Just when you thought Six Days in Fallujah couldn’t get any more controversial…
The developer of Six Days in Fallujah told attendees at Konami’s recent Gamers’ Night event that Iraqi insurgents are contributing to the project along with U.S. Marines and Iraqi civilians.
Joystiq’s Randy Nelson has a detailed report, including the startling remarks by Atomic Games president Peter Tamte:
It’s important for us to say, you know, that there are actually three communities that are very affected by the battle for Fallujah. Certainly the Marines. Certainly the Iraqi civilians within Fallujah, and the insurgents as well. We are actually getting contributions from all three of those communities so that we can get the kind of insight we’re trying to get.
I need to be careful about the specifics that I give… I think all of us are curious to know why [insurgents] were there. The insurgents [came from] different countries. And I think we’re all kind of curious about you know – they went there knowing that they were going to die… And I think that that’s a perspective that we should all understand.
[Insurgents are] involved in the creation of the game as well, as are Iraqi civilians. That’s important to us. It’s true. The game — the influences for the game came from the Marines that returned from Fallujah. But quite frankly in talking with them, it’s um, many people would just like this to be a recreation and we can’t recreate that without getting the perspectives of all the people who were involved.
Although Tamte doesn’t give a straightforward answer to whether or not Atomic has actually communicated with insurgents, his comments indicate that some type of input has taken place. It’s unclear whether that input was direct or indirect.
The news that there is an insurgent perspective is likely to provoke renewed outrage among some Iraq War veterans as well as families of military personnel killed and wounded in the conflict. Dan Rosenthal, a veteran of the war who now operates the gameslaw.net site, reacted strongly to word of Six Days in Fallujah’s insurgent perspective:
Absolutely unbelievable that Peter Tamte and [creative director] Juan Benito would try to make an "entertainment" experience about a war that we’re actively fighting, while soliciting advice and input on how to best kill Marines in game, from people who have worked to kill Marines in real life. The hypocrisy and double-speak coming out of Atomic’s leadership is beyond unbelievable.
The game is a "communications tool"…..a communications tool for who? The insurgency? And then out of the other corner of their mouths, they try to pass the game off as a "telling of stories"; but that’s a rude slap in the face to the approximately 100 Marines who died in the battles of Fallujah when the "story-telling" game includes Halo-style health regeneration. I’m pretty sure I don’t remember that being standard issue when I was in Iraq.
GP: We’re struggling to recall another game that generated this much controversy this early in its development cycle.