Acting, Kinect and Protected Speech

December 10, 2010 -

Is acting protected speech, and if so, is acting in a video game - especially in the age of motion sensing console devices - protected speech as well? This is the theory thrown out in a thought provoking post called "Is Playing a Video Game Conduct or Speech? Lessons from Microsoft Kinect" over at Law Law Land Blog.

Steven Smith kicks that idea around a bit, comparing the acting kids do in video games to the actions in a school play. The idea begins at GameStop, where Smith is buying a game for his daughter:

I was drawn to the display of the Microsoft Kinect, the new hands-free controller that is designed to allow the ultra-interactivity of the Nintendo Wii, but without any controller at all. You (and, apparently, one million of your likeminded early adopter friends) stand in front of a 3D camera system, which translates your movements in real life into the movement of your avatar on the screen.

Which leads him to a thought about video games and free speech:

I immediately thought of it as acting in a play. The real you is performing the movements from the gallery, while the virtual you is acting them out, in costume and on set, on the stage of your TV. It is like playing cops-and-robbers in the playground, except no one else need be present and no playground is required.

This brings it back to the oral arguments that took place on November 2 before the Supreme Court and a question from Justice Elena Kagan. She asked: "Do you think video games are speech in the first instance? Because you could look at these games and say they are the modern-day equivalent of monopoly sets. They are games. They are things that people use to compete. You know, when you think about some of them — the first video game was Pong. It was playing tennis on your TV. How is that speech at all?"

Smith talks about how the EMA handled the question:

The Entertainment Merchants Association and the State of California both assumed that the games were speech, in the sense of the creative expression of the artists and programmers who made the games. Where they differed was simply over the issue of whether the state had a compelling basis to regulate this assumed speech. But Kagan was challenging the underlying assumption, asking the more fundamental question, are these games speech at all? And does it depend on the nature of the game (Monopoly and Pong, with little or no storyline, versus Dungeons and Dragons and Grand Theft Auto, which are all about the story — and, in the case of D&D, the basement black lights, Cheetos, and Sprite).

Which leads to a series of important points:

To his credit, Paul Smith, counsel for the Entertainment Merchants Association, handled the question with aplomb. He argued that the definitions in the law contain an underlying presumption that the games at issue contain a narrative structure, i.e., a plot of some kind. He then argued that the players of such plot-driven games are like actors, “helping to make the plot, determine what happens in the events that appear on the screen, just as an actor helps determine what happens in a play. You are acting out certain elements of the play and you are contributing to the events that occur and adding a creative element of your own. That’s what makes them different and in many ways wonderful.”

That is, in my humble opinion, the real point about video games and why they deserve First Amendment protection, no matter how violent some of them may be. We allow minors to act in very violent plays, movies and television shows. As far as I am aware, no state has sought to prohibit children from acting in such creative works. (They may need parental permission under labor laws or for private, contractual liability reasons; but no one says that the kids themselves cannot get together and act out whatever horrors their minds can conjure up.) Video games simply expand the relevant stage on which these games of pretend may be acted out.

Smith goes on to say that anyone can be a virtual actor thanks to video games. Sometimes players have to follow a script and sometimes they engage in violent acts, but no more than a child actor playing a role in a violent movie or an adult-themed TV show. This closing thought says it best:

The First Amendment not only protects the William Shakespeares, Alfred Hitchcocks, Mario Puzos and Take Twos of the world — it also protects the actors (including child actors) who wish to play Brutus, Norman Bates, Michael Corleone, or CJ Johnson.

 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Poll

What do you think about Bill Paxton taking on the film role of Jack Thompson?:

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
PHX Corphttp://www.extremetech.com/computing/203654-leaked-sony-emails-show-mpaas-opposition-to-fair-use-confirms-users-are-viewed-as-thieves Leaked Sony emails show MPAA’s opposition to fair use, confirms users are viewed as thieves04/18/2015 - 10:49am
prh99I'd happily run DBAN on all their servers and back up with a 7 pass wipe.04/18/2015 - 1:07am
Matthew Wilsonmetaphorically speaking of course04/17/2015 - 9:40pm
Matthew Wilsonhttps://soundcloud.com/totalbiscuit/brevity-is-the-soul-of-twit I agree with TB twiter is not good for anything more their links. twiter is a toxic wasteland, and I wish I can nuke it from orbit.04/17/2015 - 9:38pm
MechaCrashI can understand why Sony wants the Pokemon and Smash movie rights, but it's not hard to see why Nintendo wouldn't want to sell to them. Kinda their competitors in the console arena.04/17/2015 - 8:01pm
PHX Corp@MW We won't know until the nintendo General Shareholders meeting if the leaks(From Sony Pictures) is true or not04/17/2015 - 7:55pm
MechaCrashIn GG news: they got kicked out of Calgary Expo for getting a booth under false pretenses and disrupting panels. http://www.themarysue.com/calgary-expo-gamergate-evicted/ How long before they get thrown under the No True Scotsman bus?04/17/2015 - 7:53pm
MechaTama31EZK: Because what if I want to see that website I was looking at a while ago? Well, just keep scanning through my tabs til I see it! There's an aspect of archaeology to it, too. "Oh yeah, I was looking up how to build my own pizza oven. Good times..."04/17/2015 - 6:52pm
Matthew Wilsondo it in the art style of those trailers, and I am on board.04/17/2015 - 5:24pm
PHX Corphttp://mynintendonews.com/2015/04/17/sony-were-apparently-trying-to-get-the-rights-to-a-pokemon-and-super-smash-bros-movie/ Sony Were Apparently Trying To Get The Rights To A Pokemon And Super Smash Bros Movie04/17/2015 - 4:14pm
E. Zachary KnightCan't wait to see the new digs on Saturday.04/17/2015 - 1:41pm
Andrew EisenBy the by, I moved this week so if I dropped a comment thread or two, my apologies for leaving you hanging.04/17/2015 - 12:22pm
Andrew EisenIf I were going to buy Mortal Kombat X, I'd wait for the inevitable Game of the Year edition that includes all the DLC for an overall cheaper price.04/17/2015 - 12:22pm
PHX CorpMortal Kombat X: On Disc DLC Confirmed Read more at http://gamingbolt.com/mortal-kombat-x-on-disc-dlc-confirmed04/17/2015 - 12:17pm
james_fudgeme04/17/2015 - 8:37am
Ryan RardinWho else would like to see The Misadventures of Tron Bonne on PlayStation Classics?04/17/2015 - 2:21am
ZippyDSMleeso I can save my bookmarks and nuke it with a ree install put my bookmarks back reget all my plugins and I am good to go04/17/2015 - 2:15am
ZippyDSMleeMechaTama31: I run 70 tabs and use a suspend plugin to suspend them. i have a folder in my bookmarks that have all my pluings in it04/17/2015 - 2:14am
E. Zachary KnightOnly one question: Why?04/16/2015 - 10:16pm
MechaTama31Most of which I could probably delete the bookmark for too, if I had the inclination to wade through them.04/16/2015 - 9:16pm
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician