Yee Vows to Fight on Despite SCOTUS Decision

While Leland Yee maybe disappointed with the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision to uphold the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals decision on Brown v. EMA, he says that he isn’t done with the fight against violent videogames, according to multiple reports. One story from ABC station KGO and another from newspaper The San Francisco Appeal report says that Yee was heartened by the dissenting opinions of Thomas and Breyer, and that comments from Justices John Roberts and Samuel Alito have left the door open for future legislation.

"Even with the existing court, there may be, if we craft the bill differently, there may be a basis for trying to get another hearing within the Supreme Court on this critical matter," Yee said.

Yee added that he will be studying the concurring and dissenting opinions to try to craft a revised bill that will pass a constitutional test. Of course, maybe if he had done this in the first place instead of relying on questionable research and political bluster, we’d be reporting on a different decision today.

Sources: The San Francisco Appeal, KGO

Tweet about this on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on Google+Share on RedditEmail this to someone


  1. 0
    Adamas Draconis says:

    Of course if he DOES try and include all media formats, he’ll get slapped down even harder. Precident has been set children.


    Hunting the shadows of the troubled dreams.

  2. 0
    Slipperman says:

    You know, despite all the greedy self-serving nut jobs that are representing the American Tea Party right now, Leland Yee (and also Joe Baca as well) actually make the Tea Party look sane and decent in comparison at this point…just saying =/

  3. 0
    hellfire7885 says:

    Indeed. It’s kind of hard to get people to forget about real problems when their road is full of potholes and the state can’t even affor a patch job.

  4. 0
    Shahab says:

    Yee wants to be mayor of SF and this type of stuff he believes will help him get there. I think he is sorely misunderstanding what those voters care about though and really hope he does not win. Once he either wins or loses that post he’ll forget all about this stuff.

  5. 0
    axiomatic says:

    Yee needs to realize that SCOTUS will never take him seriously as long as he is only singling out Video Games.

    You either attack this issue for all media formats (books, movies, games, music) or you shut the fuck up.

  6. 0
    black manta says:

    Like I read from someone else, it’s all about politics at this point.  He made promises to get financial backing for this, and he blew it.  He can’t go to those people he managed to convince to back that crazy bill and say to them,  "Well shucks.  I guess we screwed up.  That’s it for us.  See you later!"  That’s like a big company that fails after releasing a bad product; the investors won’t let them off that easily.  He’s done and he knows it.  But he has to make it look good so that the people who backed him won’t feel like he wasted their money (which he did).  It’s all about appearances.  That’s politics for you.

    Also, I remember Hal Halpin saying in an interview tha if Yee did come back with another bill, it would be very likely that the state of California at this point would say, "Thanks, but no thanks.  You had your chance and it ended up costing us more than we were willing to invest.  We’ve got more worthwhile problems now.  Please go away."  And like  Attack_Gypsy said, Brown proably won’t go for it.  As AG at the time, he was there when the bill was first introduced and followed its progress.  You think he’s going to allow that to happen a second time?  Especially now that he’s governor?  I think not.

    And finally, if Yee’s running for mayor, he’ll find his energies going more into campaigning.  But like someone else here said, this could end up becoming a BIG liability for him.  All his opponent has to do is run an ad saying how much of CA’s badly-needed money were wasted getting a bill that was doomed to failure all the way up to the Supreme Court, and that’ll pretty much torpedo his chances of winning the election.

  7. 0
    BearDogg-X says:

    Again reiterating, Yee is such a crybaby.

    And a motard. Did he not read Scalia’s majority opinion? It doesn’t matter if he reworks the bill or not, SCOTUS says that it would be unconstitional. In fact, in his concurrence, Alito basically admitted that Scalia’s opinion made it that any law regulating violent game sales to minors wouldn’t be allowed.

    Lyle Denniston of SCOTUSBlog even says as much: 

    The Court used the broadest constitutional language open to it to accomplish that result, apparently leaving no room for government to try different approaches.

    Geaux Saints, Geaux Tigers, Geaux Hornets, Jack Thompson can geaux chase a chupacabra. Hell will stay frozen over for quite a while since the Saints won the Super Bowl.

    Proud supporter of the New Orleans Saints, LSU, 1st Amendment; Real American; Hound of Justice; Even through the darkest days, this fire burns always

    Saints(0-3), LSU(3-0)

  8. 0
    Mad_Scientist says:

    "Even with the existing court, there may be, if we craft the bill differently, there may be a basis for trying to get another hearing within the Supreme Court on this critical matter," Yee said.

