Submitted by NovaBlack - April 30, 2008 at 6:36 am -0500172.202.90.67
ugh.. seriously.. here we go again *sigh*
Just because YOU dont understand something doesnt mean it isnt of value. I actually am finding GTAIV VERY artistic, well put together with a fantastic and emotional narrative.
Its not all about 'ooh lookz i can chop off headses, ohh blood, lets kill people, yay'
TO me its actually on the same kind of artistic level as scarface / goodfellas / godfather.
And as far as ''Where earlier generations of youthful art crossed boundaries… they also affirmed something else, some alternative or countercultural value…'' goes..
who are YOU to judge wether it has some cultural value. You even JUST SAID you are from a different generation and hence different culture to the younger generation. So how can you decide if it has value or not.
I see the game as an excellent commentary on the corruption of wealth / power etc and the fact that no matter how big you are, theres always someone bigger/badder/better just around the corner. About how shallow material wealth actually is in the end. And for me, thats a good lesson.
Anyone else played the game and noticed the excellent social commentary on America especially with regard to the constant satire on the radio stations regarding Terrorism, the threat of terror, intolerance/fear of other religions, and (on the tv) a really funny cartoon mocking Americas invasion of other countries that have nothing to do with them in pursuit of resources and money. (albeit with another halo / alien skit interweaved)
Posted 07/23/08 at 10:13pm GRIZZAM PRIME: Lunatic: Nope. Ever fading if I'm not mistaken.
Posted 07/23/08 at 08:05pm LuNaTiC: is there a way to view old shouts? sorry if its a noob question.
Posted 07/23/08 at 07:07pm gamepolitics: momma didn't raise no sock puppet
Posted 07/23/08 at 06:15pm Rodrigo Ybáñez García: Jack is a repressed man. Don´t be surprised...
Posted 07/23/08 at 06:07pm GryphonOsiris: So Jack admitted paying for gay porn... all I can say is wow... just wow...
Posted 07/23/08 at 05:09pm lumi: to the case, and he's been on 60 minutes once!
Posted 07/23/08 at 05:09pm lumi: GP, you should mention you'll be filing a legal injunction against him if he doesn't comply. Phoenix Wright will be attached
Posted 07/23/08 at 03:32pm Alteffor: You should add a section to the site for anything Jack CC's to you. It's always entertaining to read the stuff he writes.
Posted 07/23/08 at 03:31pm Matriculated: Does anyone know when the Supreme Court reaches their decission?
Posted 07/23/08 at 03:04pm Freyar: I demand to see this letter! (Not that I have any grounds to demand on.)
Posted 07/23/08 at 02:53pm gamepolitics: JT called me a "sock puppet" in an e-mail to Hal Halpin... i gave him 24 hours to retract it, LOL
Posted 07/23/08 at 02:46pm Haggard: Might want to take a look at what Anthony Horowitz wrote about GTA IV in the Telegraph, article seems to have been taken down
Posted 07/23/08 at 01:05pm Silencets: Beutiful. I always did wonder about Jacko Wacko
Posted 07/23/08 at 10:24am Matriculated: So Jack (an anti-gay activist) PAYED for gay porn
Posted 07/23/08 at 10:22am Matriculated: [i]...and purchased membership.[/i]
Posted 07/23/08 at 10:21am Matriculated: [i] few months later, as part of his ongoing campaign against Kent, Thompson followed links to gay porn on Kent's website[/i]
Posted 07/23/08 at 07:40am sortableturnip: Jack's at it again: http://blogs.miaminewtimes.com/riptide/2008/07/jack_thompson_faces_permanent.php
Posted 07/22/08 at 11:22pm PHOENIXZERO: Ugh, that CNBC program "Play to Win" is it? Is on again...
Posted 07/22/08 at 09:34pm ZippyDSM: todayin zippy land:after spending 8 hours working on my AC unit yesterday it finally died today. theres go 300$ I don't have...tin trailers are ovens in the summer >>
Posted 07/22/08 at 09:17pm Cheater87: http://www.gameplanet.co.nz/news/132121.20080723.Saints-Row-2-uncensored-in-Australia/
Just because YOU dont understand something doesnt mean it isnt of value. I actually am finding GTAIV VERY artistic, well put together with a fantastic and emotional narrative.
Its not all about 'ooh lookz i can chop off headses, ohh blood, lets kill people, yay'
TO me its actually on the same kind of artistic level as scarface / goodfellas / godfather.
And as far as ''Where earlier generations of youthful art crossed boundaries… they also affirmed something else, some alternative or countercultural value…'' goes..
who are YOU to judge wether it has some cultural value. You even JUST SAID you are from a different generation and hence different culture to the younger generation. So how can you decide if it has value or not.
I see the game as an excellent commentary on the corruption of wealth / power etc and the fact that no matter how big you are, theres always someone bigger/badder/better just around the corner. About how shallow material wealth actually is in the end. And for me, thats a good lesson.
Anyone else played the game and noticed the excellent social commentary on America especially with regard to the constant satire on the radio stations regarding Terrorism, the threat of terror, intolerance/fear of other religions, and (on the tv) a really funny cartoon mocking Americas invasion of other countries that have nothing to do with them in pursuit of resources and money. (albeit with another halo / alien skit interweaved)