SCOTUS Blog Schwarzenegger v. EMA Preview

October 27, 2010 -

The SCOTUS Blog gives us a preview of the arguments we can expect from both sides of the Schwarzenegger v. Entertainment Merchants Association review before the Supreme Court on November 2. Deputy state attorney general Zackery P. Morazzini will argue for California (Jerry Brown is busy campaigning for Governor of the state), and Paul M. Smith of Jenner & Block will be arguing for the video game industry.

This is a great read because it covers everything about the case that you could possibly imagine, but the bit below sums up a general feeling about the SCOTUS taking up the case in the first place:

One of the briefs, from the Pennsylvania Center for the First Amendment and the Brechner First Amendment Project, implied that the Court may have taken on more of a societal challenge than it realized when it granted review of the case. By granting the petition, it commented, “the Court now stands primed to wade deeply into the culture war over media violence. This is a surreal, surrogate and substitute war…for addressing the problems of real-world violence, as California and other government entities play the media blame game…It also is a war over censorship.” What the Court is being asked to sustain, that brief said dismissively, is “feel-good legislation.”

Read the whole thing here.

Posted in

Comments

Re: SCOTUS Blog Schwarzenegger v. EMA Preview

If there was anything that would have helped California convey to the court how serious they were about this issue and that would have helped it stand a chance, it was having their very own Attorney General stand before them to make the case personally.  However, since Jerry "Moonbeam" Brown won't be there as he is campaigning (and will probably fail...again) and having some other guy nobody's really heard of instead, their argument won't come across as strong as it would have otherwise.  Again, just goes to show what the state's priorities are.

It sounds like the stakes on this really are far higher than we realized.  And that this may indeed be the final word on not just video game violence, but ALL depictons of violence in media.  I relly hope, then, for a favorable outcome.  I think however that since they know that this really is a piece of "feel-good" legislation, and that those types of laws ultimately do nothing, that they may have already made their minds up and will reaffirm the lower court rulings

Re: SCOTUS Blog Schwarzenegger v. EMA Preview

I like to think the Supreme Court is not swayed by name recognition of attorneys.

Re: SCOTUS Blog Schwarzenegger v. EMA Preview

Honestly, that's probably a bit naive.  Certainly its not the main thing they'll be focusing on, but it could have some *small* impact.  It's been pointed out multiple times that thinking the SCOTUS judges are perfectly objective machines is not realistic.  Not saying the name recognition of the lawyers will be main issue, but it could have some small impact.

Re: SCOTUS Blog Schwarzenegger v. EMA Preview

"It's been pointed out multiple times that thinking the SCOTUS judges are perfectly objective machines is not realistic."

Of course it isn't, but that's not the same thing as deducting points from an argument because somebody other than a state AG showed up to argue it.

Now, if he's a worse lawyer than the AG, then yeah, it's going to hurt his case.  And the Justices' own personal biases will play in on some level -- that's why we can say things like "Alito will probably side with California and Thomas with EMA."  But that's not the same thing as taking the argument less seriously because somebody other than the AG showed up.

Re: SCOTUS Blog Schwarzenegger v. EMA Preview

This wait is killing me.  To me, for videogames to lose First Amendment protection is basically a death sentence to the entire medium, as I will not abide a situation where the only games are designed for children in mind.   This court decision had better come fast so I can determine if I need a new hobby or not.

Re: SCOTUS Blog Schwarzenegger v. EMA Preview

Not ot mention the people who play part in getting first ammendment protections removed from video games are unlikely to stop there.

 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
Andrew EisenTo the surprise of no one, that HD remake of the first level of Super Mario 64 has been DMCA'd. http://mario64-erik.u85.net/Web.html03/30/2015 - 10:54pm
MaskedPixelantehttp://www.destructoid.com/dark-souls-ii-scholar-of-the-first-sin-upgrade-and-pricing-systems-detailed-289743.phtml Dark Souls 2 pricing revealed, is only mildly confusing.03/30/2015 - 6:02pm
MaskedPixelantehttps://twitter.com/yugiohtas/status/582642955489431552 Roger Slifer sent to the graveyard.03/30/2015 - 3:49pm
james_fudgeEZK: it sounds like a carry-over bug from Demon's Souls.03/30/2015 - 1:29pm
Andrew EisenJust watched a clip of one of his correspondent appearances on The Daily Show. Seems like he'll be a good fit.03/30/2015 - 1:26pm
MaskedPixelantehttp://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/31/arts/television/trevor-noah-to-succeed-jon-stewart-on-the-daily-show.html The Daily Show with Trevor Noah.03/30/2015 - 1:17pm
E. Zachary KnightApparently there is an item duping glitch in Bloodborne. I loved those glitches in old Final Fantasy games. They were great. Nothing like infinite Excaliburs for Ninja's to throw.03/30/2015 - 12:58pm
Papa Midnightis no market for these games. There will be no intreospection whatsoever. It's either that or they blame piracy.03/30/2015 - 11:35am
Papa MidnightI'd like to take this time to reiterate the utter mess of a PC port that is Dead or Alive 5, which is missing significant amounts of features on PC in comparison to it's console counter-part. When sales go poorly, I'm certain the excuse will be that PC03/30/2015 - 11:34am
E. Zachary KnightSleep and sanity? No need for that here. Check out our experience at Super! BitCon as we made a game while visitors got to play games. Game Jamming During A Game Convention: A Convention Jam Tale. http://tinyurl.com/ogx46t703/30/2015 - 10:43am
ZippyDSMleePlank? PPLLAAANNKKK!!!!! :P03/30/2015 - 10:05am
MaskedPixelantehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kXYXuXX48m8 Take the "no-prank pledge" today.03/30/2015 - 9:11am
ZippyDSMleecrap around. It’s quite annoying but kinda fun like galaxy...even if has the power ups I hate the planets... oh and here comes a C&D in 3...2.....03/29/2015 - 11:45pm
ZippyDSMleeI was never that much of a fan they messed up the power ups, the level design was good enough for the time but ...meh.. Playing through sunshine again since I am no longer a south paw the controls are still stupid there's little to no options to change cr03/29/2015 - 11:45pm
Cheater87http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/parents-could-be-reported-to-police-if-children-play-violent-video-games-like-call-of-duty-and-grand-theft-auto-10141697.html03/29/2015 - 11:45pm
ZippyDSMleehttp://www.afterdawn.com/news/article.cfm/2015/03/29/click-here-to-play-super-mario-64-in-hd03/29/2015 - 11:45pm
ZippyDSMleeMedia mafia wants you to sleep wif the fishes!03/29/2015 - 11:44pm
MechaCrashThe MPAA and RIAA are a pack of extortionists and thugs, and they both need to be destroyed.03/29/2015 - 10:19pm
ZippyDSMleehttps://torrentfreak.com/mpaa-wanted-less-fair-use-in-copyright-curriculum-150329/03/29/2015 - 10:17pm
PHX CorpI have to say somthing about an injustice in the Xbox video Store, the first 6 Star Wars films are not available in either SD or HD03/29/2015 - 6:17pm
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician