Shareholders Lose Court Battle Against Midway

A United States District Court judge has dismissed a lawsuit brought against Midway Games by a group of shareholders who had alleged that the company artificially inflated its stock by deceiving the public.

Filed by Joseph Zerger, “on behalf of himself and all others similarly situated,” the suit targeted Midway Games’ Steven Allison, James R. Boyle, Miguel Iribarren, Thomas Powell and David Zucker.

In a filing dated October 19, 2009, Northern District Illinois Eastern Division Judge David Coar ruled against the plaintiffs, stating:

Plaintiffs have failed to show that Defendants said or did anything more than publicly adopt a hopeful posture that its strategic plans would pay off. Such preening for the financial press is classic puffery. Even if these statements were not puffery, Plaintiffs cannot establish that they were false when made.

The plaintiffs had alleged that:

While the executives rushed to sell their Midway stock at the trumped-up prices their “scheme” temporarily sustained, the lead plaintiffs and other putative class members purchased it—and lost millions when the market eventually learned the truth.

Midway declared bankruptcy in February of this year.

|Image Via icanhascheezburger|

Tweet about this on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on Google+Share on RedditEmail this to someone


  1. 0
    JDKJ says:

    It’s actually legal jargon. It usually refers to a claim which inherently cannot be substantiated  (i.e., isn’t either true or false). Most frequently encountered in advertising and trade law (e.g., "BMW. The Ultimate Driving Machine" or "Gillette. The Best a Man Can Get."). Because puffery generally isn’t a verifiable claim, it can’t be said that puffery is misleading and, therefore, it doesn’t usually constitute a basis for liability. Unlike superlative claims, which can be verified (e.g., "Gillette Sensor. The Closest Shave a Man Can Get"). 

  2. 0
    MechaTama31 says:

    But guys, wouldn’t it be so much nicer to play the stock market if you knew that if you lost out, you could always sue and get your money back?  It’s win-win!

  3. 0
    Zerodash says:

    Regardless of whether the heads of Midway were pulling BS, it didnt take a rocket scientist to determine just how fucked the company was.  When a new MK game and a new IP (This is Vegas) are stated as the saviours of the company, its time to divest from the company.

Leave a Reply