FTC Backpedals on Newspaper Rescue Plan

June 11, 2010 -

It looks like the folks at the top of the Federal Trade Commission are distancing themselves from the fairly controversial proposal to save the newspaper industry - if the Wall Street Journal is to be believed. The "working paper on reinventing the media" was released on May 24 and widely criticized by most everyone as ludicrous. The report looked at ways to save the newspaper industry by charging fees to news aggregator sites that source newspapers, and taxes on electronics like iPads, laptops and Kindles. Money collected from these and other methods would then be redistributed to traditional media outlets.

So how is the FTC distancing itself from the plan? From the top down. No doubt after seeing a Rasmussen poll that showed a majority of Americans loathed such a plan, the FTC's top man has backpedaled as if he had nothing to do with it at all. In testimony before the Senate Judiciary subcommittee on Wednesday, FTC Chairman Jon Leibowitz called the plan to tax devices "a terrible idea." But tax aside, it seem that the FTCV has not abandoned the idea altogether.

This method is was what lawmakers call a "trial balloon," where a government agency that does not answer to voters does the dirty work, pushing forward ideas that everyone knows will be controversial.

Leibowitz has an interesting past which may explain his feelings on news aggregators: he's a former vice president of the Motion Picture Association of America. His views about this part of the bill are public knowledge - late last year at a workshop he noted that online news readers get a "free ride instead of paying the full value - or in fact paying anything - for what they're consuming."

Source: WSJ


Comments

Re: FTC Backpedals on Newspaper Rescue Plan

No one from the RIAA or the MPAA or other similar organizations has any business in government in my not so humble opinion. This is especially so in arms that that have control or influence over the area they came from.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

"The most difficult pain a man can suffer is to have knowledge of much and power over little" - Herodotus

--------------------------------------------------------------------------- "The most difficult pain a man can suffer is to have knowledge of much and power over little" - Herodotus

Re: FTC Backpedals on Newspaper Rescue Plan

Wow, could this article be anymore loaded with emotional bias? Where do those journalists come from, seriously? It's an editorial presented as an article. Worst is, while I still agree with the emotions conveyed, I still feel aggressed by them. Oh Dennis, where are thou...

Re: FTC Backpedals on Newspaper Rescue Plan

"...late last year at a workshop he noted that online news readers get a "free ride instead of paying the full value - or in fact paying anything - for what they're consuming."

Not true.  We pay for our internet service (granted, that money doesn't go to the websites we visit).  We put up with ads.  We pay subscriptions for the sites that require it (like the Wall Street Journal).

 

Andrew Eisen

Re: FTC Backpedals on Newspaper Rescue Plan

 I don't think that comparison holds... like you said the money you pay for internet service does not go to the news, furthermore you pay for your internet for many other reasons than just newspaper... as for Ads, newspapers aswell have plenty of ads so that's nothing new at all... the only thing that holds up are supscricption websites, but only very few sites that source newspapers actually do that. 

frankly i think i could agree with the part of the FTC's plan that thinks that news sites should pay more to the newspapers they source... afterall the newspapers are the ones doing all the leg work to get those stories and at the very least deserve compensation for that. The part that i didn't like was the tax of irrelevant devices... 

Re: FTC Backpedals on Newspaper Rescue Plan

 Everyone here is correct to a degree, it really comes down to where the news is sourced from. If an online news site gets their news from a wire service, they pay a subscription, we then view ads which pays for that subscription, therefore we have paid for the news.

It's when the news comes from papers or other news sources that it gets less clear. If a blogger sees a news item on a major news source's website, quotes that article, adds their own opinion and links back to the the original source, have they 'stolen' that article? Some/most bloggers would argue no, as the source was attributed and linked, most publications or networks would argue yes, as the blogger used that article to generate revenue at no cost to themselves.

That being said one could argue that a great amount of material from major news publications or networks supplemental sections is actually sourced from online consumer media, eg the majority of a papers tech supplemental will come from either media releases or from investigation undertaken from online consumer media sources such as Wired, Engadget or Gizmodo.

Essentially what it comes down to is that both sides need to work at being more transparent about where their information comes from and appropriately crediting their sources.

Re: FTC Backpedals on Newspaper Rescue Plan

I'm not making a comparison.  I'm giving examples that disprove the assertion that we pay nothing for the news we consume online.

 

Andrew Eisen

Re: FTC Backpedals on Newspaper Rescue Plan

"We put up with ads."

So in short its the same crap we had to deal with in newspaper form but in digital form.  What a surprise.

Re: FTC Backpedals on Newspaper Rescue Plan

Yeah, but unlike with newspapers, we can easily block them. Though of course newspaper ads don't have the potential to damage your property.

Re: FTC Backpedals on Newspaper Rescue Plan

 We can block ads, sure, but we shouldn't, as this would make us thieves.

Re: FTC Backpedals on Newspaper Rescue Plan

"Yeah, but unlike with newspapers, we can easily block them. Though of course newspaper ads don't have the potential to damage your property."

Silly rabbit we can also block out ads in newspapers.  Its called not reading the ads. 

Re: FTC Backpedals on Newspaper Rescue Plan

Not reading an ad =/= not seeing the ad at all.

Re: FTC Backpedals on Newspaper Rescue Plan

"Not reading an ad =/= not seeing the ad at all."

Oh no my feeble human brain is too weak to simply ignore a ad even if it only sees the ad for a microsecond.  Whatever shall I do?  

And don't get me wrong I get most of my news online its just personaly I find online ads and naming rights to sport and concert venues ten times more annoying than newspaper ads.  

Re: FTC Backpedals on Newspaper Rescue Plan

Advertisers are counting on your feeble meat brain from being unable to ignore an ad you saw for a microsecond.

Re: FTC Backpedals on Newspaper Rescue Plan

"Advertisers are counting on your feeble meat brain from being unable to ignore an ad you saw for a microsecond."

If my feeble meat brain can't take the time to do research before buying a product because I saw an ad then my feeble meat brain deserves the Ted Kennedy experience because that is total idiotcy.

 Plus if the ad is truely annoying then its a good thing I took the time to watch it as I won't buy anything from that company at all.  (Looking at you Tag Body Spray)

 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
Matthew Wilson@zipp I dont like the star menu taking up the whole dam screen, so just getting the start menu back will be worth it.04/21/2015 - 11:19am
ZippyDSMleeI got a extra HDD I will take win 10 for a spin. see if tis worthwhile heck if I do not have to move colums over in Skyrims creation kit its a keeper!04/21/2015 - 10:53am
ZippyDSMleeMatthew Wilson: Been on win 8.1 a few months the only thing I do not like is compatibility issues with older programs. 10 won't fix that sadly...04/21/2015 - 10:51am
E. Zachary KnightThe US Supreme Court has ruled that the 4th Amendment does offer US citizens some protections. This is a change of pace from other 4th Amendment rulings. http://reason.com/blog/2015/04/21/supreme-court-says-police-violated-4th-a04/21/2015 - 10:35am
E. Zachary KnightNot sure on that specific. But It is slightly annoying, but it can help to clairfy on occasion.04/21/2015 - 10:13am
IvresseCan I just ask out of curiousity why people repeat the title in their shout when it clearly states it in the URL?04/21/2015 - 9:07am
E. Zachary KnightI would say that is true. It drives me nuts when games are patched. The closer the patch is to launch, the worse it is.04/21/2015 - 9:06am
PHX Corphttp://www.npr.org/2015/04/19/400829880/when-video-games-are-patched-gamers-lose-trust-in-reviews When Video Games Are 'Patched,' Gamers Lose Trust In Reviews04/21/2015 - 9:03am
IvresseWell Totalbiscuit's port report video was positively glowing about it...04/21/2015 - 4:05am
MattsworknameHey, slightly off topic, but, anyone got a good sugestion for a flight stick for elite dangerous?04/21/2015 - 12:38am
Matthew Wilson@pm intreasting the gta5 port was already good from what I have read.04/20/2015 - 9:32pm
Papa Midnighthttp://www.pcgamer.com/gta-5-pc-patch-reduces-cpu-usage/04/20/2015 - 9:00pm
PHX Corp@zippy I'm Probaly going to Warn my uncle who is a techie that it may come out at the end of july04/20/2015 - 8:45pm
Matthew Wilson@zippy I want windows 10 badly, but that is because I am stuck on 8.1 yuk. that being said the new dx12 looks very good, and the reported performance gain from it.04/20/2015 - 8:00pm
ZippyDSMleeMy body is readY! http://www.afterdawn.com/news/article.cfm/2015/04/20/amd-microsoft-to-launch-windows-10-at-the-end-of-july04/20/2015 - 7:54pm
PHX CorpI may have posted this before but a leaked email from Sony pictures has the MPAA written all over it http://www.extremetech.com/computing/203654-leaked-sony-emails-show-mpaas-opposition-to-fair-use-confirms-users-are-viewed-as-thieves04/20/2015 - 4:53pm
Mattsworknameyet another reason the DMCA should be dismantled and rewritten04/20/2015 - 4:41pm
Matthew Wilson@zippy that is worse than the ESA thing.04/20/2015 - 4:26pm
ZippyDSMlee0-o good luck with that car companies, http://www.autoblog.com/2015/04/20/automakers-gearheads-car-repairs/04/20/2015 - 4:07pm
Andrew EisenYes, hence my subsequent shout.04/20/2015 - 3:15pm
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician