Yesterday, GamePolitics reported that two more former college quarterbacks have sued EA over the alleged inclusion of their likenesses in the best-selling NCAA Football series of games.
Ryan Hart of Rutgers and Troy Taylor of Cal filed their suit in New Jersey Superior Court. In May, former Nebraska QB Sam Keller lodged a similar complaint against EA.
While some observers have ridiculed the athletes’ claims, columnist Jon Solomon of AL.com, a website incorporating several Alabama newspapers, believes the allegations have merit:
The NCAA insists that college athletes shouldn’t be sales tools… What does that mean? Crossing that line has been awfully blurry, even before the video game lawsuits.
Why do you think fans buy No. 8 Alabama jerseys and No. 15 Florida jerseys? It’s no coincidence the punter’s jersey number doesn’t hang in stores next to those of Julio Jones and Tim Tebow…
There is no question EA Sports identifies individual players. If this were an open-records request by a media outlet, universities would redact every video game player, citing personally identifiable information. Funny how that works, isn’t it?
All it takes for a major NCAA mess is one sympathetic judge or jury to an athlete’s claim of exploitation. Ironically, that forum could come from video games, which are wildly popular with the very college athletes whose identities are being used.