Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

September 23, 2010 -

An opinion piece in a Fort Meyers, Florida newspaper describes the ability to take on the role of insurgents in the upcoming Electronic Arts game Medal of Honor as games reaching  an “all-time low level.”

Taking a page (or bait?) from UK Defense Secretary Liam Fox, who urged retailers not to sell the title, the author of the News-Press editorial posed a similar challenge to readers:

…we do suggest that Americans at the very least refuse to buy 'Medal of Honor.' We suggest that retailers refuse to stock it. And we especially suggest that parents not allow their children to own or play it.

While thankfully against government intervention to stop the game’s release, the author asked if EA’s creative vision for game required, “the portrayal of deaths in an ongoing war,” and called Medal of Honor “shameful and an insult to the families of the men and women in uniform who have died there [Afghanistan], and will die in the future.”

The columnist probably helped EA sell a few more copies of the game in Southwest Florida.


Comments

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

While thankfully against government intervention to stop the game’s release, the author asked if EA’s creative vision for game required, “the portrayal of deaths in an ongoing war,” and called Medal of Honor “shameful and an insult to the families of the men and women in uniform who have died there [Afghanistan], and will die in the future.”

Hmmmm I guess they haven't seen the interviews of the Tier 1 Operators yet.....they need to watch them before they should say this crap.

 

"It's better to be hated for who you are, then be loved for who you are not." - Montgomery Gentry

"It's better to be hated for who you are, then be loved for who you are not." - Montgomery Gentry

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

All of this hype over an MW2 clone. This game is getting so much more attention than it deserves... this is "No Russian" all over again.

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

What? MOH originally kick-started the whole generation of modern FPS games. COD came when the guys at IW left to start a new franchise.

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

Any MoH boycott is not going to make a dent in the sales of this game.

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

boycott or not i doubt its gonna sell as well as it could, CoD whomped MoH ages ago and they just kept making worse and worse MoH's since.

tbh though i enjoyed pacific assault, a fresh take on WW2 since so few take to the pacific front and the Marines there.

 

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

Looks like this person is anti freedom and pro censorship. He wants to take away freedom to choose and buy what you want.

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

How so?  The author isn't advocating any kind of legal or governmental interference; he's urging customers to CHOOSE not to buy it and retailers to CHOOSE not to stock it.  How is that trying to take away people's freedom to choose?

I don't agree with his position, but it's a position he's free to take.  He's not trying to censor the game, merely urging boycotts, which consumers have the right to do.

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

I will half agree.... encouraging people to not buy it is fine, encouraging stores to not carry it, in my book, is NOT ok since that serves to cut off other people's choice.  It serves no other purpose then to make the item harder to obtain.

While it is unlikely that this piece will have much effect, the 'discourage the retailer' can have a profound effect on people's access to a service.  For an extreme example, look at abortions in Mississippi.... they are federally required to permit them, but pressure on doctors has resulted in only a single clinic for an entire state... so while not a de-jure ban, such pressure can result in de facto bans.  Which is why I have issues with even suggesting going down that path even if the party is too weak to have any real impact.  The ethical argument remains the same independent of effectiveness.

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

Abortion clinics ARE a pretty extreme example, and not really comparable.  We're not really talking about boycotts in that case, we're talking about much stronger protests, often including harrassment and even threats.

"The ethical argument remains the same independent of effectiveness."

But not independent of amount of pressure applied or importance of service.  This op-ed is a world different from threats of violence.

I still don't condone it, but it's a pretty benign bit of protest.

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

The less stores that sell it the less people would be able to buy it.

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

Unless major online retailers like GameStop and Amazon refused to sell it, very few consumers would be denied the opportunity to buy it.

Meanwhile, brick-and-mortar stores are faced with the decision of whether it will hurt their business more to sell the game or not to sell it.  This is the case with every single product that every single retailer sells, ever.  They will choose the decision that they feel is best for their business, and in this case most retailers will almost certainly choose to stock the game.

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

i still find it funny, there have been taliban/al qaeda in a number of games for years now, and just because they were labeled "opfor" or "Terrorists" no one said a word. Now that someone pulled the gag off their mouth and said one is taliban theres an entire shit storm to wade through..

entertaining to say the least.

 

tbh i'm gonna buy it just to peeve of these folks, and FYI i'm a vet of this recent war.

so they can shove it.

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

Far as I know, EA's never referred to them as the Taliban.  All the press materials I've seen have called them insurgents.

 

Andrew Eisen

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

yeh but it was revealed the original name for'em was to be taliban, thats where the whole fiasco started.

otherwise its no dif than CoD4, MW2, Americas Army, CS, and the entire lot of modern warfare based games.

 

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

Can you source that?

 

Andrew Eisen

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

"Amanda Taggart, senior PR manager for EA, told AOL News. "In Medal of Honor multiplayer, someone's gotta be the Taliban."


there were also news posts all about when they said it a few months ago.

but the search functions on these sites seem to be rather limited...

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

Not exactly what I was looking for but interesting to see that EA did use that word at one point.  Thanks.

 

Andrew Eisen

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

As pointed out at the bottom of the article that you link to, the opinion piece is an "abridged" version.

Here is the original article:

http://www.montgomeryadvertiser.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=20109110306

Nightwng2000

NW2K Software

http://www.facebook.com/nightwing2000

Nightwng2000 is now admin to the group "Parents For Education, Not Legislation" on MySpace as http://groups.myspace.com/pfenl

Nightwng2000 NW2K Software http://www.facebook.com/nightwing2000 Nightwng2000 is now admin to the group "Parents For Education, Not Legislation" on MySpace as http://groups.myspace.com/pfenl

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

"While thankfully against government intervention to stop the game’s release, the author asked if EA’s creative vision for game required, 'the portrayal of deaths in an ongoing war,'"

Seems a far better choice, and a less insulting one, than to not portray the deadly nature of war.

"and called Medal of Honor 'shameful and an insult to the families of the men and women in uniform who have died there [Afghanistan], and will die in the future.'"

That's Jingoism masquerading as sentimentality. The game is certainly not intended as an insult, and the fact that people have died in war does not make it an insult to portray both sides in a war as something other than caricatures. If people are insulted by Medal of Honor it's only because they choose to be insulted.

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

"And we especially suggest that parents not allow their children to own or play it."

Well, at least he reminded folks to pay attention to the ESRB rating, thats always a good thing.

.

"the author asked if EA’s creative vision for game required, “the portrayal of deaths in an ongoing war,”

Guess he has been napping over the last decade and hasn't seen the plethora of war movies and novels and other games out there.

As for the rest, meh, he's entitled to his opinion. Though to suggest that game or other art form not be available to the public because it includes an enemy we are currently fighting is pretty cowardly in my opinion.

 

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

You can suggest that I refuse to buy it, that's fine.  But when you suggest retailers don't stock it, well then you're attempting to circumvent my ability to decide for myself whether I want to play the game or not.  That's not cool.

"Does [EA's] creative vision [for the new MoH] require the portrayal of deaths in an ongoing war?"

I'd say "yes" is a safe bet.

 

Andrew Eisen

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

Well, that is the core of the "moral right".. using thier power to make it as difficult as possible for other people to choose differntly then they would.  After all, choice is evil and even being exposed to the option needs to be stopped.

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

Perhaps, but I think it bears noting, once again, that in this example the author isn't advocating any kind of ban or governmental action.  I disagree with the call for a boycott, but I commend them for their restraint in ONLY calling for a boycott.

Hell, it's not even that much of a boycott.  The article doesn't suggest that anyone should refuse to shop at a store that stocks the game.

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

Consumer boycotts are part of a free-market system.  Consumers have the right to request that a retailer not stock an objectionable product, a publisher not release it, an advertiser not advertise with it, or, say, a radio station to cancel a program.

And retailers have the right to say yes or no.  It comes down to whether they think they'll experience more dropped sales from choosing not to stock it, or from boycotts resulting from their stocking it.

In this case, I don't think many retailers will refuse to stock it.  That's the free market at work.

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

Indeedy do.  But it still excludes you from my cool book.

 

Andrew Eisen

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

And I can totally recommend that they stop watching Matlock and buying Craftmatic Adjustable beds...

It's so easy to judge something that you're not personally interested in enough to make an informed statement.

------- Morality has always been in decline. As you get older, you notice it. When you were younger, you enjoyed it.

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

Fair enough.  I disagree with this particular boycott attempt, but consumer boycotts can certainly be a positive thing as well.

Re: Op-Ed Urges Consumer, Retailers to Avoid Medal of Honor

And, concomitantly, his peppermint bark mailing list.

 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
NatirEnjoy your description. It is more funny to click the steam link though.. it is SFW.... "Shower With Your Dad Simulator 2015: Do You Still Shower With Your Dad?" is a fast paced shower-simulation where you shower with your 8-bit dad. It's good, clean fun!08/03/2015 - 12:28pm
Matthew Wilsonhttp://arstechnica.com/gaming/2015/08/the-18-million-dota-2-international-2015-marks-the-end-of-an-era/ a good story about a dota 2 team that formed just for the international. it is basically a all star team of the best US and European players08/03/2015 - 12:27pm
Big PermIt's a link to a game where you're a naked child around a bunch of naked dudes. Indies must be stopped08/03/2015 - 11:17am
Andrew EisenAs always folks, please give some indication of what you're linking to as well as who.08/03/2015 - 11:15am
NatirIf someone linked this, sorry. I kind of laughed and I figured some may get a kick out of this... Really weird and creepy though. http://store.steampowered.com/app/359050/08/03/2015 - 11:12am
Matthew Wilsonhttp://www.ign.com/articles/2015/08/03/new-article-about-konami-suggests-grim-situation-at-company well hopefully they will get out of game development after mgs508/03/2015 - 11:05am
IvresseSeriously IronPatriot, you're worse than a Daily Mail reader.08/03/2015 - 10:51am
Ivresse@IronPatriot: Will you stop lumping TotalBiscuit into this whole Gamergate issue, it's lying numpties like you who make up your own bullshit to justify your hatred to begin with that screw the internet up in the first place...08/03/2015 - 10:49am
ZippyDSMleeMost social justice is great but some of it is so stupid it taints the whole thing into triple negatives. A shame most of the gamergate stuff is bad...the core ideals are not bad it just jumped the shark and the n ut cases came out of the wood work..08/03/2015 - 10:07am
ZippyDSMleeJim dives into the red ash controversy , http://www.thejimquisition.com/2015/08/1876/08/03/2015 - 10:03am
IronPatriotSeriously people, do not believe crap spread by those who think "social justice" is an insult or that its a good idea to join a movement created for harassment. Like your gamergate hero TotalBiscuit.08/03/2015 - 9:32am
IvresseSeriously people, do not believe the shit that the internet spreads about anyone, especially with the whole gamergate SJW crap colouring the issue to the point of stupidity08/03/2015 - 9:14am
Ivresse@Big Perm: Only to the morons that inhabit the internet. Also his wife is damn awesome, I bumped into her when I had to catch my train before TB's meet and sign session, she ran to find TB, got him to sign my mousemat, then ran back to give it to me.08/03/2015 - 9:13am
MechaTama31I dunno. I'd rather see new characters than see, for example, someone other than Bill Murray try to be Venkman.08/03/2015 - 9:10am
Big Perm@ Ivresse. Is true that TB eats puppies?08/03/2015 - 9:01am
MattsworknamePS: hudson played winston zedimore08/03/2015 - 7:24am
Mattsworknameinfo: the orignoal cast wasn't part of Star trek, but the charecters in the movie were the same charecters. Ghostbusters with out stance, ego, venkman, and Earnie hudsons charecter, whose name I forget for some reason , feels wrong to me08/03/2015 - 7:23am
PHX Corphttp://www.nintendolife.com/news/2015/08/scathing_nikkei_report_hints_at_shameful_treatment_of_staff_by_dictatorial_konami_management Scathing Nikkei Report Hints At Shameful Treatment Of Staff By Dictatorial Konami Management08/03/2015 - 7:15am
IvresseJust finished with Coxcon 2015 last night (convention in the UK organised by Youtube Jesse Cox). Was a damn good weekend meeting Jesse, Totalbiscuit, Dodger etc. and getting to ask them questions and stuff.08/03/2015 - 6:15am
InfophileReference for my comment earlier about Dan Aykroyd in the new Ghostbusters: http://www.theguardian.com/film/2015/jul/15/ghostbusters-call-dan-aykroyd-for-cameo08/03/2015 - 6:00am
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician