City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game Exhibit

June 9, 2009 -

The New York Civil Liberties Union has filed a federal lawsuit claiming that the city of Troy, New York and its Public Works Commissioner suppressed free speech by shutting down a controversial video game exhibit in March, 2008.

GamePolitics readers may recall our extensive coverage of the politically-charged situation surrounding Iraqi-born artist Wafaa Bilal. His Virtual Jihadi exhibit employed a modded PC game which included a mission to blow up then-President George W. Bush. Bilal said that the exhibit was intended to express his view that U.S. policy in Iraq helped create terrorists.

Bilal, a U.S. citizen and a faculty member at the Art Institute of Chicago, was invited to display his work at Rensselaer Polytechnical Institute in Troy but was abruptly ordered off campus after the school's College Republican Club raised objections to the game. Bilal was then offered space to display Virtual Jihadi at a nearby gallery, the Sanctuary for Independent Media.

The gallery, however, was suddenly shut down for building code violations by Troy's Public Works Commissioner, Robert Mirch (left). Mirch, who is named as a defendant in the suit, had earlier led a demonstration protesting the exhibit. He called the suit politically motivated.

The Albany Times-Union offers comment on the suit from Melanie Trimble of the NYCLU's Capital Region Chapter:

City officials cannot selectively enforce building codes to shut down an art exhibition they find distasteful. Mr. Mirch abused his authority to suppress the free speech rights of people he disagree with, an unconstitutional act that must be challenged.

According to the Times-Union report, the NYCLU seeks a court order to block the city from using its building code to infringe on civil rights. The suit also seeks damages on behalf of the non-profit which owns the Sanctuary for Independent Media as well as for the gallery's executive director. The NYCLU has posted a press release on the suit.

DOCUMENT DUMP: Grab a copy of the complaint from the NYCLU website...


Comments

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

I can think of a lot of groups that will be watching this case closely.

Building Code Violations are a classic way for local government to shut things down that they find politically inconvenient yet no law actually exists against.  It has been used by Philadelphia many times on the BDSM, Burner/PEX, and Swinger communities for instance.  People are less willing to stand up for sexual deviation, but maybe a more artsy case like this (that more people will get behind) will set a useful precedent.

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

Right, so we can blow the shit out of every Arab we see in ever modern shooter set in present day, and that's okay, but playing an Arab who's out to shoot at Americans is BAAAD!

Yah... sure.

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

Delet This i pressed wrong button

Antisthenes - Observe your enemies, for they first find out your faults.

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

blaming hobbies like politicians do should be as much of a no-no as saying the n word in public. I'm serious

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

Regardless of the political affiliation of the misguided civil servants, I wanna point out this is a 1st amendment issue, like most restrictive videogame legislation attempts.  Whether or not you like the guy's "art" he certainly has the right to make it and others have the right to display it.

I rarely find myself sticking up for Republicans, but this pandering idiocy is truly bipartisan.  I've been watching politicians fighting our constitutional freedom by attempting to wrongfully legislate music and videogames since Tipper Gore was outraged by sexy lyrics and then-Democrat Joe Lieberman bemoaned the videogame violence.  Nader had some anti-games rhetoric in his platform also.  Going for the culture war win is a tactic employed by all parties, and it is anti-American IMHO.

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

Nelson: *points and laughs at the city being sued* Hah ha.

 

TBoneTony

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

You are right. It's not all republicans. It's just the loud ones. I wish some of the fiscal republicans would speak up nice and loud to drown out these retarded moral republicans.

And Hillary is scared of video games. She's so old when she sneezes dust clouds rocket out from under her skirt.

 

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

we have games that let you kill sadaam in a street fighter like grudge match.

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

"Mirch began collecting signatures today on petitions for his re-election bid for the Rensselaer County Legislature. Mirch, a Conservative, is the legislature's majority leader."

 

Hmmmm....

Hunting the shadows of the troubled dreams.

Hunting the shadows of the troubled dreams.

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

I was wondering when this lawsuit would come. 

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

I hope he loses or at the very least feels the pressure from the courts.

----------------------------------------------------

Debates are like merry go rounds. Two people take their positions then they go through the same points over and over and over again. Then when it's over they have the same positions they started in.

---------------------------------------------------- Debates are like merry go rounds. Two people take their positions then they go through the same points over and over and over again. Then when it's over they have the same positions they started in.

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

Too bad that here in Brazil noone can do like there and sue the government for banning more videogames than China (yes, Brazil banned more games than China! Where China nowhere say that censhorship is banned, and Brazil constitution has a clone of first amendment, clearly saying that censhorship is illegal)

 

criadordejogos.wordpress.com

--- MaurĂ­cio Gomes twitter.com/agfgames

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

 

That kinda suck.  I know Brazil home of beautiful beaches and the ladies!! But banning game, god !!  I wish all the models would boycott this banning of game by protesting the government.  They could try no modeling business until video game ban lifted.  That would be a sure fire way to get the ban lifted.  I wonder how many politicians secretly look at monthly magazine full of hot models.   

 

mikedo2007

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

 

It sucks for the tax payers when idiots like this run these departments. The tax payers suffers not this guy. Isnt there a way to get this guy to foot at least 75% of the bill. Its time that these officals start paying out of their own pockets for their stupidity. If you dont want the responsibility then do NOT take the position.

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

Upstate New York can often be a lot like downstate Alabama: Redneck and Republican.

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

*AHEM* Fortunately not all in Alabama are like that. (We just get drowned out by their yelling)

Hunting the shadows of the troubled dreams.

Hunting the shadows of the troubled dreams.

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

Sterotypes do not represent the entirety, they just represent the loud obnoxious ones that nobody likes.

---

I once had a dream about God. In it, he was looking down upon the planet and the havoc we recked and he said unto us, "Damn Kids get off my lawn!"

I once had a dream about God. In it, he was looking down upon the planet and the havoc we recked and he said unto us, "Damn Kids get off my lawn!"

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

Sigh, another sad sign of local government insanity. What's depressing is how often this kind of stuff happens, a pity it's not more economical to fight local government. Takes a ruckus like this to get enough attention to even have a shot.

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

I hope the city loses. Sucks for the taxpayers, but the city had no right to deny him like that. Quite clearly politically motivated.

-If an apple a day keeps the doctor away....what happens when a doctor eats an apple?-

-Optimum est pati quod emendare non possis-It is best to endure what you cannot change-

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

Well, finding a way to shut down the exhibit was clearly politiclaly motivate.d What goes around comes around.

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

What a slimy politician. I was wondering when something like this would happen in regards to this display. Seriously, this kind of thing sounds like what the Mafia would do to put pressure on someone. Pay or threaten a well-placed politician to shut down someone who is resisting them.

No, I'm not accusing anyone of having Mafia ties, I'm just saying it sounds kind of like some sort of Mafia movie.

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

Shuutting down the entire building due to a door code is as asinine as shutting down an entire amusement park because one gate on one ride has a rusty hinge.

 

 

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

 ""Since I haven't seen it, I can't comment on what I haven't seen,'' Mirch said."

Wow... just wow...

call me crazy but i think speaking out and leading protests against the game qualifies as "commenting on it"

Let him burn in court

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

He called the suit politically motivated.

Unlike the building code violation shutdown.

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

 That's what went through my mind right after I went well DUH give that man a cookie he figured out the suit against him is politically motivated after he used his position in power to shut down an exhbit due to his own political motives.

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

Whatever happened to subtlety in art?

--------------------------------------------------------

Believe in something! Even if it's wrong, believe in it! -Glenn Beck

-------------------------------------------------------- Believe in something! Even if it's wrong, believe in it! GET OFF MY PHONE! -Glenn Beck

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

Oh, subtlety in art still exists, but these days an artist can't do a famous exhibit without being part of a "cause" or a "movement".

GameSnooper

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

The general dumbing-down of society, sadly.

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

Oh thems were the good old days!

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

Republicans love to sound like they are couragous freedom fighters...

But they are scared of a video game. Cowards they are.

Everyone should just stop being scared of little things.

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

They are freedom figheters.

Fire fighters fight fire, crime fighters fight crime, so of course these people qualify as freedom fighters (that joke comes from George Carlin).

Although I wouldn't use the actions of a these republicans to condmen all republicans.

----------------------------------------------------

Debates are like merry go rounds. Two people take their positions then they go through the same points over and over and over again. Then when it's over they have the same positions they started in.

---------------------------------------------------- Debates are like merry go rounds. Two people take their positions then they go through the same points over and over and over again. Then when it's over they have the same positions they started in.

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

Aren't the people you speak of usually some of the first to try and silence speech they disagree with?

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

Hillary Clinton and Jennifer Granholm both seemed pretty afraid of video games, didn't they? =p

-If an apple a day keeps the doctor away....what happens when a doctor eats an apple?-

-Optimum est pati quod emendare non possis-It is best to endure what you cannot change-

Re: City Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

What about the Ebola virus? That's quite a little thing indeed, but definitley something to be scared of!

--------------------------------------------------

I LIKE the fence. I get 2 groups to laugh at then.

-------------------------------------------------- I LIKE the fence. I get 2 groups to laugh at then.

Re: Troy, NY Sued Over Shutdown of Controversial Video Game ...

I'm surprised this didn't happen sooner.

I wonder if this is going to garner major media attention.

 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Poll

Should 'Hatred' have been removed from Steam Greenlight?:

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
NeenekoMakes sense to me, and sounds kinda cool. One cool thing about Minecraft is the meta game, you can implement other game types within its mechanics. There are servers out there with plots, an episodic single player one sound kinda cool12/18/2014 - 11:07am
MaskedPixelantehttps://mojang.com/announcing-minecraft-story-mode/ Umm... what?12/18/2014 - 10:24am
NeenekoThat would make sense. Theaters probably can not afford the liability worry or a drop in ticket sales from worried people. Sony on the other hand can take a massive writeoff, and might even be able to bypass distribution contracts for greater profit.12/18/2014 - 10:03am
ConsterNeeneko: I thought they cancelled it because the major cinema franchises were too scared of terrorist attacks to show the film?12/18/2014 - 9:55am
Neeneko@Wonderkarp - there is still a lot of debate regarding if the movie was a motive or not. Unnamed officials say yes, the timeline says no.12/18/2014 - 9:10am
NeenekoSomething does not smell right though, Sony is no stranger to being hacked, so why cancel this film? For that matter, they are still not giving in to hacker's original demands as far as I know.12/18/2014 - 9:06am
PHX Corp@prh99 Not to mention the Dangerous Precedent that sony's hacking scandal just set http://mashable.com/2014/12/17/sony-hackers-precedent/12/18/2014 - 8:25am
Matthew WilsonI hope its released to netflix or amazon12/18/2014 - 12:11am
prh99Basically they've given every tin pot dictator and repressive regime a blue print how to conduct censorship abroad. The hecklers veto wins again. At least when it comes to Sony and the four major theater chains.12/17/2014 - 11:55pm
MaskedPixelante"It's not OUR fault that our game doesn't work, it's YOUR fault for having so many friends."12/17/2014 - 9:48pm
Matthew Wilsonapparently tetris did not work because he has a full friends list12/17/2014 - 9:21pm
WonderkarpSo Sony cancelled the release of the Interview. was it ever confirmed that the Sony hacking was done because of that specific movie?12/17/2014 - 8:54pm
MaskedPixelanteWow, Ubisoft went four for four, I didn't think it was actually possible.12/17/2014 - 8:37pm
MechaTama31Oh, ok, I was mixing up "on Greenlight" and "Greenlit".12/17/2014 - 8:23pm
Matthew Wilson@phx you beat me to it. how do you screw up tetris?! my ubisoft this is just stupid. no one should ever preorder a ubisoft game again! ps people should never preorder any game regardles of dev.12/17/2014 - 6:28pm
PHX Corphttp://www.ign.com/videos/2014/12/17/what-the-heck-is-wrong-with-tetris-ps4 I give up on ubisoft12/17/2014 - 6:01pm
MaskedPixelantehttp://comicbook.com/blog/2014/08/16/exclusive-original-unaltered-cut-of-star-wars-trilogy-to-be-rele/ Yeah, this'll never happen.12/17/2014 - 5:03pm
NeenekoThey have and exercise control over which games are allowed on their privately controlled 'open forum'. Their endorsement is fairly minimal since it is only 'we do not reject this', but it is still an endorsement of sorts.12/17/2014 - 3:58pm
NeenekoHistorically there have been issues with libraries allowing some groups but not others. Perhaps 'endorsement' is too strong a word, but their editorial control IS a preapproval process, even if the standards are pretty minimal.12/17/2014 - 3:56pm
E. Zachary KnightLet's put this a different way. My local library allows any group to reserve and use multipurpose rooms. That does not mean that the Library endorses all events that take place in those rooms.12/17/2014 - 12:54pm
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician