Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

February 26, 2009 -

Writing for UK newspaper The Guardian, author Cory Doctorow offers an eminently sensible fix for those confusing, consumer-unfriendly End User License Agreements:

Here's the world's shortest, fairest, and simplest licence agreement: "Don't violate copyright law." If I had my way, every digital download from the music in the iTunes and Amazon MP3 store, to the ebooks for the Kindle and Sony Reader, to the games for your Xbox, would bear this – and only this – as its licence agreement.

"Don't violate copyright law" has a lot going for it, but the best thing about it is what it signals to the purchaser, namely: "You are not about to get screwed."

Cory also finds irony in the approach which content rights-holder take on the copyright issue:

The copyright wars have produced some odd and funny outcomes, but I think the oddest was when the record industry began to campaign for more copyright education on the grounds that young people were growing up without the moral sensibility that they need to become functional members of society.

The same companies that spent decades telling lawmakers that they were explicitly not the guardians of the morality of the young – that they couldn't be held accountable for sex, drugs and rock'n'roll, for gangsta rap, for drug-fuelled dance-parties – did a complete reversal and began to beat their chests about the corrupting influence of downloading on the poor kiddies.

Ditto for the video game industry. As GamePolitics has reported in the past, game publishing lobby group ESA hopes to takes its anti-piracy "education" program into elementary schools.


Comments

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

 

"Don't violate copyright law"

 

That seems a bit silly.  Contracts create rights and obligations between parties.  Consumers are already legally required to not violate copyright law.  It is, after all, the law.  If people violate copyright law, the copyright holders can pursue legal remedies regardless of any promises in an ELUA to not break the law.

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

Easy for him to say when he's got rms and his katanas backing him up.

------ Ago. Perceptum. Teneo.

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

Not sure who called this idea brilliant.  Corey perhaps?

 

The EULA is a legal straw man.  It's a scarecrow meant to give lawyers something to send out C&D letters to people they don't like.

If it had ever been given a serious legal challenge I would say that we need to do something about it.

 

As for education.  Teach children product liability law, teach them lemon laws, consumer protection laws and the bill of rights and then let them laugh at the EULA and tell the corporations that their petty little slip of paper isn't going to protect their failing business model from the innovations of the next generation.

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

"If it had ever been given a serious legal challenge I would say that we need to do something about it."

Blizz V. MDY

This is from a blog paraphrasing the end ruling thus far (as far as I know there's still an appeal process to go through).

"Blizzard argued, and Judge Campbell agreed, that when users violated the World of Warcraft EULA, they no longer had a license to play the game and were therefore guilty of copyright infringement."

I'm trying to find a better source, I had one a while back that was following the whole story but I don't remember where it was now.

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

I must chuckle at the irony he pointed out, but the phrase of "Don't violate copyright law" is too vague for many uses. Basically that doesn't do much except strip away all rights since everything basically requires that you break the copyright protection on it just so you can play your damn game. So in other words, you just make the law-abiding gamers criminals and treat them with more shit than being thankful for them actually buying but then immediately call them a pirate because of bugs that are out of their control.

Oh, and whenever you make a back-up they'll call it violating copyright law as well, despite the fact it is suppose to be the exception to that, besides fair use laws. Typically, I find that the moment you agree to an EULA, you basically say, "I'm ready to get screwed and hope it doesn't happen to me."

In my eyes, none of this is a fix. This is just beating around the issue instead of making these things illegal or something.

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

I don't like it. "Copyright law" is too vauge and still doesn't solve fair use issues like the cracking of DRM for personal use being illegal. And the EULA changes as law changes.

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

To be honest, even though there are tons of DRMs and such out there, Doctorow's proposed EULA is really all the gaming and music industry have right now.  There is nothing (that I know of) that 100% prevents someone from copying the data from a game or music file stored on any device.  If there is a will there is a way, and the consumers have shown there is definitely a will.

www.20sidedwoman.blogspot.com

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

(read my entire comment before replying)

Too bad for the music and game industry. As the world changes, so must they.

Or they could keep getting more and more hypocritical and piracy could become easier and completely untraceable to the point that law enforcement can't get ahold of REAL internet criminals because the pirates have created the demand for complete online anonymity.

I can just hear it now, rap music talking about the evils of copyright law on the same album about nailing a prostitute.

Why not have a computer accessible in the next GTA game? If the protagonist tries to pirate something, give them a moral lesson about the dangers of piracy! Or you could even turn the entire prostitute faction against him! Militant sluts ftw.

<rant>

Here's an EULA for them that I'll claim to have spoken to every checkout clerk : "By selling me this title you agree that I own a single copy of this software and can do whatever the hell I want with it."

Since there is no paper trail in a verbal agreement, and there is none in an EULA, I figure that this is about as legally binding.

</rant>

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

Didn't he first propose that EULA ages ago?


The Devourer of Time awaits... Lord, grant me the strength to finish what I

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

Here's the world's shortest, fairest, and simplest licence agreement: "Don't violate copyright law."

...and I am sure by then, Hell will freeze over.

Not being critical here, but I see no solid solution for the EULA problem.

______________________________ Because I have NO Life... :P I introduce the following. PSN User ID: FirebirdXR (Yes, I use that moniker often) Xbox Live ID: FirebirdLR (Don't bother, It's a Silver Membership) *Limited Time Only* I put both because I

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

Don't copy that floppy!

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

I'm scared of EULAs because I'm worried it may make game modding illegal, even when the mods are designed such that you need the original game to run them.

Also, I think that sort of EULA is particularly ridiculous since the reason I want to make game mods is so that I can send them to the company that makes the game as a sort of tech demo for what I'd like to see from them in the future.

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

Theoretically some do, and there have been threats brought about onto modders who push it too far. A special case would be morroblivion, which required an installed copy of morrowind+tribunal+bloodmoon. It, through batch files and an installer, (Intended to) ported all of morrowind's content into oblivion.

It was shut down and later picked back up, i don't know what the current status is.

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

In addition to "don't violate copyright law", a reasonable EULA might also say "you may also do the following things, otherwise prohibited by copyright law, subject to the following terms and conditions". Open Source licenses are often a good example of such a principle.

Unfortunately, most EULA's go beyond this reasonable principle and attempt create new rules out of thin air.

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

Except those aren't EULAs. Some of the OSS licenses explicitly disclaim being a EULA (see GPLv2).

Maybe pull false advertising claims on the companies? EULAs aren't licenses, they aren't granting something you'd not have otherwise.

 

 

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

EULAs and Open Source Licenses are both adhesion contracts. It's just that Open Source licenses are adhesion contracts done right.

The trick the commercial software publishers are pulling is trying to get you to agree to a license when you absolutely don't have to. They want to sell you software retail, but treat the transaction as if it weren't a sale. It's basically a scam.

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

It's treated more as a rental rather than a purchase.

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

God of War DRM right? 3-year rental. ^_^

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

Uh... I thought that was Gears of War

Doublepost

*edit* double posted.

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

Ive made that same mistake of galling Gears god more times than I can fucking count. Too many GoW's...

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

There are hundreds of thousands of lawyers working all the time on copyright law cases. If copyright law was so simple that you could just say "don't violate it", then those lawyers wouldn't need to exist.

---------------------------------

Internet troll > internet paladin

-------------------------------------------------------- Believe in something! Even if it's wrong, believe in it! GET OFF MY PHONE! -Glenn Beck

Re: Cory Doctorow Has a Brilliant Idea to Fix EULA Mess

Sadly, I don't see it happening, as that is too simple ane would leave too much open t oconsumers, at least how the copyright holders would likely see it.

 

"game publishing lobby group ESA hopes to takes its anti-piracy "education" program into elementary schools."

That can not turn out good. I can see it now.

"IF you see a video game for sale at a yard sale ,report it to a police officer, because that person, is a pirate"

 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Poll

Did Microsoft pay too much ($2.5 billion) for Minecraft developer Mojang?:

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
Andrew EisenKrono - Many of the people pushing gender issues aren't nice people? I'm sure not everyone's a sweatheart but so far, everyone I've seen with such a critique had absolutely nothing to back them up.09/19/2014 - 10:46am
InfophileI think there's a qualitative difference between a site and a hashtag though. GP can ban anyone from commenting, so they can have the image they want. But anyone can use any hashtag and try to poison it. Granted, that hasn't happened to the other one yet09/19/2014 - 10:13am
E. Zachary KnightKrono, your comparison to GP does not work. We do not need to get rid of GP, because no one associates GP with trolls and abuse. The same can't be said for gamergate.09/19/2014 - 10:09am
Krono@Michael You don't remember the "other hashtag" because no one actually uses it. We're talking 836,983 uses of #gamergate over it's lifetime, and 8,119 for the "alternative". 47,129 uses on the 18th vs 41. With #notyourshield at 140,133 uses & 5,209 uses09/19/2014 - 9:48am
Kronoresearch it. Changing tags to get away from trolls would be like wiping GamePolitics and restarting under a new name to get away from people calling Jack Thompson a filthy names in the comments section.09/19/2014 - 9:35am
Sleaker@quiknkold - seems like all that page is is a bunch of random developer opinions and rumors that we're supposedto do what with?09/19/2014 - 9:31am
Kronoas an opportunity to push back against them. It's one of the things muddling the issue. @conster A new hashtag would do nothing to improve anything. Trolls will simply follow to the new hashtag, and it will confuse the issue for anyone attempting to09/19/2014 - 9:25am
Krono@Andrew aaah. Yes, I'm sure there's some of that. Part of the problem is many of the people pushing gender issues are not very nice people. Basically the latest incarnation of moralists we've seen in the past couple decades. Naturually some will take this09/19/2014 - 9:23am
quiknkoldhttp://www.nichegamer.net/2014/09/real-gamedevs-sound-off-regarding-the-gamergate-controversy/09/19/2014 - 8:35am
MaskedPixelanteMeanwhile, in news that actually DOES matter, Scotland voted "NO" to Scottish independance.09/19/2014 - 8:20am
ConsterSeriously? "We shouldn't make a new hashtag - it's better to associate ourselves with psychos than to decrease our visibility"?09/19/2014 - 7:54am
Michael ChandraI forget what it is exactly, but there already is another hashtag that some use, exactly to separate themselves from the abusive behaviour. So don't bother lying to me.09/19/2014 - 7:06am
quiknkold2 to 3 or more09/19/2014 - 6:53am
quiknkoldMichael Chandra : I'll say this. The only reason they havent used another hashtag is because it would look like a form of dividing the arguement. Using another Hashtag has come up, and they feel like if they made a new hashtag, it'll split the debate from09/19/2014 - 6:53am
Michael ChandraYou want a debate? Build a wall between you and the poisoned well. Make clear you despise it, despise the behaviour. Then get into the other issues you are troubled with, and don't say a single word again about the poisoned well.09/19/2014 - 3:46am
Michael ChandraAnd someone claiming #notyourshield was to be taken serious, when chatlogs show they wanted it going to hide even more harassment behind? Yeah, not buying a word you're saying. You poisoned your own well.09/19/2014 - 3:45am
Michael Chandraallegedly fired over giving a game a mediocre review and the company threatened to pull ads? Sorry but I ain't buying this.09/19/2014 - 3:45am
Michael ChandraBut people arguing this is horrible and just about ethics, even though there's very little support that journalistic integrity was actually violated here, while they never spoke up when a journalist was09/19/2014 - 3:43am
Michael ChandraIf people start with condemning the way GamersGate was used as a misdirection, then use a better hashtag, that would work in convincing me they mean it.09/19/2014 - 3:43am
Andrew EisenOoo, this one came down to the wire! https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/749082525/nefarious09/19/2014 - 1:03am
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician