U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in Brown v. Entertainment Merchants Association

June 27, 2011 -

The United States Supreme Court has ruled in favor of the video game industry and retailers in Brown v. Entertainment Merchants Association (formerly known as Schwarzenegger v. Entertainment Merchants Association). The full opinion can be found here. According to Justice Scalia, who wrote the opinion: "the act forbidding sale or rental of violent games to minors does not comport with the 1st Amendment." Alito concurred with the judgment, joined by the Chief Justice. Justices Thomas and Breyer dissent, in an opinion by Thomas - according to SCOTUSBlog.

The court had to decide if a state law restricting the sale of violent video games to minors violated the First Amendment right to free speech. The Ninth Circuit Court ruled in favor of the EMA, saying that the law violated the First Amendment.

The law was written by California State Senator (D-San Francisco) Leland Yee and signed into law by California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger in 2005. The law was immediately challenged by the video game industry and retail advocacy groups in the United States District Court for the Northern District of California. A judge put a permanent injunction on the law, ruling that it was unconstitutional because it violated rights protected by the First Amendment.

You can check out all the petitions and arguments from November here.

Source: SCOTUSBlog

 

Posted in

Comments

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

Right now I've got Don't Stop Believing.

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

Wait wait! I've got the perfect one! If you know the words, sing along!

"This was a triumph!

I'm making a note here, huge success!

It's hard to overstate my satisfaction..." EVERYBODY!

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

Aperture Science
We do what we must
because we can.
For the good of all of us.
Except the ones who are dead.

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

But there's no sense crying over every mistake 

You just keep trying till you run out of cake

and the science gets done

and you make a neat gun

for the people who are still alive.

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

Wow I hadn't realized how nervous I was about this.  Hopefully this is the end of these kind of laws.  The real shame is the amount tax payer money wasted on this law in a time of financial crisis.  I personly will be celabrating with the most violent game I have.  (Either Bulletstorm or Mortal Kombat)

Now, I beleive in these circumstances are the following is obligatory so everybody join me.  U-S-A, U-S-A, U-S-A

"Video games qualify for First Amendment protection. Like protected books, plays, and movies, they communicate ideas through familiar literary devices and features distinctive to the medium.  And “the basic principles of freedom of speech . . . do not vary” with a new and different communication medium."  Brown V. EMA


 

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

Can't wait to see what Yee has to say. He is probably crying.

E. Zachary Knight
Divine Knight Gaming

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

I'm crying too! Joyfully, though. Makes it hard to dance!

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

 I don't know.. it is hard to say how much political capital he really has wrapped up in this topic at this point.  

 

The river has moved on... while gamers care, the general voters seem less interested now

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

I hope Yee manages to keep it classy in his response, though I doubt it.  Expect some major hyperbole. 

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

Not too sure on that.  Yee is a Democrat from California- hardly the theistic type. 

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

That doesn't mean anything. He's still a politician and they're all expected to appeal to god.

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

He's busy looking for his crying towel as we speak and celebrate.

Geaux Saints, Geaux Tigers, Geaux Hornets, Jack Thompson can geaux chase a chupacabra. Hell will stay frozen over for quite a while since the Saints won the Super Bowl.

Geaux Saints, Geaux Tigers, Geaux Pelicans. Solidarity for the Saints = No retreat, no surrender. 2013 = Saints' revenge on the NFL. Even through the darkest days, this fire burns always.

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

7/2 is a large majority, i expected it to be much closer.

Here are we -- and yonder yawns the universe.

Here are we -- and yonder yawns the universe.

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

To Leeland Yee, Arnold, Jerry Brown, and every other anti-gamer out there:

IN YOUR FACE!

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

Somewhere in Miami, a certain ex-lawyer is screaming, "NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!"

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

I think he was probably far more upset that he couldn't have them ALL recused.  :)

Nightwng2000

NW2K Software

http://www.facebook.com/nightwing2000

Nightwng2000 is now admin to the group "Parents For Education, Not Legislation" on MySpace as http://groups.myspace.com/pfenl

Nightwng2000 NW2K Software http://www.facebook.com/nightwing2000 Nightwng2000 is now admin to the group "Parents For Education, Not Legislation" on MySpace as http://groups.myspace.com/pfenl

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

Not to belittle or take away the earned celebration of others, but can we have a "Gamer's Pride" march celebration?

Nightwng2000

NW2K Software

http://www.facebook.com/nightwing2000

Nightwng2000 is now admin to the group "Parents For Education, Not Legislation" on MySpace as http://groups.myspace.com/pfenl

Nightwng2000 NW2K Software http://www.facebook.com/nightwing2000 Nightwng2000 is now admin to the group "Parents For Education, Not Legislation" on MySpace as http://groups.myspace.com/pfenl

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

Hell Yeah. 

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

VICTORY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  yee was an ignorant fool ahahaahah

 

Re: U.S. Supreme Court Upholds Ninth Circuit Decision in ...

Hooray for our side!

 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Poll

Which Feminist Frequency video are you looking forward to most?:

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
Goth_SkunkAs such, the first playthrough is always going to be the most evocative.01/30/2015 - 3:47pm
Goth_SkunkSo while branching storyline is hallmarked as a feature of the game, the storyline never stays branched for too long. There is a linear story that may branch at points, but each branch always comes right back to the main line further down the road.01/30/2015 - 3:46pm
Goth_SkunkMy biggest gripe about it though would have to be that its replay value sucks. I quickly learned that apart from a few key decisions you make, most choices end up not being relevant because something terrible happens anyway.01/30/2015 - 3:45pm
Goth_SkunkI *love* The Walking Dead. Like I said, I played Season 1 through in one go, and subsequently pre-purchased Season 2 in its entirety sight-unseen.01/30/2015 - 3:43pm
Andrew EisenBy the by, I take it you're a fan of Telltale's Walking Dead? I'm one of the very few who really doesn't like it. Bums me out.01/30/2015 - 3:39pm
Andrew EisenI think we're safe with stuff like Life is Strange, Resident Evil: Revelations 2, and TellTale's games. I was thinking more along the lines of D4. It's genuinely up in the air whether we'll get a conclusion to that story or not.01/30/2015 - 3:33pm
Goth_SkunkUltimately, from this potentially ignorant perspective, it's the gamer who assumes the risk, not the developer. I don't approve. Fortunately, I'm only paying $5 (CDN, no less), so that's money I can easily write off if I'm disappointed.01/30/2015 - 3:32pm
Goth_SkunkIf I'm wrong, and the unthinkable should happen where the developer ends up aborting production of the rest of the episodes, bundle purchasers would be understandably upset. Even moreso if attempting to get a refund turns out to be a hassle.01/30/2015 - 3:30pm
Goth_SkunkThere is an option on XBL to purchase all episodes in a bundle. Pay full price now, get the rest of the episodes as they're released. I would like to think this means that the other episodes are in fact done and ready.01/30/2015 - 3:29pm
Andrew EisenCatch 22 sometimes. Some gamers don't want to buy it if there's no guarantee the whole thing will come out and the whole thing can't come out unless enough people buy the early installments.01/30/2015 - 3:17pm
Goth_SkunkI sincerely hope this trend towards episodic games is not done so because the developer only had enough capital to produce the first 1/5th of the story and is banking on making enough money from the sales of that fifth to produce the rest.01/30/2015 - 3:16pm
Goth_SkunkThat being said, I want to try Life is Strange to get my feet wet.01/30/2015 - 3:13pm
Andrew EisenI'm that way too. I'll wait until the whole thing is out. Same goes for DVDs of TV shows. I'll wait for the season set.01/30/2015 - 3:13pm
Goth_SkunkIf an episodic game is really good, and the time between episodes is more than a week, I'm more inclined to wait for the rest of the episodes to all come out than to try playing it episode by episode at launch date.01/30/2015 - 3:12pm
Goth_SkunkAs someone who played through TWD Season 1 entirely in one day, and then played Season 2 episode by episode when they each came out, I strongly agree with this sentiment.01/30/2015 - 3:11pm
Goth_SkunkFrom what I've been hearing, people haven't been buying it because they're sick of episodic games where they have to wait 6 weeks or more between episodes and they'd rather just wait for the whole thing to come out at once.01/30/2015 - 3:10pm
Andrew EisenNot sure what GamerGate could do to dissuade people from buying a game they'd otherwise be interested in or why it would even want to but I agree, I think the premise is interesting and look forward to learning more about how it actually plays.01/30/2015 - 2:58pm
Goth_SkunkAnd for what it's worth, I saw Life is Strange advertised today on XBL, and the premise looks very, very intriguing. I'm going to buy it today and give it a shot.01/30/2015 - 2:42pm
Goth_SkunkI'm hearing rumours that the recently released game Life is Strange is not selling very well on Steam, and that GamerGate is being blamed as a result. It's just a rumour though.01/30/2015 - 2:42pm
Matthew Wilsonhttp://smashboards.com/threads/apex-2015-venue-changed-competition-will-restart-tomorrow.388991/ twitch saves apex2015 tournament after original location gets condemned.01/30/2015 - 2:37pm
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician