Judge Rules Louisiana Shooting Was an ‘Accident,’ Boy Thought Gun Was a ‘Toy’

While the media immediately jumped to the conclusion that an 8-year-old boy who shot his elderly grandmother was somehow motivated by playing Grand Theft Auto, it looks like they were completely and utterly wrong. What police initially called a "homicide" has been ruled an accidental shooting, according to the Huffington Post.

A Louisiana judge ruled Monday that the boy will remain with his parents, though he did say that the court was still trying to determine how to help the family after this tragic accident.

On whether the shooting was a homicide or an accident, the judge said that it was definitely an unfortunate tragedy.

"It's not a crime if he's under 10 years old. We're still trying to figure out how to help this juvenile and his parents," said East Feliciana Parish District Attorney Samuel D'Aquilla. "It was determined that he did the shooting and it was an accident. He thought it was a toy gun, a play gun."

The shooting took place in a mobile home near Slaughter, LA., last Thursday. Smothers had been watching TV and caring for the boy, who was playing video games right behind her (we assumed that this trailer was small, given the types of trailers in the park – the kind you tow behind a vehicle). At some point during the day, the eight-year-old picked up a .38-caliber handgun and shot Smothers from about four feet away.

According to reports, the boy has been handed back and forth between the parents and his grandmother. Law enforcement officials have said that he and Smothers had a "normal, loving relationship."

Source: Huffington Post

Tweet about this on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on Google+Share on RedditEmail this to someone


  1. 0
    Craig R. says:

    But without video games to blame what will some law enforcement officers and members of the media be able to sensationalize now!?

    I mean, it's not like it's a big effing deal that an 8 year old found a loaded gun and killed somebody with it or anything…

  2. 0
    Infophile says:

    The same reason anyone has a gun in an easily-accessible place: For protection. The harder it is to get at, the harder it is to use to protect yourself in an emergency. What this scenario highlights, however, is that simply owning a gun puts you in danger from it. This isn't an isolated case, either. The statistics bear out that people who own guns are far more likely to be shot than people who don't own guns, controlling for other factors.

  3. 0
    Thomas Riordan says:

    An accident? Thought it was a toy gun? This judge was obviously bribed by the evil video game corporations.cheeky

    This really begs the question of why anyone would have a loaded gun where a child could get it in such a small space. Especially when in the position of caring for a child.

  4. 0
    quiknkold says:

    I am so glad the comments on stories related to this are more about the loaded gun and less about the game. Thats the important fact. Had the kid owned a nerf gun, we would not be having this discussion. 

    Parents : If you own guns, and want your kids to be comfortable around them. Dont leave them out loaded. BUy your kids Nerf. Its Nerf or Nothing. 

Leave a Reply