George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

July 1, 2011 -

A San Francisco Chronicle guest editorial by George A. Rose, Executive Vice President and Chief Public Policy Officer at Activision Blizzard, takes San Francisco mayoral candidate, State Senator (D-San Francisco) and anti-game crusader Leland Yee to task for his promise to continue to fight for a violent videogame law. This even after a bitter defeat and a strong rebuke at the hands of seven U.S. Supreme Court Justices, no less. The gist of the editorial is that many of Yee's misguided policies and political grandstanding costs money that California doesn't have right now.

"Lee kept up the grandstanding this week, even after the U.S. Supreme Court on Monday convincingly and permanently laid to rest a Yee-authored 2005 law purporting to inhibit the sale to minors of video games that would have been deemed too violent," wrote Rose. "Deemed too violent by whom: by some yet-to-be-appointed commission of state officials (supported by taxpayer dollars) - a commission Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia scathingly referred to as the California Censorship Committee."

"Long before Yee’s law was signed, an industry-funded system costing taxpayers nothing had been put into place - a system that the U.S. Federal Trade Commission as recently as this year praised as the gold standard of self-regulation," he continued. "This system makes it not just difficult, but nearly impossible, for an unaccompanied minor to buy age-inappropriate games, especially the ones Yee cites as most egregiously violent."

Rose closes by saying that the SCOTUS rulings puts the power of what children play back in the hands of parents and out of the hands of lawmakers and bureaucrats. He also points out that California has serious financial issues that it needs to deal with and lawmakers shouldn't be throwing good money after bad laws:

"..public money is scarce in California these days. Squandering precious funds again on writing, defending and attempting to enforce ineffective and unnecessary laws that benefit political ambitions is a really bad idea. What’s not broken shouldn’t be fixed. It’s time for Sen. Yee to let go of the joystick and declare game over."

You can read Rose's entire Editorial at the San Francisco Chronicle.


Comments

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

I think he's more like Tantalus: he keeps reaching for something he's never going to grasp.

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

Leland Yee, what Jack Thompson would have been if he had had any actual power.

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

More polite?

Other than that, I'm not seeing a difference.  They both completely failed to get their violent game laws passed.

 

Andrew Eisen

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

Hell, at least Yee got his case taken seriously by the Supreme Court, unlike Jack.

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

And got seriously shot down, just like Thompson.

Anyway, it wasn't like the Supreme Court didn't take Thompson's case seriously, it was never presented for them to consider one way or the other.

 

Andrew Eisen

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

Still, we all know what would have happened in the end if it was, right?

JT: "I DEMAND you ban all sales of these murder simulators!"

SCOTUS: "Who do you think you are? And where are your pants?"

_____________________________________________________________________________

"Power means nothing without honor and pride."

http://grifsgamereviews.blogspot.com My video game review site.

Atlanta Video Games Examiner for examiner.com

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

Yeah.  Again, the same exact thing.

Had Thompson's law been taken to the Supreme Court, and had it decided to hear the case, it would have ruled it unconstitutional.

Just like Yee's law.

 

Andrew Eisen

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

My point (which everyone seemed to miss) is Jack's got brushed aside just being looked over.

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

No it didn't.  It wasn't appealed to the Supreme Court so it didn't get brushed aside.

Unless you're suggesting that the fact that it wasn't is a poor reflection on Thompson which I just don't see at all.

 

Andrew Eisen

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

I know that anti-gamers like Yee are going to have a much harder time with their antics than before, and I am happy about that, but let's face it, we can't defeat the tidal wave. Nothing has ever been able to put a dent in the sheer number of politicians willing to waste millions of dollars in their efforts not only to stay in power, but to ascend in power. Very few in government actually care about making a difference, if they did, they would all serve one term and be happy with that. We've had the wrong people in charge since probably before I was born, and they're going to be there until enough Americans growing a fucking brain, and a pair of balls, and kick all the damn politicians out.

I don't see that happening in my lifetime, because let's face it, too many Americans are spoiled and feel entitled to be stupid. I feel like quitting this damn country sometimes.

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

"I feel like quitting this damn country sometimes."

 

I know how frustration can build enough to produce feelings like that.  The problem is when you look around and wonder "where is there to go?" .

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

Canada.

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

I believe Canada does allow regulation of video game violence do they not?

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

Not yet, but with Harper, it might be a matter of week...

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

Scandinavia.

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

how are their free speech protections there?  I know many European countries (England, Germany, Switzerland, etc.) appear to have fewer free speech protections (I'm not implying they are draconian fascist regimes either, before people get hackles up, just saying some level of regulation/censorship is permitted there, where it would not be in the US).

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

Vampires have all the rights! Especially to say "Blood"!

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

I doubt Yee will be able to cobble together enough support to try this again anytime soon.

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

With a big lose at SCOTUS it will probably be difficult.  Some political momentum would have been lost.  Any such law would now clearly need to pass strict scrutiny which the justices said the research on this issue can't do.

Although I certainly wouldn't put it past him to try...

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

At first glance I thought the headline said Yee was like "syphilis".  I guess that's applicable too.

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

That's what I thought too, except that he misspelled the title when posting it.

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

I also read it as syphilis.

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

Thank goodness I wasn't the only one x_X

Hunting the shadows of the troubled dreams.

Hunting the shadows of the troubled dreams.

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

XD I read it as he likes syphilis. 

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

Ditto!

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

Honestly, that was how I read it the first time. Strange how Freudianism works.

E. Zachary Knight
Divine Knight Gaming

Re: George A. Rose: Leland Yee Like Sisyphus

"It’s time for Sen. Yee to let go of the joystick and declare game over."

I think Yee's hand goes right for his joystick everytime he thinks about banning games...ugh! Yee's still studying how to warp and twist politics in order to pass another law, rather than studying FACTS like these, and using OUR money to do it!

KNOCK IT OFF! You attempt to take our Freedom, attack our parenting, and usurp our budget!

 
Forgot your password?
Username :
Password :

Poll

Will Target Australia sell the next GTA game upon its release?:

Shout box

You're not permitted to post shouts.
MattsworknameOn the subject of movies and video games, if you haven't seen it and your a street fighter fan, run down a copy fo Street fighter assassins fist. Its the best video game movie made, and its by a small studio07/30/2015 - 5:37am
Goth_SkunkSee, i didn't enjoy the Transformers films, but I don't really know why. I watched them for the sake of watching them, but I doubt I'd ever have a craving to watch them again. With Pixels, I would.07/30/2015 - 5:12am
Sora-ChanOn topics of movies in general: I usually find the argument of "shut down your brain and enjoy the movie" argument to be annoying. It was something that I was told to do when it came to the transformer movies from Bay, and it irked me when people said it.07/30/2015 - 5:03am
Goth_SkunkI did. And I didn't care much for it, but it was the reason I went and saw the film. The entire thing can be summed up in one sentence: "I didn't like it! If you pay to watch this movie, you're a big smelly poopy-head!"07/30/2015 - 4:56am
MattsworknameI think everyone here has Crono, we just don't agree with him or how he handles himself or his reviews, but thats us07/30/2015 - 4:55am
CronosonicThere are far worse problems Moviebob pointed out about Pixels than it not being 'serious'. Did you even /watch/ his review?07/30/2015 - 4:35am
MattsworknameAlso, newbusters verison. http://newsbusters.org/blogs/nb/tom-blumer/2015/07/29/venezuela-orders-food-producers-divert-output-empty-state-stores07/30/2015 - 4:25am
MattsworknameNot game related, but wow, Were are all those people who sand the praises of venezula now http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/L/LT_VENEZUELA_FOOD_SHORTAGES?SITE=AP&SECTION=HOME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT07/30/2015 - 4:25am
Goth_Skunk... is one you can acknowledge, then you'll enjoy it.If you CAN'T acknowledge such a mindset, then you must be MovieBob. Welcome to GP. :^)07/30/2015 - 4:13am
Goth_SkunkIf you watch Pixels expecting it to be Film Of The Year, or if you expect a Best Actor performance from Adam Sandler, then yes, you will be disappointed. If the idea that a film can simply be fun and entertaining without needing to be serious...07/30/2015 - 4:12am
MattsworknameIm kinda torn goth, on one hand , the effects look cool, but im not sold on sandler as the star07/30/2015 - 3:54am
Goth_SkunkBut did the film specfically take elements of Space Invaders and dedicate scenes and acts to it? No, they didn't.07/30/2015 - 3:49am
Goth_SkunkThe whole film is kinda centered around a Space Invaders theory.07/30/2015 - 3:49am
MattsworknameInfo: What dictionary says and what people today use that word for are not the same07/30/2015 - 3:30am
Sora-ChanPixels was a movie I was interested in for a week. A week after it got announced it was announced Sandler was in it and i went "... naw"07/30/2015 - 3:13am
Infophile@Goth: Apparently you're in the minority, from what reviews I've seen. Haven't seen it myself though, so I can't say how valid the reviews are. One question: Did they do Space Invaders at any point?07/30/2015 - 3:05am
Goth_SkunkJust came back from Pixels. Loved it. I knew I would.07/30/2015 - 2:33am
InfophileFor reference, see https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/accountable - It just means you have to answer for it. It has nothing to do with being punished for it.07/30/2015 - 1:47am
Mattsworknameohh, gods that game is pretty, just not my style these days07/29/2015 - 11:49pm
Andrew EisenUbisoft's Child of Light.07/29/2015 - 11:45pm
 

Be Heard - Contact Your Politician