    He’s nuts. Even if he managed to get a bill that garnered the support of Roberts and Alito, that would still only be 4 out of 9. The majority opinion written by Scalia and supported by 4 of the other justices makes it quite clear that NO legistlation is going to get through.

  9. 0
    Kajex says:

    If he did, he would have crafted a better law in the first place, one that would have been accepted in every court he took it to.

    He’s fucked- and he knows it.

  10. 0
    Left4Dead says:

    It would be nice if they realized that Yee is a problem and tried to solve it by not re-electing him.

    – Left4Dead

    Why are zombies always eating brains? I want to see zombies that eat toes for a living. Undead-related pun intended.

    -- Left4Dead --

  11. 0
    hellfire7885 says:

    Such a thing should be grounds for removal from office, especially if it already failed.

    It sounds like he’s saying he knows better than the supreme court.

  12. 0
    nightwng2000 says:

    ""Even with the existing court, there may be, if we craft the bill differently, there may be a basis for trying to get another hearing within the Supreme Court on this critical matter," Yee said."

    Crafting a reworded bill, for the purpose of circumventing the US Constitution, using the same "evidence" that you used before, ie crappy studies that don’t prove squat, STILL means taking a crappy bill that attempts to circumvent the US Constitution using that same "evidence" that was dismissed as crap all the way up to the US Supreme Court.


    NW2K Software

    Nightwng2000 is now admin to the group "Parents For Education, Not Legislation" on MySpace as

  13. 0
    Father Time says:

    Yee you lost, move on.

    Stop wasting our money on your unnecessary crusade.

    -A California resident


    Debates are like merry go rounds. Two people take their positions then they go through the same points over and over and over again. Then when it’s over they have the same positions they started in.

  14. 0
    MonkeyPeaches says:

    There’s no way you can alter this bill to make it constitutional. Trying to block the sale of violent video games will always violate the first amendment. 

  15. 0
    CMiner says:

    Wow, I didn’t realize that the financial disaster that is California’s budget deficit was already over, which it certainly must be if they have the money to waste on another attempt like this.

  16. 0
    robbway says:

    What’s that definition of insanity again?  "Doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results." — Albert Einstein.



  17. 0
    Bigman-K says:

    WOW! I mean Wow. If i didn’t hate this hypocritical nanny-statist enough already this just makes me more pissed. Leland Yee is offically worse then Jack Thompson. At least Thompson had the good sense to quit. Please Cali citizens for the sake of God and taxpayers money vote this guy out of office, Please!

    "No law means no law" – Supreme Court Justice Hugo Black on the First Amendment

  18. 0
    ecco6t9 says:

    As long as Yee has a D next to his name, his district will continue to vote for him.

    And for the record the state is pretty much bankrupt.

  19. 0
    Attack_Gypsy says:

    Gov. Moonbeam won’t sign a new bill. He’s not THAT dumb.




    Yes, I am a liberal. I also believe in a strong military, less government, and the right to bear arms. ~ Me Calling an illegal alien an undocumented worker is like calling a crack dealer an unlicensed pharmacist. ~ Me

  20. 0
    Zerodash says:

    Yee needs to…

    1) Stop using lies, cherry-picked quotes, discredited research, and fearmongering.

    2) Decide if spending more of other people’s money (the taxpayer) on such an uphill battle is warranted.

    3) Determine whether working on parental awareness of game ratings would be more productive than spending years in court.

    4) Read the 1st Amendment.


    Of course, his mayoral aspirations may take precedence for his time for now. 

  21. 0
    Vake Xeacons says:

    That’s right Yee. Let’s study the SCOTUS’s open OPINIONS, instead of FACTS. I mean, who wants those, right?

    Instead of studying the positive effects of cybernatography, let’s study how politics can be manipulated so a crooked bill can be passed.

  22. 0
    hellfire7885 says:

    Also, since Yee lost and is STILL willing to persue this, he is officially what Jack Thompson would be if Thompson had gained any real power.

    Another factor being that it’s not his money he’s spending, and I would be in full support of any law that said the money for a failed law comes out of that politician’s pocket.

  23. 0
    Andrew Eisen says:

    Some free advice, Yee:

    1.  Identify a problem that actually exists.

    2.  Write a law that would actually alleviate that problem.


    Andrew Eisen

  24. 0
    hellfire7885 says:

    So, after wasting a metric fuckton of money on a bill that many people knew would fail, his answer is to….. piss away even MORE of a near bankrupt state’s money on a vanity project.

Leave a Reply