is entirely within context"

It may be in context but it is not at all admissible. Classification should be a clear process adherent to existing rules and guidelines. It is already subjective enough as is. If you start to consider who might or not complain about it when classifying a game then anything is possible.

"So you dislike the BBFC for protecting the interests of people who want to go and watch the movie? WTF are you on?"

I should like them because they let people go and watch this specific movei? It's not about this specific movie, it's about the BBFC's duties and responsabilities and how they justify their actions in general. I think they do a very poor job in explaining their decisions.

"I think you're just hating on them 'cos they don't neatly fit into your preconceived world view."

I don't mean to be confrontational but I could say the exact same thing about you. I explained my reasoning and of course I could be wrong about it.

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

Can I point out that ratings are inherently ALL about taking the general population's preconceived world view?  When rating they go with the moral majority when drawing the line.  With Manhunt 2, they felt the game had gone beyond that line, but the VAC felt otherwise.  The BBFC have in statements before and since then acknowledged that they have to move that line in accordance to the judgement.

Where ratings are concerned, you cannot appease everyone as going with the view of the 'general' population is merely that.  What they CAN do is follow guidelines and stick to their guns in the face of any criticism if they feel that their decision is the correct one.

It is worth noting that some of those who complained about the BBFC not originally giving a rating to Manhunt 2 citing political pressure are also complaining about the 12A rating being given in the face of such political pressure.  You cannot have it both ways.  I believe these 2 examples, which contradict the conspiracy theories, merely prove the BBFC's worth as an independant body.

Incidently, the 12A rating is relatively new to the cinema ratings.  If it were still 12 or 15, I suspect it would have been given a 15.

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

If The Dark Knight was a game, the BBFC would rate it 15, and that's if we're lucky.

/b

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

Actually, you may be right for the wrong reasons.  I thought much of the violence in Dark Knight was almost classical Greek in its presentation; after the opening sequence, almost all of the major violence was done in an offscreen manner (no blood trails, mangled corpses, or whatnot.)  Take the pencil sequence, for example: the guy just drops out of frame.  It's almost comedic.

On the other hand, a video game would certainly demonstrate the violence onscreen due to most of it being performed by the player.  No fun not being able to see what you're doing, right?  So if the violence is of a level to warrant the higher rating (blood, pummeled enemies, depends what path the designers take) then it would be fair to quantify it as such.

I'd be quicker to condemn the BBFC if they gave the same rating to a game as to the movie simply on the basis of their sharing subject matter.  That'd be a big disservice to the people who are supposed to be relying on the ratings as a guide to what they, or their children, should and shouldn't be playing.

---
The Mammon Industry

---
Fangamer

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

Seems my post was swallowed at some point by GP.  Cant even get a log in at the moment despite using the direct email address asking what is going on and multiple attempts to send password again...

12A is a film only rating that gaming does not have due to cinema being a single showing and games being play when you want therefore if the decision between 12A and 15 was borderline, then an equivilent game would be 15 for sure.

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

Looking at teh alst batman game it would be realistic but minus blood and gore.

I is fuzzy brained mew =^^=
http://zippydsmlee.wordpress.com/
(in need of a bad overhaul)

 


Copyright infringement is nothing more than civil disobedience to a bad set of laws. Let's renegotiate them.

---

http://zippydsm.deviantart.com/

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

Best comment by far!

 

Holy Logical Batman

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

Hmmm... good point, well made.

-- teh moominz --

-- teh moominz --

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

Oh spare me, what a load of nonsense. Got any proof of that, or are you just assuming that the BBFC are playing a game called "PEGI" the purpose of which is to hand out ratings without looking at the material?

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

mommies/bunchakneejrks

The UK has 12 and 15, its mreo reasonable for the film to be sloted to 15 and if a game was made depending on certain tigns it could be 15 as well and thats befor you add any blood/gore. 

I is fuzzy brained mew =^^=
http://zippydsmlee.wordpress.com/
(in need of a bad overhaul)

 


Copyright infringement is nothing more than civil disobedience to a bad set of laws. Let's renegotiate them.

---

http://zippydsm.deviantart.com/

Re: U.K. Video Game Critic Keith Vaz Has a New Target: The Dark

Evidence? Piss off beemoh, I know you mean well but that's a trollish statement right there.

MASS EFFECT. That is all.

-- teh moominz --

-- teh moominz --
 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
TechnogeekFor a change of pace, here's a story about death threats aimed at games industry employees via Twitter that has nothing whatsoever to do with Gamergate: http://kotaku.com/indie-dev-threatens-gabe-newell-has-game-removed-from-164867886910/21/2014 - 4:38am
MechaCrashThey aren't being held accountable because *this is what GamerGate is really about.* Hatred and harassment under a thin veneer of concern for ethics; it's a rotten movement right down to the core. Related: http://tinyurl.com/o5mamgn10/21/2014 - 1:53am
james_fudgeodd why would they delete pro vita comments?10/21/2014 - 12:50am
Neo_DrKefkaI am a little disturbed that members of #GamerGate are supporting and not holding its same members accountable when they say remarks that are unacceptable!10/20/2014 - 11:39pm
Neo_DrKefkaSome #GamerGate people are defending @kingofpol many are however lashing out at him but if we held Sam Biddle accountable and Gawker so must we hold @kingofpol and #GamerGate10/20/2014 - 11:30pm
Neo_DrKefkaA big name in the Gamergate movement Kingofpol uses a offensive term about autistic people and in turn the entire GamerGate community lashes out at him. We do not need false leaders who think they can say anything https://twitter.com/Kingofpol10/20/2014 - 11:07pm
Papa MidnightMP, honestly, I'm struggling to make heads or tales of the events being outlined in that reddit thread. I've never heard of Siliconera before, either.10/20/2014 - 10:48pm
MaskedPixelantehttp://www.reddit.com/r/vita/comments/2jbn6u/former_siliconera_moderator_leaks_screenshots_of/ Siliconera mods accused of deleting user comments that were pro Vita.10/20/2014 - 9:23pm
quiknkoldhttp://www.diamondbackonline.com/opinion/article_3fbc52ec-57eb-11e4-ba91-0017a43b2370.html10/20/2014 - 9:16pm
Neo_DrKefkaId love to see people come 2gether whether your 4 or against gamergate to gather 2gether and support an anti bullying charity and I would love to see a pro and anti gamegate debate on a neutral platform that promotes discussion and solutions10/20/2014 - 8:33pm
Neo_DrKefkaWhen someone was seriously hurt by a violent altercation. They have a prospective that people who have not had this experience lack. Bullying is a serious issue10/20/2014 - 8:30pm
Papa MidnightStraw Man to the fullest, but it gets the point across.10/20/2014 - 8:26pm
Papa Midnighthttp://i.imgur.com/dw0YPon.png10/20/2014 - 8:25pm
quiknkoldby doing something, Charitable Donations is an example.10/20/2014 - 8:06pm
quiknkoldAndrew : I dont accept any worded apology unless I can look the person in the eye when they say it. For me, he'd either have to make a video so I could read his bodylanguage, or actually do something. actions speak louder than words.10/20/2014 - 8:04pm
quiknkoldwell if they are looking for social pollution, Twitter is a great breeding ground for it. Its a breeding ground for deviance.10/20/2014 - 8:03pm
Andrew Eisenquiknkold - He had three tweets worth of apology the following day.10/20/2014 - 8:00pm
quiknkoldyou know, people keep saying Biddle's comment was sarcasm, but the thing is, Sarcasm doesnt translate well in Tweets. I took his words as really hateful, and unless I see an honest apology, I'm not going to be happy with him.10/20/2014 - 7:38pm
Matthew WilsonI doubt it will change much.10/20/2014 - 7:21pm
MaskedPixelantehttp://www.bbc.com/news/technology-29689949 Google's current piracy fighting plan.10/20/2014 - 6:58pm
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician