Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

April 8, 2009 -

While researchers Douglas Gentile (left) and Craig Anderson have often been critical of violent video games, a new report from the Iowa State University professors indicates that non-violent games may enhance pro-social behavior in chidlren.

As reported by isciences, an Iowa State reasearch team led by Gentile and overseen by Anderson studied school children in Singapore, Japan as well as college students in the United States:

College students... who were randomly assigned to play prosocial games (Chibi Robo and Super Mario Sunshine) behaved more prosocially... in a subsequent task than those who played either neutral (Pure Pinball and Super Monkey Ball Deluxe) or violent video games (Ty2 or Crash Trinsanity). Those who played the violent games engaged in more harmful behaviors...

"Video games are not inherently good or bad," wrote the researchers in the paper. "Video games can have both positive and negative effects.

"Content matters, and games are excellent teachers," they continued. "Violent content in video games can lead people to behave more aggressively. Prosocial content, in contrast, can lead people to behave in a more cooperative and helpful manner."

VG Researcher has more. Read the study abstract here.


Comments

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

I think the problem with a lot of these violence studies is they generalize the violence in the games.   You have to play the games to see where the real problems are.   Your not going to get gamers to go along with the idea that they cant slay enemy and feel like a hero in someway and get upgraded for it.    You can however get more personal with the games that are being looked at and see there IS a problem.   The developers them selves are adding little things that nudge the player into a more negative personality perspective. One that is socially hostile.   You don't really want gamers for instance killing neighbors pets but in many of these games free kills[easy] of helpless pet or livestock animals is added as a "fun" part of games.   What really needs to be looked at is the personality that the game is nudging the player to portray.  Why do devs do this?   Honestly I think some of them are playing a game of their own to see just how far they can push the envelope.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

Are you kidding me? Mario jumps on turtles to smash them out of their shells, stomps other critters into the ground, hurls fireballs at his enemies, and in general is just one badass of a plumber.

Speaking of which, the goombas look like poo in some of the games. Connection with being a plumber? I think so!

I will not buy securom games. http://www.wolvenmoon.com/sharedfiles/message1.jpg and http://www.wolvenmoon.com/sharedfiles/message2.jpg

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

For those of you who still remember, the instruction booklet for the first Super Mario Bros. paints a darker story. The "koopa tribe" magically turned the peaceful inhabitants of the Mushroom Kingdom into bricks, plants and boulders. So even when you smash bricks, you are harming people!

GameSnooper

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

Well, this study is coherent with Douglas Gentile's previous studies and talks. Among game critics, he's always been "the voice of the reason" (as he demonstrated it during last year's "Video games and violence" conference). I've already emailed him personally, and he offered me a very kind reply, though we had some disagreements. But at least, he's someone we can discuss with (unlike You Know Which Disbarred Attorney).

Furthermore, I'm quite relieved that video game studies no longer focus on negative effects and "negative games"... although I understand fellow GP readers' concerns.

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

Huh...not sure why that double posted.  Sorry!

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

It is, of course, a matter of degree.  Compared with JT almost anyone is going to seem like "the voice of reason".  It is worth noting that this research group has accepted grant funding from The National Institute of the Media and the Family in the past (and I think Dr. Gentile is actually on their board).  Although this doesn't mean we should necessarily discard anything that they say, I think it could point to an obvious "axe to grind" with which we should be aware (particularly since the same group like to complain that any of their critics are "in bed" with the video game industry). 

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

It does interest me that they specify children's behaviour.  One of the key arguments of the adult gaming crowd is that M-rated games aren't made for children, and this appears to confirm that.  But that said, I suspect the effects are more subtle than the report lets on.  After watching a violent movie, people feel a little more aggressive; after a few sitcoms, they're relaxed and more cheerful.  It's the same with games.  You're going to get different reactions out of two people if one of them was just playing CoD4 and the other was on Kirby's Adventure.

The post on VG Researcher also mentions that the results determined prosociability and aggression weren't mutually exclusive -- it's a complicated spectrum.  This is one of those cases where I suspect an awful lot of people are going to jerk their knees and end up banging them on the underside of the desk when they should be keeping cool and reading the full report.  (And that's on both sides of the debate.)

---
The Mammon Philosophy

---
Fangamer

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

Define "prosocial"

That is to say are all prosocial behaviors passive or non aggressive?

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

Janarius here, sorry I didn't include the definition of prosocial behaviours: "...define prosocial behaviors as those intended to help others."

