NSA ‘Would Welcome’ Public Advocate in FISA Court

Outgoing National Security Agency deputy director John C. Inglis tells National Public Radio that the spy agency would welcome the creation of a public advocate position to take part in Foreign Intelligence Surveillance (FISA) Court deliberations as a check against NSA requests. Inglis, who is retiring after being the number 2 man in the agency for seven years says that an advocate for the constitutionality of requests to be included would be fine as long as it doesn't impede the expediency of the NSA's activities.

"So, let's say that I'm authorized to target the head of al-Qaida worldwide and I'm actively doing that," he continued. "I'm trying to figure out what communication services — selectors — that person is using. If at every moment in time somebody had to authorize me to put the next selector on — 'He just changed his email address, can I put that on?' — if that's where the advocate stands in, that's operationally not terribly efficient."

"But if there's going to be some novel interpretation of the law — if there's going to be some authority that's going to be applied as an extension of the law [that] might say, 'I've got a different view,' we'd welcome that."

The NSA would also be okay with a public advocate's presence in the room each time it seeks a warrant, according to Inglis – if the process can be made "operationally efficient." The creation of a public advocate position was one of the recommendations that came out of the President's Review Group on Intelligence and Communications Technologies. The recommendations followed former NSA contractor Edward Snowden's leaks about the agency's surveillance programs.

Inglis did not dispute an estimate that the agency had examined electronic communications more than 44 million times in 2012, but he did say that this fact does not mean the NSA spied on 44 million people, since many targets of surveillance use multiple phone numbers or email accounts, which the agency examines multiple times.

"A particular terrorist might have dozens … hundreds of these selectors," he said.

You can check out a transcript of the Inglis interview on NPR.

Tweet about this on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on Google+Share on RedditEmail this to someone


  1. 0
    jedidethfreak says:

    The NSA is governed by the President exactly the same way as the CIA is.  That's why this has had major pushback on President Obama, despite the program starting under Clinton – the President had been briefed on the domestic spying program in 2010, and therefore knew about all of this beforehand, and did nothing about it (despite his overtures to the public that he was going to "reign in" this type of behavior).

  2. 0
    Sora-Chan says:

    last checked, the president's administration doesn't really have much control over what the NSA does. Many are probably in the dark of the NSA's activities, or atleast was, till recently.

    ╔╦═╣Signature Statement╠═╦╗

    If you don't like something I said in a post, don't just hit the dislike, let me know your thoughts! I'm interested in knowing everyone's opinions, even when they don't mesh with my own.

    Night Theme for GP: https://userstyles.org/styles/119449/

  3. 0
    prh99 says:


    …fine as long as it doesn't impede the expediency of the NSA's activities.

    In other words as long as it does not interfere with the FISA Court continuing to rubber stamping their requests.  I am sure they and Obama Administration will do everything to make sure the position is as weak as possible.

Leave a Reply