 

http://vgresearcher.wordpress.com/

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

Pro-social behaviors are definitely not passive,  well at least in terms of being passive instead of being active.  As far as prosocial behaviors being non agressive, for the most part they won't be aggressive but this is not to say they can't be somewhat.  Many team sports would likely both constitute prosocial behavior and have some degree of aggression.  However, it's quite possible that the study's operational definition of pro social is different.

With all these studies it ultimately comes down to Albert Bandura's Social Cognitive theory, which the two figures in the full study illustrate fairly well.  Basically kids acquire new behaviors by observing them. The likelihood that these behaviors will be enacted in the future is then affected by the consequences.  This actually leads to a rather interesting idea given that prosocial behaviors should generally have positive consequences and violent behaviors should generally have negative consequences.  Therefore, the positive effects of video games should generally outweigh the bad.

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

I agree. Is it prosocial to defend someone who is being mugged? Is it prosocial to help someone cheat on a test? What exactly do they mean by prosocial?

If they wanted to study prosocial behavior, perhaps they would have done better to have people play co-op games of varying violence levels. That would be cool.

I still want to see a better study of aggression caused by gaming. I would like to see a study done with people playing various competitive games. Games can include, FPS, RTS, Sports, Party and even non video games like card games. Under card games you can have people play Hearts and Spoons and see how aggression levels change playing those compared to games.

The point is, they are really aiming narrowly without any idea of the broader subject. When doing research like this, you need to start large and slowly narrow the study. Not start with a narrow test group and say you are done.

E. Zachary Knight
Oklahoma City Chapter of the ECA
http://www.theeca.com/chapters_oklahoma

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

I'm with Avalongod here.  To embrace this study ends up putting us in the same boat as Hollywood - "Our media can't make people do bad things!  But it makes them do good things all the time!"

More importantly, I'm with several folks who've pointed out that their methodology is... questionable.

Chibi Robo and Mario Sunshine?  Well... I know one of them involves earning your keep as a tiny little robot trying to help out around the house, so I guess that's pro-social.

Ty 2 though?  Well... more violent than Chibi Robo (I think), but it's not pro-social to try saving your friends and neighbors from an invading force (or is that the plot to Ty 1?)

At any rate... yeah, pro-social, neutral, anti-social are things I'd want to see defined, along with 'pro-social' behavior.  I mean... okay, how about Call of Duty?  Last I checked, fighting the Nazis was generally considered a good thing to do....

Politics, Religion, and Particle Physics http://dttaboos.wordpress.com

Politics, Religion, and Particle Physics http://dttaboos.wordpress.com

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

I hate to be a kill-joy about this, but I think this is simply part of their larger agenda to show how large an impact games supposedly have on behavior, and if people would only play nice sweet prosocial games, how everything would be right with youth-today.  To view this as a pro-game study would be a serious mistake.  Just my opinion.

As with many of these studies (prosocial or aggression) I'd be concerned that the participants are able to guess the hypothesis and just try to give the results the scientists want.  Particularly since many of these studies use psychology students, the participants are probably pretty good at guessing the hypotheses.

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

VG Researcher says that a debriefing screening process was used to weed out participants who may have suspected the nature of the experiments.  They also used a range of ages down to the fifth grade.  You'd have to be a real psycho to get past that level of scrutiny.

---
The Mammon Philosophy

---
Fangamer

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

Not really.  I'd guess that a fair amount of students who are trying to "go along" with a study in the first place will also know enough not to admit dubiousness when asked.  I'm skeptical by nature, sure, but I have concerns that these "debriefings" work as advertised, although that goes for all psyche research, not just VG studies. 

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

Much confirmation bias I sense in you.


If you go crazy then I will still call you Superman.

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

Hmmm, it's funny I never feel more social after I play a non-violent game.

Besides, how much fun can you have as mario--pretending to be a mad italian jumping on turtles...
 

Praetorian

"If you sit by the river long enough, you will see the body of your enemy floating by."

http://www.myspace.com/pree_tawr_ee_uhn



Praetorian

"If you sit by the river long enough, you will see the body of your enemy floating by."

http://www.myspace.com/pree_tawr_ee_uhn

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

Ty 2? Crash Twinsanity? Violent? Really?

Super Mario Sunshine, personal? (can't speak for Chibi Robo)

 

...no, I'm going to go ahead and say this study is worthless.

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

 Likewise. I've always been a bit of a loner, and have always stuck to single players. I don't do a lot of multi-players, especially competitive game play cause I always get my ass kicked (and I do so well against a computer, too...sigh)

While I do believe games DO have positive effects, and it's only logical to say the opposite is true, this study can go into the games-are-evil-study bin.

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

As non-violent as Mario is, how is it prosocial? It's single player. Did they try any MMOs like Animal Crossing?

While we need to take any and all studies with a grain of salt, this one does seem to be more non-biased than most. I still believe many of these "effects" of games, good and bad, are pretty mild and can be self-controlled.

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

I don't think they mean "social" as in getting along with people, but rather in participation with society.  Mario Sunshine's pro-environment message would be a good choice for that -- presumably after playing, the subjects were observed placing their trash in appropriate receptacles on a more consistent basis.

Edit: on further investigation, it seems the level of sociability was determined by getting the subjects to pick out a selection of tangram puzzles for a partner who they were told would try to solve them quickly to earn a gift certificate, then seeing if they gave them the easier or more difficult ones.  The pro-social players did trend towards giving the easier puzzles, and there was a greater difference between the pro- and the neutral versus the neutral and the anti-.  Very interesting result.

---
The Mammon Philosophy

---
Fangamer

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

Gamers like to be rewarded in their games, it makes sense we would like to pass that feeling of accomplishment around! We're all a bunch if hippies at heart! 

--------------------------------------------------

I LIKE the fence. I get 2 groups to laugh at then.

-------------------------------------------------- I LIKE the fence. I get 2 groups to laugh at then.

Re: Study: Non-violent Games May Enhance Pro-social Behavior

Seems to me the results of this study were predestined. What about games that are social and violent like left 4 dead.

 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Poll

Which group is more ethically challenged?:

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
Andrew EisenSee? Suggestions for improvements that involve taking things away do not mean the work is garbage or performing poorly, critically or commercially.07/01/2015 - 9:29pm
Andrew EisenSkyward Sword is spiff-a-rific but it would be an improved experience if the game didn't explain what each item and rupee was every single time you picked them up!07/01/2015 - 9:27pm
Andrew EisenHere's another: De Blob is a ton of fun but it would be improved without motion controls. Incidentally, THQ heard our cries, removed motion controls for the sequel and it was a better game for it!07/01/2015 - 9:24pm
Andrew EisenI'll give you an example: Arkham Knight is a ton of fun but the tank sucks and the game would be even better without it.07/01/2015 - 9:23pm
Goth_SkunkWell clearly we're diametrically opposed about that.07/01/2015 - 9:03pm
Andrew EisenNot even remotely true.07/01/2015 - 8:59pm
Goth_SkunkIt is, if the suggestion involves taking something away from a product in order to make it better.07/01/2015 - 8:49pm
Andrew EisenOffering suggestions for improvement does not mean that the work in question is garbage or not doing fine.07/01/2015 - 8:21pm
Goth_SkunkIf their products were garbage, they wouldn't be as praiseworthy as they are.07/01/2015 - 8:08pm
Goth_SkunkAnd Andrew, I really don't think GRRM or the producers of the Game of Thrones TV show need anyone to tell them what to do to make their products better.They appear to be doing just fine on their own.07/01/2015 - 8:07pm
Goth_SkunkThe only thing not worth talking about, is what shouldn't be talked about.07/01/2015 - 7:47pm
Goth_Skunk@Infophile: It could be a reason, if I were wrong. I'm not.07/01/2015 - 7:44pm
PHX Corphttp://kotaku.com/steam-players-take-justice-into-their-own-hands-virtua-1715215648 anyone seen this, Steam Players Make Their Own Justice, Virtually Imprison Troll07/01/2015 - 7:17pm
Andrew EisenHeh, just had our (IGN's) journalistic integrity called into question over two typos on one of the Wikis (which are editable by the readers).07/01/2015 - 6:08pm
Matthew Wilson@tech this isnt the only stupid tax in recent months though. they were adding a commuter tax as well. if they continue doing crap like this, they will run in to the same issues as Detroit.07/01/2015 - 5:34pm
TechnogeekI guess we can give Chicago credit for diversifying their portfolio of corruption, although they've still got a lot of work before they retake that crown from Louisiana.07/01/2015 - 5:29pm
TechnogeekEh, cities abusing taxation power for their own game isn't really a "Detroit" thing so much as a "corrupt small town" thing.07/01/2015 - 5:29pm
Matthew Wilsonhttp://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/07/chicago-netflix-customers-your-bill-is-about-to-up-9-percent/ Chicago wants to become the new Detroit so be it.07/01/2015 - 4:58pm
InfophileAnd also, she said "anyone," but she also said "probably." This means there's a subset for whom the "you shouldn't write it" doesn't apply.07/01/2015 - 4:47pm
InfophileGoing back a bit: "As I believe there is no justification, there is no reason for me to continue reading." - One reason to read might be to find out if you're wrong about there being no justification for it.07/01/2015 - 4:45pm
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician